« To Have and Have Not | Donal's Blog | Leftovers »

Oil is not Gasoline - update 2


Writing for ASPO, Tom Whipple reports:

Oil prices opened and closed the week around $68 a barrel. At one point they fell below $65 on news of a build in US crude stocks and later touched a high of over $70 on hopes that US unemployment was bottoming out. Oil's connection to the dollar, equity markets, and hopes for an economic recovery remains strong.

Demand for oil remains weak, with US consumption of petroleum products falling to 17.7 million b/d, the lowest since May 1999. While gasoline demand this year has been relatively strong, distillate consumption, which is largely used for industrial purposes in the summer months, is down by nearly nine percent. Distillate stocks continue to grow and are now 34 percent higher than last year. In the meantime, OPEC production continues to creep back up as exporters take advantage of higher prices to ease their recent financial problems.

An oversupply of distillates in the US can be reduced through exports, provided world demand holds up, or they can be stored provided there is enough space. In the last two months, oil stored on tankers has jumped by 71 percent. Some distillate is now being held aboard newly built tankers that have not yet been used for crude.

As the article notes, demand for oil is weak, while demand for gasoline is strong. So why doesn't strong demand for gasoline create just as strong a demand for oil?

Because in normal refining, a given ratio of several products must come out of a barrel of oil: gasoline and perhaps diesel, heating oil, kerosene, aviation fuel, lpg or even asphalt are produced. Gasoline is a blend of distillates and non-distillates, so oil guys tend to say "distillates" to mean heating oil and diesel. If demand for the distillates is low, then refiners must either refine less oil or find storage for heating oil and diesel they can't sell. Cutting back on refining will make gasoline scarcer, hence more expensive.

Update 1: Matt Savinar raised an interesting point on LATOC:

Also, many of your friends ... are probably asking "if the oil inventories are high then why are the prices soaring." Keep in mind there is a bottleneck in many of the refineries ... An increasing amount of the oil in "inventory" is heavy oil. Most of the currently operating refineries were built to handle the light sweet varieties and retrofitting them to handle the heavier varieties of oil is extremely capital intensive. With the credit markets locked up at a time when oil prices have plunged in the last year, companies can't get the loans needed to overhaul their refineries to handle the heavy stuff.

Hard to believe oil refiners can't get credit.

Update 2: Wall Street Journal June 10 2009

Although gasoline demand may be rising, refiners cut back on production of other fuels last week, operating at 85.9% of capacity, down 0.4 percentage point. Gasoline inventories fell by 1.6 million barrels, compared with a forecast for an 800,000-barrel increase. Distillate stocks, including heating oil and diesel, fell 300,000 barrels, where analysts had expected a 1.5-million-barrel gain.


21 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

And refining capacity is currently one of the bottlenecks in the US gasoline (and other petroleum product) supply chain.

It's going to get a bit more complicated, I suspect, once the "summer driving season" ramps up fully. And we all remember that the gas price crunch last year was a contributing factor to a series of larger economic - and thus social, difficulties. Not the only factor, to be sure, still, it had an impact.

user-pic

Hmmmm. So that's why the price of gas went up a dime every time I went by the gas station last week.

user-pic

good post, Donal, what about the rate of discovery of cheap oil? Cheap oil meaning not tar sands or any oil recovery or refining process that requires an energy input that is equal to or higher than energy output.

Demand for oil can go down and still be out of whack with supply, right?

user-pic

I haven't heard of any recent discovery that wasn't deepwater.

user-pic

Your answer didn't make sense.

"So why doesn't strong demand for gasoline create just as strong a demand for oil? "

The main difference is pipelining, as noted in the article (storage and refining, mostly). Strong demand for gasoline will eventually affect demand for oil. Of course gasoline is not the only oil product, but you say

"a given ratio of several products must come out of a barrel of oil"

and if we accept that, then to get more gas you must produce more of the other products. That means that prices of some oil-based products should go up and others down, since refining more gasoline to meet increased demand there will oversupply the other product fractions of the barrel.

user-pic
Strong demand for gasoline will eventually affect demand for oil.

It will instantly *affect* demand for oil, but as I wrote, the demand for oil won't be as strong as that for gasoline if there is a very slow market for distillate.

