Sometimes the men are intent on keeping old grudges going and the women have to step in to quiet things down. Hopefully Savage Politics won't mind the complete copy - a Web link didn't seem to have the same power.http://savagepolitics.com/?p=214
Hillary’s Irish Legacy: Just Tea?
March 17th, 2008 Lin Farley Posted in Political Analysis | 56 Comments »
*Happy St. Patrick’s Day!*
by: Lin Farley
Who makes peace? Is it the officials who forge an
agreement and then sign the documents? Or is it the people who inspire
others to change their minds.
In Northern Ireland you needed both. And that is why it is “silly” to question Hillary’s role in the peace process there.
No, her name does not appear on the Good Friday
accord that formally ended hostilities, but Hillary Clinton not only
helped to win the peace there, she is still working to maintain it. The
people of Northern Ireland understand this, and they did long before
anyone on this side of the Atlantic questioned Hillary’s role in the
peace process.
In August 1999 the British Secretary for Northern Ireland, Mo Mowlam, told Ireland’s Talk Magazine:
Hillary is one of the essential reasons we’ve had 18 months of relative peace. Without her we would have no economic boom.
If only the American newspapers that have published
questions about Hillary’s contribution had bothered to talk to the
Irish, how different their stories might have been. Hillary supported
in every way possible the thousands of Catholic and Protestant wives
and mothers who were incalculable in winning the peace. These were
women, it turned out, who were much like she is: strong at the broken
places. Bobby Sands, a Republican freedom fighter by his own
description, who died in 1981 of a hunger strike in Long Kesh prison,
wrote:
There are praises of flowers who epitomize the
unconquerable spirit of Irish womanhood. Let no man dare to scorn these
women and let your weeds of indifference and sleeping roses blush in
everlasting shame.
Hillary traveled to Northern Ireland seven times
between 1995 and 2004, and she was the only First Lady in American
history to visit that blood-soaked country even once.
Much of her work there was behind the scenes, but
nothing was more critical than her advocacy and support of the women of
Ireland. Senator George Mitchell, the chief negotiator at the North
Ireland peace talks has said of Hillary,
“She was very much involved in encouraging the
emergence of women in the political process in Northern Ireland, which
was a significant factor in ultimately getting an agreement.”
In 1997 at the University of Ulster, County Antrim,
Hillary delivered the first memorial lecture in memory of the recently
deceased Belfast community worker, Mrs. Joyce McCartan, who had lost 18
relatives during the Troubles. The two women had first met in 1995 on
Hillary’s first visit to Northern Ireland over a cup of tea at a
women-run, drop-in center on the Ormeau Road. Speaking to an audience
of about 1,000 the First Lady passionately declared that Joyce McCartan
and “all the brave women who had marched, cried, shouted and demanded
peace for over 20 years deserved to be heard.”
According to Irish journalist Susan Breen, it was at
this point in her speech, to her audience’s delight, that she produced
the stainless steel teapot that the Belfast woman had given her on that
first visit. Clinton said she used it every day in her second-floor
private kitchen in the White House, and had brought it back as a symbol
of hope:
“I don’t know whether a Catholic or a Protestant
made this teapot. I don’t know whether a Catholic or a Protestant sold
this teapot. I only know that this teapot serves me very well, and it
stands for all those conversations around those thousands of kitchen
tables where mothers and fathers look at one another with despair,
because they cannot imagine the future will be any better for their
children.”
But this teapot also is on the kitchen table where
mothers and fathers can look at one another and say: `We have to do
better. We cannot permit this to go on. We have to take a stand for our
children.’
Speaking directly to Northern Ireland’s politicians, Hillary declared:
“When the people want peace, it is the
obligation of political leaders to find the common ground where it can
thrive. That requires compromise and reconciliation. That involves
postponing or even giving up one’s cherished ideals in the belief that
others will do the same to end the conflict.”
Hillary also declared that the U.S. would continue to play its part in support of the peace process.
A year later Hillary was back in Northern Ireland
lending her voice to the struggle for peace in a keynote speech to the
`Women in Democracy’ Vital Voices conference at an overflowing
Waterfront Hall in Belfast. In the course of that speech she received
two standing ovations from an audience that included: the wife of the
First Minister, Daphne Trimble; the RUC Chief Constable, Ronnie
Flanagan; the Sinn Fein leaders, Gerry Adams, Martin McGuinness and Pat
Doherty; Ulster Unionist representatives Jim Wilson and Peter Weir; the
US ambassador to Ireland, Jean Kennedy Smith; and the Chief Executive
of the Northern Ireland Fair Employment Commission, Bob Cooper.
