« All About Me | Desidero's Blog | Quick Thoughts: Why Hillary at State Works »

Coming Out Party: Keep On Raping in the Free World


Okay, this won't be a surprise to some of the more observant, but to a few who say called me a cunt and suggested my repeated postings on feminist topics were only driven by identity politics and my genital makeup (would that be L'Oreal or only Avon?), this may come as a bit of a surprise.

I'm a man. Not gay or a trannie (though God knows I've tried - I actually look - or looked - quite hot in a good fish-net dress, and have been chased through the streets of New Orleans by frat boys assuming too much from my purple tights - but I digress). Simply heterosexual male. Okay, scratch the "simply" if you like.

It's been odd here at how much I can talk about hockey and thrash music and engage in banter and expressions and topics that I would assume to be decidedly male, but because I champion some female issues, I've been shrouded in gender ambiguity. Well, I've always loved androgyny, from Bowie to Cure to Marilyn Manson, so bring it on, but still it strikes me as peculiar and a little too easy.

And I'm continually amazed by the attitudes I see around me. I wasn't raised among feminists like in the story I'll point to. I didn't have a seriously impressionistic childhood like Quinn. I simply made a few observations and reacted in what I thought was a rational manner. In college I met a very cute petite blond, majoring in Mechanical Engineering. Her father had worked in the auto  business in Detroit for umpteen years, and she could strip down and rebuild an engine in about 2 hours. "Now that's clever", I thought to myself, "you don't need a beard or a beer belly to do that job after all". And that was it.

In one of my jobs I noticed all the big decisions were made on smoke breaks, so decided I better learn to smoke or pretend real good. And came to realize there weren't any women on these breaks either. "Funny, I wonder if that's how most companies work?" I thought. Well, not quite - it's also how politics and clubs work too.  And that was it.

I remember a female journalist who was a chatterbox, couldn't stop talking, quite wearing. And then one catastrophe happened, an earthquake, and she was the one who walked up to the police line, slipped under the tape, got into the sites and got the story. And after that I realized she was the one who got to work early and left very late. Even a week after her 2nd childbirth. And then she was fired. Some important guy that no one liked, who did little, and who only caused trouble wanted her slot. And that was it.

So it's rather odd to me that it would be unusual to look at the world and pick out patterns and notice imbalances and unfairness and to comment on it. If I look at the bailout or mortgage crisis, I look at who it affects, note where new black homeowners might be more affected, the poor in another, businesses in another. I put together a montage of impressions. And if that montage starts to show female qualities, would it be normal to lose interest, to dismiss it, to put it away, to say it's just a  "chick thing"? There have been studies of imbalances in schools, where girls were encouraged away from math, for example, and now it looks like the imbalance has swung more to bias against boys, including their energy and less focus. Should one side of the pendulum interest me more than the other?

I watch kids play with toys - some with blocks and cars, some with dolls and paints. Both are chattering away creating a variety of patterns, excited about their play. Should I find one more interesting than the other, or ignore that their choices of play toys differ significantly?

So it's rather odd to me that there's this assumption that a man wouldn't naturally want to identify with female issues, that straights couldn't have a natural interest in gays as people and a culture, that a white couldn't live in a black world without running into any obvious walls or requiring some heavy training to understand "the black experience".

If someone's beating someone in the street, is it normal to say, "oh, it's only a gay, just a gypsy, just a black, just a woman"?

A few weeks ago I mentioned the horrid war in the Congo - brutal, massive, and never-ending, but somehow overshadowed by the smaller (but not unimportant) events in Sudan. I noted the prominence of rape in the ethos there, to which one of my stalkers labelled my attitude, "ONLY WOMEN MATTER". Which I don't think was my specific point, but yes, there are occasions when what is happening to women matters more than what is happening to any other group. If it were happening to an ethnic group, we would call it "genocide" and be horrified. But if it happens to women, we call it "war" and take it in stride. Or at least some of us.

