« House Training: Waxman Threatens Blue Dogs with Rolled-Up Newspaper | eades's Blog | GOP: The Party of Ignorance and Fear »

Iranian Pro-Government Academic Tells CNN He Is Not "The Mouth of Sauron"


Seyed Mohammad Marandi, a professor of English literature and North American Studies at the University of Tehran known for his pro-government views, was subjected to a bruising interview July 26 by Fareed Zakaria on CNN's GPS. Professor Marandi did an admirable job of maintaining his composure as Zakaria hammered him with questions and counterpoints on the respective roles of the regime, the opposition, and the international community in the current Iranian crisis, warmly smiling throughout the interview as pictured here and addressing Zakaria amicably by his first name. At the conclusion of the interview, Zakaria asked Marandi how he felt about the possibility that history might one day regard him as the smooth-talking "mouthpiece" of a doomed dictatorship. In his response, Marandi said he believed this would not be the case despite efforts by Americans including Zakaria to portray him as "the mouth of Sauron."

With this statement J.R.R. Tolkien's tales of Middle-Earth entered the contemporary debate on U.S.-Iranian relations, suggesting that to American eyes Iran appears as something like the land of Mordor ("where the shadows lie"), that Iranian rulers such as Khamenei or Ahmadinejad appear to us as something like the dark lord Sauron, and that we appear to ourselves as some cross between the Coalition of the Willing and the Fellowship of the Ring. Our president would thus be cast as Frodobama, attempting to destroy the Ring of [Iranian nuclear and theocratic] Power in the very fires of Mordor from which it was forged. Wow!

From an Iranian professor of English literature who studied in England and wrote his PhD dissertation on Lord Byron - poet of the Romantic era by which Tolkien's own work was influenced - such is at least a mildly thought-provoking suggestion, especially for those of us with similar interests in English literature. While I disagree with his support for the recent actions of the Iranian regime, I obviously found his cultural reference to Tolkien as a metaphor for the American view on contemporary U.S-Iranian relations compelling enough to spend half an hour blogging on it. I must confess I'm especially intrigued by the thought of a hobbit-hero named Frodobama Hussein Baggins. Perhaps I just don't have enough to do.

(As for characters in addition to Frodobama, I'm thinking Ted Kennedy as Gandalf the Grey; Joe Biden as Frodobama's loyal but gaffe-prone companion Samwise Gamgee; Hillary Clinton as a female version of the nimble elf Legolas; and the unwillingly self-cast Professor Marandi as Saruman, "the mouth of Sauron." American neocon Daniel Pipes, who rooted for Ahmadinejad in the recent Iranian election for the sake of further conflict, would in my opinion be very well cast as the creature Gollum. Any further or different suggestions are most welcome. Little if any attempt at serious political analysis here - just a bit of silly fun on a lazy Sunday afternoon.)

Mark C. Eades
http://www.mceades.com


12 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

So, eades, you have convinced us that the metaphor is compelling. But is it appropriate?

Perhaps your self-assessment is correct, and you do not have enough to do. How about expanding just a little on the implications and accuracy of the Sauron/Iran leadership analogy.

Carey Rowland, author of Glass half-Full, http://www.careyrowland.com

user-pic

Frodobama?

=D

Daniel Pipes as Gollum does have possibilities... I think you nailed Samwise/Biden.

Suggestions?

Gimli the Dwarf: Dennis Kucinich

Wormtail: Dick Cheney

user-pic

"Wormtail"??? Do you mean Grima Wormtongue?

This thread is PAINFUL to a Tolkien Fan. ... must. flee.

user-pic

Mixing J.R.R Tolkien with J.K. Rowling I guess. And, what's interesting, is that both characters were quite similar--the talking out of both sides of their mouths kind of characters. I'm curious if Rowling's Wormtail was an homage to Wormtongue.

But you're right about Saruman. The mouth was actually trying to become the resident of Isengard, replacing Saruman (unlike the movie, Tolkien's Saruman wasn't wholeheartedly for Sauron--he wanted that ring for himself. He betrayed both Gandalf and Sauron).

Uh oh, I've gone nerd. Before long I'll be talking in Elvish.

user-pic

First time I actually sat through a Zakaria interview. Straight out called him a liar on the US supplies of chemical weapons to Iraq. Wow. I mean, the claim isn't straightforwardly true - just dual-use, chemical precurser stuff. But still. Wow. Does Zakaria get crazy belligerent with other people? Just asking.

user-pic

Not that ive seen. GPS is the only Sunday show i can stand watching. One of the reasons why Zakaria might have been more confrotational with this guy is that one of his friends who was on GPS a week or two before being arrested in Iran was forced to do a false confession. From Wikipedia: "On 30 June, he was presented by Iranian authorities at a press conference, where he described Western journalists as spies, stated that he had covered "illegal demonstrations", and confessed to helping promote a "colour revolution""

He was arrested over a month ago and for all we know is still in jail.

When the, The Daily Show was taping their Iran segments before the elections in Iran they interviewed him as well.
http://www.thedailyshow.com/watch/mon-june-22-2009/jason-jones--behind-the-veil---persians-of-interest

So its understandable that Zakaria wasn't the most friendly of people with him. And the guy who was pretty much lying about whats going on in Iran the entire time.

user-pic

Thanks for the info, musgrove. Yes I saw the Jones pieces. Very tragic in hindsight...

user-pic

read some of the post from this person, http://twitter.com/persiankiwi

user-pic

Right --you do not have enough to do!!!...Amusing but relevant?

We are compelled to be concerned about the Iranian people because we have been cut off from information and the Govn't has killed reportedly hundreds and we have no info on the detainees...

user-pic

This is a totally geeky point, but there is no way that Obama could be the equivalent to Frodo. Do we really imagine that Obama is going to be performing a personal mission behind the lines in Iraq to blow up Natanz with the gaffe-prone Biden in tow?

Ted Kennedy as Gandalf? How does that even make sense? And WTF! The "mouth of Sauron" was a The Lieutenant of the Tower of Barad-dûr, not Saruman!

Maybe read the books before we play this game.

user-pic

I wonder who is Boromir?

user-pic

From the transcript, Zakaria "sounds like" an interviewer on FOX.

http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0907/26/fzgps.01.html

If Farid's friend was arrested, perhaps he should have mentioned that fact. It would have provided a more dramatic, concrete illustration of the situation in Iran.

Leave a comment

eades

user-pic

Following:
Followers: 25

Posts
Comments & Recommends


Favorites

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address