Crimmigration

Immigrant rights groups are disappointed in President Obama and Janet Napolitano for strengthening the 287(g) program, which gives local police and sheriffs authority to enforce immigration law. Critics charge that 287(g) enables self-selected racial profiling of anyone that looks or acts like an immigrant (wearing brown skin), and demean the practices as Crimmigration or Catch and Release.
Amy Goodman interviews two critics (video and transcript):
Our understanding, those of us who were watching Obama and had hopes in Obama, was that, under Obama, programs like 287(g) would be terminated, because they are driven off of a desire for racial profiling. Officers that want to be able to have the power to pick up Latinos, brown people, while driving, these are the self-selecting group of people that joined to 287(g). And unfortunately, two weeks ago, Napolitano gave us our first really blatant betrayal when she decided not only not to suspend 287(g), but to expand it around the country.
Notably, she gave this program--she reinitiated the contract with Joe Arpaio of Maricopa County, Arizona. Mind you, Joe Arpaio is currently under federal investigation. The Department of Justice, Eric Holder is investigating his use of the program. Meanwhile, Napolitano is going ahead and handing it off to him.
...
There was another anecdote last night about a guy in Morristown, actually a white guy who loves bachata music. He was saying that "I was driving in my convertible the other day, top down, listening to my bachata. The police stopped me." They don't even have 287(g) yet. "The police stopped me and said in Spanish, 'Give me your driver's license.' And they spoke worse Spanish than me, and I responded in Spanish, as a white guy, 'I don't even'--you know, I gave them the driver's license, responded in Spanish, and it was so clear that they assumed that I was Latino, because I don't have blue eyes, because I'm Italian American."
The Heritage Foundation supports strengthening of 287(g):
Section 287(g) Is the Right Answer for State and Local Immigration Enforcement
A §287(g) pilot program with the State of Florida could serve as a national model. Florida specifically limits its officers' civil immigration enforcement to situations in which they are part of a security or counterterrorism operation that is supervised by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officers. The Florida program outlines the criteria for selecting the participating officers, including U.S. citizenship, three years of law enforcement experience, and at least an associate's degree. Selected officers receive intensive training and must pass a final competency exam. The program also establishes ways for people to file grievances against the program and its officers. The Florida initiative demonstrates how to craft a program that meets federal as well as state and local needs.
But researchers at the UNC School of Law Immigration and Human Rights Clinic echo the criticisms:
The team of law students, led by ... lawyers with the ACLU in North Carolina Legal Foundation, released a report on the 287(g) program in North Carolina titled The Policies and Politics of Local Immigration Enforcement Law on Feb. 18.
According to the report, one of the unexpected and problematic outcomes of the law is reluctance among immigrants to contact police if they are victims or witnesses of crimes because of the risk of being jailed or deported themselves. Additionally, there are growing concerns that law enforcement officers are targeting Hispanic-appearing individuals for minor traffic offenses.
...
After an extensive review of the program and data from partner organizations, the federal government, and community interviews, they have produced a 152-page report on the program detailing its weaknesses and proposing solutions, including greater transparency and a functional system for complaints or appeals.
When I was in high school, it was explained to me that there was no corresponding agency to the KGB in the United States. Perhaps combining the CIA, FBI, Secret Service, State Police and Coast Guard would be similar to the KGB, I was told. With some 500,000 persons, KGB combined foreign espionage, internal political espionage, surveillance of the armed forces, internal security, surveillance of foreigners and suspicious citizens, monitoring foreign communications (including code-breaking), protecting party members and their families and border security.
So now I see the US combining Homeland Security, Immigration and local police and sheriffs, and operating extensive prisons for citizens and aliens alike, and I wonder who won the cold war, ... or the last election.