So I thank Zuzu at Shakesville for bringing up a speech by  Stephen Lewis (a Canuck, Quinn, you must have the most sensitive hockey players in the world up there) on the Millenium Goals. Should I say "failure of the Millenium Goals" (thanks, George). In which he mentioned the recent reporting of Eve Ensler - author of "The Vagina Monologues" - on entrenched rape in the Congo and expanded these to the reality of war and other typical behavior everywhere - that it always has a "sexicide" (my term) component, and this kind of inevitable lunacy towards half of the human race just can't continue while expecting significant progress anywhere else. If half the blacks were tortured somewhere, we'd scream bloody murder, if half of Christians were traumatized and marginalized we'd be withholding aid and contemplating invasion, even in Muslim Kosovo when presented with behavior a 10th as despicable we organized bombing raids and a takeover by the UN. But for the women of the Congo to be pawns in a sick game of rape and work slavery we simply pass by as Africa being Africa.

I'll let Stephen speak for a few sentences and then click on through for the rest (scroll down for the transcript).

I live in a feminist family, I love it. I believe to the end of my days that the feminist analysis of the exercise of male power is probably the most insightful analysis to explain much of what is wrong with much of this difficult world. And I must say that the more I've had the privilege of working in the international community, the more I have come to the conclusion that the struggle for gender equality is the single most important struggle on the planet. You cannot continue to marginalize 52% of the world's population and ever expect to achieve a degree of social justice and equity: it's just not possible.

And when you look at the damage that is done to the women, particularly of the developing world, through so many perverse realities whether it's international sexual trafficking or female genital mutilation or child brides or honor killings or an absence of inheritance rights or an absence of property rights or an absence or laws against rape and sexual violence or an absence of microcredit to give women some sense of economic autonomy or a lack of political representation - whatever the panoply of injustice, discrimination and stigma visited on women it seems to have no end, and it so profoundly compromises their existence.

And what has happened through the developing world latterly in many parts and which is so unsettling, unnerving, so profoundly compromising are the patterns of physical and sexual violence. The World Health Organization just did a quite astonishing study. It interviewed twenty-five thousand women in fourteen countries about physical and sexual violence. It found that the lowest levels of violence were in Japan at 14%, and the highest levels were in rural Ethiopia at 71%. And when they looked at the United Kingdom, the United States and Canada they found interim levels of 30-35%. So they saw that this was a pattern so deeply entrenched, whether it's marital rape or sexual violence from intimate partners or domestic abuse, these patterns are overwhelmingly entrenched.......... (transcript + audio).
And while people complain about "Identity Politics", identity politics makes a lot of sense when your identity is being erased and marginalized. Our identity is not just as individuals, but as an aggregate of different profiles we belong to. And if any of those profiles gets wiped out, we lose part of our identity as well. Just like those backwoods of my childhood that I can't go back to, or the bustling Jewish-enabled cultural boom of 1920's Berlin, it's erased from the human experience, from human possibility.

So here's hoping that over the coming years these obvious issues will stop being a chick thing, a black thing, a gay thing, a Muslim thing, a Christian thng, a white thing - and simply start being a human thing.

39 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

About a month ago I was responding to someone else about you and caught myself as I couldn't decide whether to call you a he or she. It's never really mattered to me. Keep voicing your voice, Des, I thoroughly enjoy your writing whether I agree with them or not.

user-pic

Thank you for a great post. We're all in this together! BTW, from the time I started hanging around here (Spring 2008) it seemed plain to me that you were male, so I thought it was weird recently when people pegged you as female simply because you posted re: "women's" issues.

user-pic

First, great post for the simple reason that anything that brings me up short, makes me go back an re-read and forces me to think gets high marks from me. While I don't always agree with what you say and once I even prematurely cut your thread (still kicking myself for that one) they always make me think.

Second, A stark reminder of why I should never, ever assume.

user-pic

Cut my thread? That was my fault - I accidentally erased my post the way I was using the blogger, so left an empty post with the Can Sarah Palin Choose Herself as Senator? topic line sitting there. You came along in that 5-10 minutes and punctured both tires. Ow. Head still hurts, scabs up and down both arms.

user-pic

Interesting post Des, I recommended it. I don't often agree with you, but I agree with a great deal of this. I think we all have to say that discrimination and mistreatment of anyone is an offense to us all. Otherwise, we're not being fair.

user-pic

I'll admit I often thought of you as a woman, Des, simply because so very many of your posts and comments have seemed predicated on an "angry feminist" viewpoint. I don't agree with all you have to say, but I agree with enough to respect your views and your writing.

