« Where is the Rotwang? | destor23's Blog | Tom Daschle's Tax Problem »

Learning To Be The Majority


Let me start with a shout out to Jason Everett Miller, one of the truly beyond-partisan thinkers at TPMCafe -- this post is about how the Democrats need to act with a congressional majority and the White House, but it is not a post about fierce partisanship.

The Democrats do, however, need to be more aggressive and they need to shed the tactics of a minority party.

Take the stimulus bill:  The Democrats would like to use the government to support access to contraception, to fight the spread of STDs and to accomplish a host of other social goals.  We also need to pass a stimulus spending package that should be about 5% of GDP, or more, say the economists, if it's going to be effective at all.

Now, the stimulus package can and should include our broader goals.  Green energy, infrastructure repair, universal high speed and wireless internet access should all be in there.  But, the stimulus package would really be better if it had some Republican support.  These huge bills are always vulnerable to cries of "pork!" after all and it's better if both parties take some responsibility for what's in this.  Besides, most of the Republicans agree that we need some stimulus too.  By all rights they should vote for this because, heck, it's the right thing to do.

If we can give them some cover by removing STD prevention and birth control access from this particular bill, I say we do it. Yes, you can persuade me that both are stimulus because they reduce public health costs but it's a bit of a twisted argument and it'd be best for all involved if the stimulus bill contained stuff that most reasonable people would call stimulus without too much objection.  Yes, I can be persuaded about STDs and birth control but... I see where people say it's not stimulus but rather a barely relevant add-on.

And here's where I get to the power of the majority and how we should act... We don't need to put STD prevention and birth control access in the stimuus bill because we have majorities in both houses and the presidency.  We can introduce and pass a separate bill that would accomplish both over the objections of any socially conservative Republicans.  We're the majority.  Let's drop this from the stimulus and then pass it separately.

Tom Coburn is never going to help us pass bills that help prevent the spread of STDs.  Fine.  He might help us with the stimulus.  And we no longer need his help for STDs (and never had it anyway) so let's drop this.

Minority parties have to resort to making big bills with everything in them so that they can pursue an agenda under the cover of something else.  We're not the minority now.  I'm not saying that we should compromise with the Republicans.  But on issues like the stimulus package we can certainly clean up the bill and get some support from some of them.  Then we can beat them in up and down votes on some of our other goals.  Yes, they can use parliamentary procedure against us but the same was true when they had some pretty slim minorities in the last decade... they didn't care... with small majorities and the White House they broke many of our parliamentary tactics and we all complained about it.  Their side will fold on some of these issues too.

It doesn't all have to be in the stimulus.  The majority party should strive to make bills that can get bipartisan support but also shouldn't be afraid to pursue its goals simply because it is the majority.  Republicans crafted No Child Left Behind and The Patriot Act to win bipartisan support and those bills passed.  Then they did bankrupcty reform with only a few defectors from the Democratic side.  We can make the stimulus our Patriot Act and then pass the birth control and STD bills as our bankruptcy reform.  It can be done.  We know.  They did it.

20 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Uh... I do apologize but when I wrote this I wasn't aware that NO house Republicans voted for the stimulus bill.

I'd stand by my post if that weren't the case. But NONE of them voted for it? Jason, dude... how can we possibly work with these people?

user-pic

How about from now on, when this sort of thing happens, we all just shout.... "Jaaaaaaason! Come git yer dudes in line!"

Still, it's been good politics by Obama. Dumb of them too, I think, to have ALL voted against it. Your larger point holds, Destor - about learning to act as a majority party. Which sometimes means stripping out stuff we'd like... and other times, body-slamming it through. But you've got to show the public, the media & the GOP that you can do both carrot & stick, compromise & hammer.

On 3 now... Jaaaaaason!

user-pic

Jaassonnnnn! Nuthin personal, Jason, but you're gonna have to adopt some different strategies to have an impact with your compatriots in the House.

user-pic

I would rather have Freddie pay them a visit. Just substitute K Street for Elm Street.

user-pic

You don't need to actually work with them, only make the offer and let the chips fall where they may.

Usually with some "Chip" (like Eric Cantor of VA) making an ass out of himself. Give them enough rope and they'll swing in the 2010 primaries. Patience isn't only a virtue right now, but it is a requirement as well.

See my comment downstream about why I think you are exactly right in your analysis.

user-pic

I'm going to send Planned Parenthood a link to this blog.

You are very persuasive.

They should announce that they will write a separate bill, too. Because it is a slap in the face to women. And we know it.

user-pic

They will eventually get the female bills passed.

Speaker Pelosi just made it against the law to take women employee rights away from them...Imagine.

Only 40 plus years.

user-pic

I'm afraid you took the Republican bait on this one, destor. The provision was about helping the states with Medicaid costs, which is a good thing:

First of all, assisting states with their Medicaid programs is a proven and effective strategy for stimulating the economy in times of economic distress. That's why the stimulus package contains $87 billion to help states with Medicaid costs. One can only assume that Rep. Boehner's singling out for criticism the Medicaid spending for contraception is politically motivated.

