Canadian Health Care: Myths vs. Facts
In a previous post I explained the basics of Canadian health care , and I pointed out that the highest rate is only $108 for a family of three or more. Those with limited income get their insurance virtually free, just like American members of Congress do. Yes, those same elected nimrods who bash Universal Health Care are receiving essentially the same thing.
Senators and Congressmen get to participate in the Federal Employees Health Benefits Program(FEHB). This is low cost (but good) insurance and taxpayers pay two thirds of the premiums. FEHB insurance does not deny claims because of pre-existing conditions, just like Canada's Health Care system.
Former President Bill Clinton has been a very vocal supporter of Canada's system. He knows America's system as well as any American, and he knows a lot about the Canadian system. Clinton notes that in the U.S. today, there are "incentives to keep people misinformed and full of fear."
The main tactic used by lobbyists is to take isolated incidents of poor health care delivery and misrepresent these rare incidents as if they were standard operating procedure in Canada. Sure, examples of medical malpractice and improper diagnosis can be found on both sides of the border, but malpractice is not the norm in Canada or the USA.
The Canadian System provides for universal coverage for medically necessary health care services provided on the basis of need, rather than the ability to pay. In practical terms "universal coverage" means you get the services and care you need, but doctors bills and hospital bills are unheard of in Canada. I visit my family doctor every three months for medication refills, and to discuss any health concerns. These visits are free just like major surgeries and specialist appointments are free. "Ability to pay" is never a concern in Canada.
Any time (24/7/365) I have a health related concern I can dial 8-1-1 and speak with an experienced nurse or a pharmacist. The nurse will decide if I can treat the problem myself, or if I should see my family doctor or go to the emergency room.
The only time I used that service was when I had a swelling spider bite on my foot. I was driving home and the nurse told me it was potentially serious. "Go to the Emergency Room and have it looked at right away." As always the emergency room visit cost me nothing, and the prompt treatment probably saved me from getting a skin graft.
THE "WAITING LIST" STRAW MAN ARGUMENT
Yes, Canada does have waiting lists for some procedures, but...
...1. Nobody ever goes on a waiting list for emergency care. Heart surgeries, Cancer treatments, etc all take place immediately.
2. We have some waiting lists for some non-emergency procedures such as knee replacements, MRI scans, etc but wait times are not ridiculous and they are well prioritized. The big difference between Canada and the USA is Canadians will always get the procedure. ALWAYS. So what if they have to wait. It's not a perfect world.
3. In America I saw people die of Cancer with no treatment, because
they were poor. I also knew several people who walked around on painful
knees and hips because they could not afford the arthroscopy or joint
replacement. I am certain they would have been delighted to get on a
waiting list for a free joint replacement.
4. Rich Canadians can "jump the queue" and pay for non-emergency MRI's or surgeries if they wish. Personally, I would prefer to use a cane for a few months (just like Dr. House) and get my knee replaced for free.
Are Canadians really being "forced" to get treatment in the USA?
No. Sometimes the specialists and surgeons are backed up, or staffing shortages occur. In a small number of cases Canadian patients get sent south of our border when it is best for the patient. Complicated pregnancies requiring a certain hospital to do the delivery, and rare diseases where the best expert is in the USA are two examples, However - when this happens - it is all at the Canadian Governments expense. Travel(Ambulance or Air Ambulance) and treatment are all paid for 100% by the Government, not the patient.
How many Americans get to travel to Canada when the top specialist is in our country, and have it paid for by the American Government? Sending patients to the USA for teatment, when appropriate, is a good thing not a bad thing.
Overall President Clinton is on the right track, and he surely has President Obama in his corner. Both men know that America's system is immoral and embarrassing when compared to all established Western democracies.
Universal Health Care, regardless of ability to pay, is the only way to go. I look forward to the day when my American friends can enjoy the Universal Health Care I take for granted.