All that said, I agree with your post here. So many segments of our (American) society face discrimination, it's difficult to single out any one as more oppressed than another. Extreme anti-gay bias, the extreme anti-Muslim attitudes reiterated in the campaign, the anti-intellectual bias evident in charges of "elitism," etc., come to mind. And yes, the anti-woman bias of our culture.

Many of these biases are actively promoted by the right-wing conservatives who revel in their top-dog status in society. But prejudice and oppression are not the sole dominion of the far right.

You're right on point when you say that 52 percent of the planet cannot remain chattel without that abomination enslaving us all.

user-pic

Gee Des, I only call guys cunts, so there isn't any gender issue for that word for me.

;)

user-pic

That would make you British?

user-pic

Tena left out that she calls everyone "guys."

After that, the logic races toward just one conclusion - Texan. ;-)

user-pic

* Still tap-dancing I see. Yeah, yeah, so now we all know the sex.

But what SPECIES?

* Liked this. "Our identity is not just as individuals, but as an aggregate of different profiles we belong to. And if any of those profiles gets wiped out, we lose part of our identity as well."

* And CONGRATULATIONS ON COMING OUT! Now we can have a beer, talk hockey, fix cars & do manly home repair things! Ahhhhh... sweet smell of freedom.

user-pic

But did you tell them? Or at least hint? Rosebuds in Spring? Somewhere, anywhere, just not in California???

user-pic

I admit I don't always understand your posts, Des, so are you saying you'd prefer people call you a prick now? ;-)

All I care is that you keep kicking ass and taking names. Or whatever it is you do. You know I've always been a fan. Especially when you were vomiting pea soup.

user-pic

Yeah, it was easy then, they could just call me "Them" and it all applied. And free peas soup? Who could complain?

user-pic

We can still call you "Them" ;)

user-pic

For Pete's sake, everybody knows "Desidero" is a boy's name. And if you're not sure, you just double-check the underside of the mushroom cloud avatar.

Great post. Thanks.

user-pic

Originally it was "Desider", but the new TPM ate my registration and wouldn't give it back. I could have gone for Desiderata, but God knows I have trouble typing so much.

user-pic

TPM has technical problems?

user-pic

No, can't be!!!

user-pic

I admit to being somewhat confused at first when I read other posts referring to you as "she". Yes, you often discussed "women's" issues, and you vociferously supported Sen. Clinton in the primaries, but I had previously inferred you were likely male based on the back-and-forth in the comments.

Not that it mattered to me one way or another - people should be judged on their ideas, not what reproductive parts they have. As a funny New Yorker cartoon once said, "on the internet, no one knows you're a dog."

Keep on calling them as you see them. I don't always agree, but you're certainly an interesting voice to have around.

user-pic

My dog didn't know I was me at first. Confusion rains.

user-pic

PS - and now back to Stephen Lewis' speech. What can we do to help?

user-pic

Not a clue what we can do to help. Ok, a tiny thing - just within TPM. Invite Stephen Lewis over to write something for TPM. Hell, invite his daughter-in-law too - Naomi Klein. Ask Lewis what the hell he thinks should be done re: Congo. Then sign on, demand more stories, pin Josh down & demand Congo stories daily. New campaign. They're retooling, so why not test drive it?

user-pic

Bzzzz. You have better ideas than this, try again.

user-pic

Ummmm.... scare people by saying the fighting was triggering another Ebola outbreak? No? Re-pitch Protect the Bonobo?

Look. After hearing that you were right about those Africa & NAFTA stories about Palin being hoaxes, my confidence is shot. Des? RIGHT? People will be fleeing in horror. Holy TPMeltingTheFuckDown!

Seriously, I have no idea how to cut through to the American public right now, about something like the Congo. There's too much domestic politics, economic shrapnel flying, too many personalities & events in play. 5.4 million dead? I donno. Surely to God there's some rich bastard out there that'd like to bankroll stopping something like that.

user-pic

I never even considered the idea you were a woman.

I'm such a chauvinist!

