« Putting faces on hardship | Donal's Blog | Mayberry OMG »

Shared Streets


The picture above shows the urban space taken up by an equal number of single occupant automobiles, bus passengers and cyclists. For all you armchair urban theorists, Ped Shed’s Laurence Aurbach posts a three-parter about designing roads for better purposes than just driving faster and faster.

Towards a Functional Classification Replacement

In practice, functional classification results in three rigid postulates:

1: The longer the trip, the bigger the roadway 2: The bigger the roadway, the faster its traffic should travel 3: The faster the traffic on the roadway, the more isolated the roadway must be from its surroundings

The effect on transportation in America is obvious and immense: The large majority of traffic in urban areas is channeled into freeways and arterials.

Meanwhile in the U.S. a pitched battle for control of urban streets was underway. Today we assume that automobile domination was the uncontroversial result of mass auto ownership. But until the 1920s, every street in America was a “shared space” street, where all pedestrians had the right to use the roadway at any time or at any place they desired. Many, including police, safety officers and traffic engineers, fought to keep it that way by strictly limiting autos to nonlethal speeds. The opposition — auto, oil and road-building industries — spearheaded a movement to ban pedestrians and dedicate streets to ever-faster motor vehicle traffic.

The standard suburban arterial experience is long waits at a traffic signals, jack-rabbit races to next signal, followed by more long waits, repeated day after day. A better option is slower, more constant speeds. LaPlante (2008) points out that coordinated signals are easier to integrate into slow-speed networks and suggests that a 30 mph street with coordinated traffic signals can perform as well as a 45 mph street with stop and start movement.


17 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Bloomberg has just endorsed a major proposal in this regard for Broadway in Midtown Manhattan that the shared streets folks like: http://www.streetsblog.org/2009/02/26/a-bold-and-transformative-new-vision-for-broadway/

user-pic

A picture is worth something. Victoria wished to get rid of the manure and asked that no horses be allowed with London. Too tough on commerce they said.

Ban all cars, no one gets in or out except in a cab, on a bus or on the metro.

user-pic

I lived a large portion of my life in a tiny town of 800 people. I loved riding my bike around to get where I needed to go. Where I live now, riding a bicycle on the streets is a death wish. They are narrow and some have no shoulders. *sigh*

user-pic

Somewhere in our travels (and neither my husband or I can remember if it was here in the states or in the UK) we came upon a community where they had "community" bicycles. Some industrious group had, as a service project, gone to the dumps/landfills and otherwise solicited no-longer-wanted bicycles, refurbished them, painted them all alike, and made them available to the community at no charge, for people to use to get around town. You see one, you take it, use it and leave it wherever you end up for the next person who comes across it to use. Some of them got stolen, but they just kept rehabbing more...Seemed like a good idea to us!

user-pic

In the 80s, a Dutch coworker told me about White Bikes in the Netherlands, but wiki has a report that says it wasn't that extensive.

user-pic

Yeah, I checked wiki to see if I could find anything on the community we visited, but couldn't find anything...I remember the bikes being yellow, but for the life of me can't remember where we were when we saw them...

user-pic

Dave Matthews (of the Dave Matthews Band) helped to start that here in Charlottesville. I donated 3 bikes myself. Each bike was checked, oiled, etc, and painted bright yellow.

Unfortunately they were all stolen. Tried again. Same thing.

In Barcelona they have bikes like that, but everyone has to pay a small amount per month and use a card to check one out and then back in. It is a great system and if I knew how to put in pictures I have a great one of the bikes all lined up. Only citizens could use them; not for tourists.

user-pic

This "stealing" crap is one of my major hot buttons, and for the life of me I don't have a solution to it that would be acceptable in a civilized society. I, personally, go for the 1st time offender being forced to watch a video of someone getting their hand chopped off, with a warning that you will get that next time...then for a 2nd offense having your non-dominant hand chopped off, and for 3rd, your other hand.

Why is stealing so damn acceptable?

user-pic

This is a wonderful blog! And again, I note how Donal not only uses a bike but transports hay that way!

It would be interesting to look at how people are housed. How many folks in these mcmansions versus ... well, whatever. And how many barrels of oil to heat various sizes. And so on.

Images are so powerful!

user-pic

SHARE THE ROAD!!!!!

Donal, love the picts you've loaded. Can you enlighten, how do you load picts? When I try it, it never works.

user-pic


One more, since TPM won't let me load three at the same time.

user-pic

When posting with pix, you have to choose one of the html formats instead of rich text format. I use Markdown with Smarty Pants, but I imagine that Markdown would work just as well.

If your image location is http://www.photo.com\image01.jpg

Add IMG SRC=" in front and " at the end, and enclose with html brackets. You can also add something like " Width=400 Height=300> at the end to change the size.

user-pic

Under "Leave a comment" I don't see any options for changing formats. It says you may use HTML tags for style, but doesn't give options for rich text. Any ideas? I have seen pictues in other comments; just don't know how to get there.

user-pic

I've never tried that.

user-pic

Donal, great post. I live in a town that was great for bike riding about 20 years ago but it is now downright scary. So what they decided to do was pass and enforce a law keeping bikes off the sidewalks. Having been on a bike in traffic and in a car behind a bike for several blocks it seems to me there needs to be more consideration on both sides. Of course I don't live in NY City and I don't understand why people even have cars in that city. Can you imagine a world where electic buses glide through the city along with bikes and skateboards? How quiet, how clean, what a dream!

user-pic

Portland,Oregon, here on the Left Coast, is taking into consideration a new traffic law to balance the responsibilities of road-users with the size of their vehicles, i.e. the bigger you are the greater your fines for traffic infractions.

http://bikeportland.org/2009/02/25/weight-based-traffic-fine-idea-will-have-to-wait/

I recall we tried that free-bike program a few years ago and people took the bikes too far and never returned them. Essentially, they all disappeared rather quickly.

Leave a comment

Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address