« Rod Blagojevich, Performance Artist | Doctor Cleveland's Blog | The Opposition Party »

The Standards of Civility for Democrats


So, Andrew Sullivan has a round-up of the instantaneous reactions, mostly complaints, from right-wing bloggers about the Inaugural Address. There are some moments of gracious or grudging acknowledgment, but there's also carping on matters so small that in fact, they do not exist. One complaint, is that Obama, who campaigned against Bush's policies, should have given more praise to Bush and his policies. Why this might be so is beyond me. Perhaps I have forgotten the fulsome praise that FDR lavished upon Hoover, or Jefferson upon Adams.

At least a couple of bloggers, to wit Jennifer Rubin and Jay Nordlinger, take issue with Obama's thank-you to to Bush, which they view as insultingly brief. Rubin calls it "unduly perfunctory." Nordlinger calls it "the barest minimum: 'I thank him for his service,' or something." The idea seems to be that Obama rudely and pointedly truncated a gesture of thanks which one would normally expect  to be fuller.

For reference, what President Obama said during his Inaugural Address was this:

"I thank President Bush for his service to our nation, as well as the generosity and cooperation he has shown throughout this transition."

Apparently, this is much shorter and less classy than what George W. Bush said in his inaugural address in 2001:

 "As I begin, I thank President Clinton for his service to our nation."

That's it.

So, you see how classless Obama is: to give Bush (who leaves behind an economic meltdown, a massive deficit, and two unresolved wars) only slightly more praise than Bush gave his own predecessor (who left behind peace and a bidget surplus). But of course, from such pundits' perspective, Clinton was owed no praise, because Clinton "had no class" and Bush did. Meanwhile, Bush is entitled to more deference from the mere parvenu who succeeds him. It's not about what they say at all.

13 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

"only slightly more praise than Bush gave his own predecessor (who left behind peace and a bidget surplus)."

The lack of peace I can manage, but I do miss the bidgits. Rec'd

user-pic

One of the many wonders of the internet is that people can't rewrite history quite so easily...I love it when their hypocrisy can be pointed out so quickly.

And I say the bidgit surplus should come back to us. I need one...I think.

user-pic

And when Bush and his posse moved into the White House they falsely accused Clinton's crew of trashing the place. They lied from day one.

user-pic

Has there been an official report issued on the number of "O" keys missing on White House computer yet?

user-pic

I'm wagering "0"...

user-pic

Yes, sorry about that "bidget surplus" typo. I was typing from a keyboard which I'm falsely contending has had its W removed. That messes me up more than you'd think.

What I meant to write, of course, was "surplus of bidets." I never quite understood why Clinton prioritized them so much, but what works, works.

user-pic

Don't underestimate the importance of cleanliness, especially nether cleanliness. Keeps the mind clear.

user-pic

Good post. Read Bwak's post. Hand in Hand.

Is a bidget a short budget? Or a bitch of a widget?

user-pic

Wingnuts are very fragile emotionally. They spend their whole lives under the psychological bed.

Obama should have had Bush arrested right there at the start of the speech. That would have made an impression.

user-pic

I suspect President Obama sees Bu$h as a fish too small for the skillet to waste any effort on. Not enough there to worry about - more important matters to work on.

user-pic

I disagree. War crimes and the Constitution are very important matters. We let it go with Nixon and with Reagan. It gets worse every time. This time there have to be consequences. Obama can't say that the rule of law will be a guiding principle and then refuse to go after the biggest lawbreakers of all.

user-pic

It was a speech - not opened for debate. Besides, which failed policies would they consider right and proper to air before the public, both national and international? Surely they wouldn't expect President Obama to sugar-coat praise just to soothe the opposition's discontent at his inauguration would they?

user-pic

I would have thrown a shoe at Busg right there an the dais!

Leave a comment

Doctor Cleveland

user-pic

Following: 8
Followers: 9

Posts
Comments & Recommends


Favorites

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address