That means that prices of some oil-based products should go up and others down, since refining more gasoline to meet increased demand there will oversupply the other product fractions of the barrel.

It's more complicated than offsetting price corrections because, as Whipple notes, they're running out of storage for the overproduced distillates, even using pristine new oil tankers as storage instead of transport. Clearly it isn't worth taking the loss on distillates just to make more gasoline.

user-pic

"the demand for oil won't be as strong as that for gasoline if there is a very slow market for distillate."

That is what doesn't make sense, if the fraction of a barrel which goes to gasoline is more or less fixed per your "given". The demand for oil is of course not limited to the demand for gasoline, but that's obvious if it's your only point here.

I think you're muddling supply/demand issues with pricing issues. The open market price for "distillates" is not linked directly to refining, as you note, because of storage capacities on both the in and out sides of the refinery, what I called "pipelining". A refinery can keep the price high... for awhile, but eventually it runs out of storage space for the low-demand distillate and so it must cut prices to sell off its now excess inventories. On the "in" side, there are short term price disconnects because of forward contracts and storage of crude oil etc.

user-pic

Yes, I do "muddle" pricing with supply and demand:

The market price of a good is determined by both the supply and demand for it. In 1890, English economist Alfred Marshall published his work, Principles of Economics, which was one of the earlier writings on how both supply and demand interacted to determine price. Today, the supply-demand model is one of the fundamental concepts of economics. The price level of a good essentially is determined by the point at which quantity supplied equals quantity demanded.

http://www.netmba.com/econ/micro/supply-demand/

user-pic

Sometimes I muddle just for fun. I come from a long line of muddlers.

user-pic

:) Thanks for the information.
I was wondering about this.

user-pic

Hey Donal, a short lesson in economics. Goes down well for the less read, like myself.

Thank yo.

user-pic

I think that the mix of products from refining is variable, but not so easy to change. It is not as hard as changing the mix of automobile products coming out of assembly lines, but not easy.

Last year the distillate prices were abnormally high. The stuff is used as truck fuel, heating oil etc. Industrial consumers of heating oil can switch to other fuels, particularly to natural gas. Trucks can switch to natural gas as well.

But the largest difference probably is that the last year there was a shortage of distillate in China, and not so this year.

user-pic

Last year the Chinese needed lots of diesel for the earthquake rescue efforts, so we enjoyed lower prices from the surplus of gasoline being refined.

user-pic

But whither speculation?

user-pic

Speculation is responsible for any price changes you didn't anticipate.

user-pic

Like last winter/summer?

I want restitution.

user-pic

Or at least some breathing room? You're not the only one hurting:

As oil prices rose over $70 per barrel last week and Goldman Sachs raised its forecast for oil prices, the American Trucking Associations joined a coalition of trade associations asking Congress to rein in excessive speculation in the commodities markets.

Remember, since most of what we eat, drink, wear and dwell in is trucked, higher fuel prices mean higher prices for everything bought by everyone. And if that's not cautionary enough for you:

Clearly, it is necessary to dampen — with a firm policy stance — the growing speculative bubble in global oil prices. Now forward markets do have their purpose, vital as they are for proper price discovery and functional markets. But financial markets do have a tendency to go off on a tangent, and so proper supervision and norms are needed to curb runaway speculation... Urgent action is needed before it is too late.

As we know from late last summer, bubbles have that unfortunate tendency to... pop.

user-pic

OT: One of those classic memories that will be forever 'burned' in my mind was when my dad decided to burn a pile of wood. I think he often would put kerosene on it if it was wet to get it going. Well, this time for some reason he put gasoline on it. I'll never forget the huge fireball, the circular wave of fire racing over the ground where the fumes had traveled, and my dad siloetted against the orange, running like I've never seen anyone run.

He was fine. The fire didn't spread to the fields or woods. And now, years later, it's pretty damn funny.

user-pic

Heh, my dad did basically the same thing. Later my brother did the same thing and I felt the shock wave hit the tin roof of my cabin hundreds of yards away.

user-pic

lol, yeah, I forgot about the shock wave. And the heat against my face.

Wow, did your brother use a whole can? That's some shock wave!

user-pic

I think he saturated the pile then flicked a lit match.

Leave a comment

Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address