I like your post, but I must have missed what set it off. Regardless, your points are valid, especially re: The DRC, where America has shamefully ignored a brutal war because it is just so awful, and so messed up, that Darfur doesn't look so bad by comparison.

user-pic

Nothing much set it off, actually it was the Shakesville side where she said she's never seen any male advocate so much for women. But this is really irrelevant. Women are treated more horribly than I can ever imagine. That's really all that matters, is that we try in some way to help reduce the problem. What can we do?

user-pic

Great post! I, too, never really thought about your gender. And, I, too, missed whatever prompted this post. But, I'm glad for it, because I hope it will provoke a lot more thinking about these issues.

(BTW, I actually HAD previously thought about the origin of "desidero" and am glad to hear your explanation.)

user-pic

I've always thought of you as a he, if that's any comfort.

user-pic

I always thought of Desi as a sentient being

or at least a being....

user-pic

Or at least....

user-pic

I....., I'm sorry!

Orange mushroom clouds don't fit in my normal buddhist taxonomy!

user-pic

Again, I don't care about me. What Can We Do To Help? Brainstorming session or individual ingenuity, I don't care.

user-pic

The United Nations Development Fund for Women is actively trying to spread the word and get people involved. Here is their "about us" link:

http://www.unifem.org/campaigns/vaw/trust_fund.php

On the link below, they list ways to help.

http://www.unifem.org/campaigns/vaw/you_can_help.php

It is time for us address these atrocities.

user-pic

whats your point?

that you still feel insecure about how you felt while wearing those fish nets??

no one is staring at you!..

sheeeshhh.

user-pic

Good post! Thank Quetzalcoatl no one let the wildebeest into the house. ; ).

What can we do? Hormone therapy? Sedatives for the male population? I've see a lot of primates through the course of the last year. Not so many homo sapiens as rescued chimpanzees, (no bonobos alas!), and the issues you write of here are even more apparent in the chimp population, (our nearest relative on the evolutionary tree, assuming we'll give intelligent design a pass here). Given that we possess written language I think what you did here is as good a start as any, short of writing and actually enforcing national, and international laws insuring the rights and education of women.

Oh and anyone who has a mushroom cloud as an avatar is a man by default, fishnet hose notwithstanding.

user-pic

Awwww, I was kinda hopin' for a guest appearance from Wild E. Beest. You gotta KNOW it would've been special.

Maybe if we get a chant going... Wild-E-Beest... Wild-E-Beest... ;-)

user-pic
user-pic

Well Desi, I kind of had you pegged for a guy even before I knew for sure and not from the masculine Desidero. When you speak of women's issues, it always seemed to come from a place of empathy and understanding of women's issues rather than belonging to the group ("we" or "us"). The very reverse of identity politics, which is as it should be. I don't like to brag, but in the oppression olympics I may have hit a trifecta being African American, female and of Muslim descent on my dad's side and in name if not in religious practice. I'd like to hope that experiencing discrimination doesn't lead to I am more oppressed than you, but rather a greater sensitivity to injustices even when it happens to groups you don't belong to. So it was a shame on the night we elected the first African American as President, there was also written into the CA constitution discrimination against gays and lesbian marriage.

In terms of women's issues I've argued about the sexism and gender inequality that still exists in America, but it doesn't hold a candle to what is happening around the world. And yes I think violence against women, particularly in the Congo and Sudan, demands greater intervention. My father is Somali and I remember the high hopes of finally ending the civil war and famine in Somali when the US intervened in '92, only to have the Black Hawk Down incident happen which made the US much less likely to intervene when our "national interests" were not at stake.

Your question of what can we do is an excellent one. The US can't be the world's policeman, but neither can we hold our moral authority while allowing these atrocities to keep happening. I have no answer other than not let these stories continue to fall away, to force people to acknowledge what is going on by speaking out about it. And perhaps making a little room on the 24 hour news cycle for what is actually going on in Africa rather than rumors that Palin thinks Africa is a country.

user-pic

I always figured you were a guy Des, however I may have missed a few of those posts dealing with "women's issues" (which are really everybody's issues anyway).

I was about to call it male intuition.
Except that, (oh crap!) I just noticed the little Kool-aid smiley face in your mushroom cloud.

Maybe more subconscious than intuitive...

Leave a comment

Desidero

user-pic

Following: 1
Followers: 29

Posts
Comments & Recommends


Favorites

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address