Not only is it politically motivated, it is highly ironic coming from a self-described fiscal conservative who repeatedly says the stimulus package should include spending that doesn't increase the deficit. When the Congressional Budget Office assessed a virtually identical provision in 2007, it found that it would save the federal government $200 million over five years by helping women voluntarily avoid pregnancies that otherwise would result in Medicaid-funded births. An expansion such as the one permitted by the stimulus package could save Rep. Boehner's state of Ohio $1.4 million in 2009 - money that could make a real difference in a hard-hit state that is struggling with significant budget shortfalls.

Coming from a member who is adamantly antiabortion, Rep. Boehner's opposition is doubly ironic, since publicly funded family planning services significantly reduce the number of unintended pregnancies and abortions that occur. Each year, the contraceptive services provided just at publicly funded clinics help women avoid 1.4 million unintended pregnancies, which would result in 640,000 unintended births and 600,000 abortions. Without these services, the number of abortion performed each year in the United States would be 49% higher than it currently is.

In short, inclusion of the Medicaid family planning provision in the economic stimulus bill is eminently justifiable. It's classic anti-recession economic policy, it doesn't increase the deficit, and it reduces unintended pregnancies and abortions.

user-pic

Thanks for the shout out. I think this blog is exactly right.

A majority should proceed with confidence and clarity. If a few programs hit the chopping block to get this through the senate with some support, a real majority would follow-up with a host of bills for each and every measure that went away. Throwing some bones to small business won't hurt and get a few more votes.

If the Senate does their job right, no matter what happens in the House with the combined bill, it will pass and Obama can claim true bipartisanship in getting it done. I hope all the current republican leadership dig in their heels for the next two years and force Obama to fix things over their loud and obnoxious objections. That will make it that much easier to replace them in the 2010 primaries.

Barack knows he is playing to the republicans at home not the ones on the Hill.

user-pic

See, after much trying you've managed to civilize me.

user-pic

Which gives me much hope for the larger effort ahead, however I must admit that it was you (and a couple others around here) who helped civilize me first. It wasn't until I could take a more pragmatic progressive stance as a liberal that I could figure out how to do so as a conservative.

user-pic

I find it quite fitting liberals see STDs as such a major priority.

Not only can you see democrat voters as they walk into the free clinics, but if your window is down, the wind is right, and they're far enough along in their infections, you can SMELL em!!!!

user-pic

Renaye, you are a truly disgusting major league asshole.

user-pic

Any wonder why I choose to believe this person represents a dying fringe ideology rather than the majority of people who self-identify as conservative? The crazier the right fringe gets, the quicker a new republican party can emerge from the ashes of the old.

user-pic

Uhhh,

I believe the subject of the post to be government funding for STD treatment.

I like to stay on subject.

user-pic

Actually, that isn't the subject of this post, but that you think it is helps explain why you are so often out in the right field spinning in rhetorical circles.

user-pic

hahaahahahahha. Froggy that is a funny line. Maybe it is just my mood.

user-pic

Glad you got a laugh out of it, dd! She really does disgust me. Check out the pure Nazi "final solution" sadism in another comment renaye/spric/it made today:
http://tpmcafe.talkingpointsmemo.com/talk/blogs/the_media_consortium/2009/01/crying-for-change-from-coast-t.php#comment-3356439

Here's the key quote:
"Raid businesses known to hire illegal aliens and begin prosecutions against those hiring them while jailing the illegal aliens. Two or three hundred acre enclosures could be fenced in to warehouse the illegals. They should be fed coarse foods during their incarceration and provided minimal shelter. No hurry should be made in prosecuting the illegal aliens."

user-pic

This is good Destor. That part about acting like the majority is right. But, I think, what they also need to start acting like is what Obama told them. The ground has shifted, this is not only is NOT politics as usual, it can't be politics as usual. We haven't seen the end of the "economic downturn". Things are going to get ugly and then they will be different - forever. I don't mean to mix up topics but the economy is going to force the politians in congress to sit up straight and act like adults.
I didn't know that people with STD smelled, being as I don't go around sniffing them you know. I guess some people do (sniff them I mean).huh.

user-pic

"But, the stimulus package would really be better if it had some Republican support."

Maybe not on the health care thing, but won't a lot of the bill's money flow through red state Congressional districts? I mean, whether it's strictly pork or not, isn't there some leverage on Repos to vote for things which bring jobs and cash flow to their voting constituency?

I have to think the 0 votes thing is merely a tactical move and an attempt to build solidarity. Look at the votes when the Senate version is reconciled with the House version.


Leave a comment

destor23

user-pic

Following: 96
Followers: 49

Posts
Comments & Recommends


  • Website: thosethingswesay.blogspot.com
  • Location New York City
  • Party We've thrown a few
  • Politics social libertarian, economic liberal, foreign policy skeptic.

Favorites

  • Favorite Blogs TPM, Atrios, Swampland, Forbes Trailwatch.
  • Favorite Books The Great Gatsby
  • Favorite Quotes Diamonds are forever and so is Ric Flair.

Bio

Writer, journalist, typist.

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address