« Make health care THEIR Waterloo | Doc Magnus's Blog | TPM shows "Barack" and "Obama" as misspellings but not "Reagan" or "Clinton" »

Our "civil war" rages on and on and on ...


I have been reluctant to post these ideas though I have harbored them for some time.  Recent events have only confirmed their continued applicability, however, and a post yesterday on Truthout.com by Eric Boehlert, "A President Was Killed the Last Time Right-Wing Hatred Ran Wild Like This," prompted me to respond to Boehlert with the below thoughts, and to submit them for the consideration of this community.

Basically, I thanked Boehlert "for catching up."  The rest of my statement follows:

"I've watched people I thought I knew well, including Republicans of seemingly high intellect, buy into the radical insanity, fearing -- and this is a direct quote - 'the end of representative democracy under Obama.'  Making sweeping generalizations goes against everything I believe in, but the sheer amount and intensity of irrational behavior leads me to conclude there is a pathological level of paranoia among the right wing and a huge amount of racism and 'christianized' extremism.  This is a Deep South, Great Plains, High Rockies movement -- regions that are historically the least open, the least tolerant, and the most xenophobic in the country.  Make no mistake: This country's 'Civil War' started with the '3/5ths Rule' in the Constitution, became a shooting war in the 1860s (when the radical Right claimed another President), a covert war until the Civil Rights Act, and has continued today under the guise of neo-conservativism, for whose adherents Muslims, the Taliban, and Iranian 'insurgents' provided a useful proxy for unification through violence.  The deep red converts are scary and dangerous, and they are seducers of many people we all know and, in some cases, even love."

Whether witch doctor, Stalin, Hitler, secret Muslim, or any other ludicrous comparison the Right wants to launch, the opposition to President Obama has completely lost its moorings from any reasoned political or social theory.  Radical federalists, neo-imperialists, or simply the super-rich hoping to avoid a fair tax share are all among those who freely exploit the paranoid as muscle against social progress.  The health care "debate" only confirmed for me the lunacy of the "other side" and demonstrated the willingness of empowered interests, this time in the form of the insurance lobby, to leverage blind hatred for narrow, parochial purposes. 

What I once wanted to tell a former friend whom I have lost in the course of this debate, a Republican I once held in some esteem, is that the intensity of the opposition that he emphasized on our past discussions does not equate to validity.  It is my experience that the most intense "believers" in any line of thinking operate detached from all facts and rely exclusively on faith in a special, shared truth that unites them and their fellow believers no matter how destructive that belief may be to the common welfare.  It's not the product of rational thought, it is the behavior of a cult and it defies logical discourse.  This was most evident previously in the Evangelism that propelled Republicans to power in the 90s until recently despite the fact that the Republicans so ensconced demonstrated a level of avarice, mendacity and immorality more befitting decadent Rome than seats of American government.  Now, we see this cultism in a Fox-fueled radical right that would, indeed, cheer at the death of a President they hate unreasoningly even though his policies (continuing some of the policies of his Republican predecessor) saved the world from a devastating Second Great Depression and certain economic anarchy.  Go figure.

I was hopeful that policy successes under President Obama, the best leader for our times, would cement a pragmatic government under Progressives for the remainder of my life (who, after all would turn down affordable health care?!).  That outcome is now at great risk.  Progressives are going to have to mobilize and defend their recent gains until the radicals are finally forced into permanent minority status and a more rational opposition emerges.  Do they have the will when there is no grand, unifying crisis at hand, only a low-level counter-revolution driven by hate, shaped by lies and energized by unthinking fear?  Time will tell whether we will participate in the next great victory over the forces of repression in America, or suffer yet another reversal that further delays our emergence as a truly rational society. 

God Bless the United States of America.

 


6 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

"Time will tell whether we will participate in the next great victory over the forces of repression in America, or suffer yet another reversal that further delays our emergence as a truly rational society."

