« Radioactive | Donal's Blog | Dear Diary »

Their own worst enemies (update3)


Pre-emptive ejection: Audience members removed at McCain rally in Cedar Falls

Lara Elborno, a student at the University of Iowa, said she was approached by a police officer and a McCain staffer and was told she had to leave or she would be arrested for trespassing.

“It was a very confusing, very frustrating situation,” Elborno said. “I said that I had a right to be there, I wasn’t doing anything disruptive — I was sitting, waiting for the rally to start.”

She said McCain staffers wouldn’t tell her why she was being asked to leave and when she got outside, she saw “a group of about 20 people” who had all been asked to leave.

“I saw a couple that had been escorted out and they were confused as well, and the girl was crying, so I said ‘Why are you crying? and she said ‘I already voted for McCain, I’m a Republican, and they said we had to leave because we didn’t look right,’” Elborno said. “They were handpicking these people and they had nothing to go off of, besides the way the people looked.”

Update 3: From the comments section of the Iowa State Daily:

Video interview of three UNI students asked to leave

Same students talk about another attendee that wasn’t made to leave

Margo Ralston 1 day 2 hrs ago

I am a UNI student and I was also one of the many that was asked to leave for no reason…they just told me that McCain staffers ask for me and the other two UNI students I was with to leave…no explanation. I have never protested at any McCain events and I was not doing anything but setting and watching the event peacefully. I also saw the republican girl crying as she was being kicked out…I feel as a student of UNI that was not being disruptive or has no past of being disruptive that I had a right to be there….the hole event was very disheartening.

Anne Johnson 12 hr 34 min ago

FYI, all.

I’m a 53-year-old library assistant and I was with Lara and the rest of the group that was coming to see McCain, and she didn’t make that up about the young Republican couple who were thrown out.

Update2: One DeusExMalcontent commenter thinks they were trying to avoid another Palin impersonation.

But another blogger thinks they went too far.

Update1: After posting the above, it was ironic to see the MSNBC headline, Do Republicans Have a Youth Problem?

Do Republicans have a youth problem?

A very ominous sign for the Republican Party is how Democratic-leaning these new and lapsed voters are. Not only do they back Obama by a 69%-27 margin, they also prefer a Democratic-controlled Congress by a 2-to-1 margin, 66%-31%. And their views of President Bush? His fav/unfav among these voters is 14%-73%. Ouch. While Karl Rove had ambitious hopes of turning Bush’s presidency into a permanent majority for the GOP, this poll suggests that Bush’s lasting legacy could actually be turning off a new generation of voters. After all, consider what young voters who came of voting age during the past seven years might associate the GOP with — the Iraq war, Hurricane Katrina, the current economy, various political scandals (Jack Abramoff, Ted Stevens, etc.), and Bush. Speaking of the president, the White House released his schedule from today until Sunday, and get this — the sitting president of the United States will not be campaigning in the final week of the campaign. Amazing. In fact, as NBC’s John Yang notes, Bush hasn’t made a single public campaign appearance with a GOP candidate this cycle. He has raised money for them, some $150 million this cycle. But that’s down from the $186 million he helped raise for the GOP in the 2006 cycle.


15 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

what's that old cliche' about "eating their own young..."

The Shakers have virtually disappeared because they did not consider children part of their process.

Maybe the Republicans will suffer a similar fate. Their third-party status is almost assured, if they continue to identify their future members as a threat.

I wonder if that young lady who voted for McCain would do so again, if she had the opportunity?

Bullies AND HYPOCRITES!

user-pic

This sort of looks like reporting, but it isn't.

Did "Donal" interview the police to determine if maybe they had a different opinion about what the innocent ejectees were doing or not doing?

Did "Donal" check to see whether the ejected Young Republican only seen by "Lara Elborno" actually existed?

Of course not!

That would be reporting, in contrast to brainless gossip-mongering.

user-pic

Er, Jacob, if you click the caption to the photo, it takes you to a MSM (minor-league version) report on the incident.
I'll have to discuss this with my sister - she works at UNI in Cedar Falls.

user-pic

"Er," I read the article, and there was no substantiation of Elborno's tearful and convenient "McCain supporter."

Yeah, I know it's "just" a blog, and the standards of real reporting aren't supposed to apply.

Right, ImpPaul?

But the hook in this story is the weeping Republican, and a real reporter would have looked for confirmation instead of accepting the report of someone with an obvious motive to lie at face value, especially when the "source" was an anti-McCain activist.

Donal just leaves out something rather significant about Elborno: "Elborno said while she has protested at events before, no plans were discussed beforehand for a protest..."

"Hey guys, let's all us neutral and innocent former protesters show up at a McCain rally, and if a protest happens... Who knew?"

Harharharhar!!!

By omitting Elborno's background, Donal has turned the original piece of sloppy reporting into blatant and clumsy propaganda.

His post is garbage.

user-pic

Considering the source, I'll take that as a compliment.

user-pic

Again, and I know I ask this all the time - Why is this not being reported on by MSM? Why aren't these people being interviewed?

Thanks for posting. Rec'd.

user-pic

"This is a job for SCAAMD!"
http://scaamd.org/

BTW, stop by the TPM chat tonight, during Obama's closing argument.

http://www.lingr.com/room/TPM-aholics/get_password

user-pic

Ahh yes the Republican party. Throw them a bone, and they, uh, kick you in the teeth. Ungrateful, hypocritical jerks.

user-pic
and the girl was crying, so I said ‘Why are you crying? and she said ‘I already voted for McCain, I’m a Republican

To be fair, there are lots of reasons why a Republican who voted for McCain would be crying.

But let's face it, would you expect a terrorist, socialist Muslim Obama plant to say anything else?

user-pic

Wait a minute - that woman in the foreground looks suspisciously like a Muslim. How come she got to stay?

user-pic

Until then she probably always believed that such things only happened to "other people."

user-pic

Maybe the reason all the McCain events are so small is because they only let in people who support him. That would definitely decrease the numbers.

user-pic

It's amazing the size of the chasm in youth voters. The potential is there for a progressive generation if we can enact policies following an unflinching progressive agenda. The potential is there to make a generational shift away from the idiocy (minus the Clinton years) that we've seen since 1980 in Presidential politics. Open the door and walk through it people, the opportunity has never been even dreamed of in a long while.

user-pic

Lara Elborno is a known trouble maker. McCain was just one step ahead of her and her goons. I applaud McCain for stopping this before it even started.

user-pic

Lara Elborno is a known trouble maker. McCain was just one step ahead of her and her goons. I applaud McCain for stopping this before it even started.

Leave a comment

Donal

user-pic

Following: 18
Followers: 29

Posts
Comments & Recommends


  • Website: www.donalfagan.com
  • Location Baltimore MD
  • Party Democratic
  • Politics Moderate Green

Favorites

  • Favorite Blogs Energy Bulletin, Casaubon's Book, Deus Ex Malcontent, dagblog
  • Favorite Books Large print

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address