Doc Magnus, I am in concert with your conveyed urgency to step it up in order to keep the pressure on in all areas of discontent. Having said that, I am not completely convinced we have achieved any "great victory" yet. At this point I am more than a little skeptical that we have got anything close to what was presented. I am trying hard not to be cynical. I don't want to have to realize the old "Bait and Switch" has been used on a hopeful, desperate mass. That would be tragic almost beyond words. It is sobering, however, to know there are now few alternatives but to wait and see. I do remain hopeful, but cautious.

user-pic

I understand the feeling, ric, and thanks for the support, but keep a little perspective: There have indeed been "Great Victories" that have given us the society that we, and our conservative counterparts, enjoy today and take for granted. Cripes, we can go back to the Magna Carta, but try the American Revolution, for starters, then the Bill of Rights, the Emancipation Proclamation and the military defeat of the South, the administration of Teddy Roosevelt and his progressive accomplishments, the FDR presidency and defeat of facism on a global scale, U.S. involvement in bringing about NATO, the U.N. and international multilateralism, integration and the Civil Rights movement, our capitalist Democracy outlasting the Soviet Union (thus taking away an all-purpose bogey man from the Right's political arsenal), the empowerment of the individiual through the Internet, and last time I checked, there was this Black guy who is President.

Actually, the field of history's defeats is largely populated by conservatives -- monarchs, dictators, and high-handed clergymen. Of course, there's a lot of pain and death to go along with that, from the victims of the Inquisition, to the Holocaust, to civilian deaths everywhere from Dresden to Fallujah.

As disgusting as, say, Dick Cheney can be, pull the lens back and you'll see we're moving in the correct direction.

user-pic

Reading your inspirational....and CORRECT assessment of our countries past victories, both military and world changing, caused my strong patriotic senses to rise. But I was referring to a more current political reality.

The Bush/Cheney years were a shock to my system. It was a period of repression and corruption so perverse I could not reconcile with my 60 odd years of living in a progressively advancing country I was so very proud to be a citizen within. It went against every fiber of belief I had in a system that has been so successful and effective for more than 200 years. I feared constantly perhaps the damage was so immense and had become so entrenched it might be unrecoverable. Then along came Obama. With a vision so refreshing and a promise so compelling, there was hope. I had genuine hope that we would be restored once again to the America I knew and longed for. That had so irrationally and quickly been subverted by Neo Cons and self-serving criminal minded politicians and corporate opportunists.

To be frank and honest, to my utter disappointment Obama first loaded his cabinet with Clinton operatives and Wall Street insiders. They immediately and predictably set out to further the bankers vise grip hold and ever growing influence on our country. The Goldman Sachs sledgehammer has been painfully entrenched in this administration. He not only did not change the abhorrent practices and policies of the Bush regime, he has steadfastly maintained and even strengthened them. Obama wants the Patriot Act renewed. He voted for a detrimental revision of FISA and immunity for the telecom wiretapping violators. From torture and rendition to spying on American citizens and continuing the illegal wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, everything he promised to end and make right is still firmly in place and growing. None of the injustices or the perpetrators of these crimes have been held to account. In fact, the prospect of going after them has diminished and even been discouraged by Obama and the still in power legislators that enabled the whole thing. The billions upon billions of dollars in bail-out funds are mostly unaccountable and in some cases outright missing. The promised recovery of that money is doubtful, and probably always was. DOMA is still in place and the Health Care debacle could have and should have been avoided. It seems like nothing more than a distraction from other pressing issues, at this point.

So. Doc, I am still a patriot. I love America as much as ever. But for the reasons I have listed I am not yet willing to hand over my confidence and trust to Obama. And I truly wanted to. I bet everything on it, my vote. Now I want to see some positive results. As I also said, I remain hopeful but cautious. Time IS running out.

user-pic

Amen.

user-pic

"even though his policies (continuing some of the policies of his Republican predecessor) saved the world from a devastating Second Great Depression and certain economic anarchy. Go figure."

As did FDR, he saved capitalism from itself. And what does he get as thanks? The same that FDR got: called "socialist".

Go figure, indeed.

user-pic

What bugs me is people like the growly, jowly old white guy whose name I've chosen to forget on Bloomberg who said that financial crises happen every 30 years or so and provoke a rush toward regulation that never keeps the next crisis from happening.

Bullroar.

The crisis from which we are recovering began when the GOP House gutted FDR's regulations during the Clinton Administration and spineless Democrats in the Senate went along with it, and Clinton signed it into law.

Go thank Citigroup (wait, now it's Citicorp again) for HR 10 and the devastation it wrought beginning with Enron and Worldcom and perfected by AIG and all the subprime over-lending and over-investing and non-regulating while Bushco went out for Pepsis.

FDR knew what he was doing. The Republicans don't, not then, not now.

Leave a comment

Doc Magnus

user-pic

Following:
Followers: 8

Posts
Comments & Recommends


Favorites

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address