In her address Hillary declared that women’s voices could not be ignored:
“If you listen you can hear the voices of women
who withstood jeers and threats to make themselves heard in the
political world once reserved primarily for men…None of this would have
been possible were it not for the courage and strength of generations
of women. You will only move forward, and as you do please know that
America will stand with you.”
Clinton praised the British Secretary for Northern Ireland, Dr. Mo
Mowlam, for her “vision and dedication.” She also said that women’s
voices must continue to be heard in a Northern Ireland for which people
have lived for, died for and, yes, finally voted for.
Referencing her planned visit to Omagh, County Tyrone, later in the day, she said:
“When my husband and I visit Omagh, we will pay
tribute to those 29 people who were murdered by the enemies of
peace.They were mostly women and children, Catholic and Protestant,
unionist and nationalist, young and old. They were people simply living
their lives, working in a drapery story, hanging out with friends,
buying school uniforms for their children.”
The terrorists targeted the people of Northern
Ireland, and in response it was the people, all the people, who bravely
stood side by side to say hatred and violence will no longer have a
place here. We have chosen ballots not bombs, democracy not division.
We have resolved to live in peace. We will never go back. We will only
go forward.
Clinton said she was aware that the last few months
had shown that the road to peace was not easy, but she had no doubt
that the bombs and terrorists would not prevail. She also expressed
delight when she was praised by a Derry student, Ms Fiona Hughes, who
introduced her as a “role model to me and to young women around the world.”
The Vital Voices conference, itself the product of
an initiative begun a year earlier by U.S. Secretary of State Madeleine
Albright and Hillary herself, had brought together over 400 Catholic
and Protestant women to foster their rise to prominence and leadership
and to ensure that their success helped support peace. Hillary also met
privately with community workers and with women politicians in Northern
Ireland to encourage them to take on a larger role. One of these
community workers, Inez McCormack, a labor and fair employment
advocate, said of the conference:
“Hillary Clinton took risks for peace in asking
me and others to bring women and communities from both traditions
[Catholic and Protestant] to affirm their capacity to work for common
purpose, she used her immense influence to give women like me space to
develop this work and validated it every step of the way. This approach
is now taken for granted but it wasn’t then. She told us that if we
take risks for peace, she would stay with us on that journey. In my
experience, it took hard work, attention to detail and a commitment of
time and energy which she delivered steadily and where needed over the
last decade.”
At the end of her Vital Voices speech, Monica McWilliams, clapped wildly and proclaimed,
“Oh, do we need this woman here now!”
McWilliams, is the peace activist who is now a
member of the Northern Ireland Assembly, but who a year earlier in 1996
helped to found the Northern Ireland Women’s Coalition, NWIC. This was
a hastily put together assembly of women’s groups so that women might
have a voice at the bargaining table in the peace process after she and
May Blood were told that only leaders of the top 10 political
parties-all men-would be included in the peace talks. With only six
weeks to organize, McWilliams and Blood gathered 10,000 signatures to
create a new political party, the NIWC, and got themselves on the
ballot. They were voted into the top 10 and earned a place at the table.
The NIWC’s efforts paid off. The women drafted key
clauses of the Good Friday Agreement regarding the importance of mixed
housing, the particular difficulties of young people, and the need for
resources to address these problems. The NWIC also lobbied for the
early release and reintegration of political prisoners in order to
combat social exclusion and pushed for a comprehensive review of the
police service so that all members of society would accept it. Clearly,
the women’s prior work with individuals and families affected by “the
Troubles” enabled them to formulate such salient contributions to the
agreement. In the subsequent public referendum on the Good Friday
Agreement, Mo Mowlam, then British Secretary of State for Northern
Ireland, attributed the overwhelming success of the YES Campaign to the
NIWC’s persistent canvassing and lobbying.
May Blood, who is now a Baroness and member of the
British House of Lords, but who worked for many years as a community
leader in the Shankill area in West Belfast, said of Hillary’s role in
the peace process:
“The First Lady sent the message that the work
and influence that grassroots women were undertaking within their
communities was just as important as anything else that was taking
place. I witnessed her building new confidence in women at the
grassroots level and their stature grew within Northern Ireland as a
consequence. All of a sudden they were being taken more seriously. The
message we were also told by Hillary Clinton was that this work needed
a political focus.”
Blood, a local Belfast woman with no college
education who spent 38 years working in a linen mill, knows a lot about
taking women’s work seriously. From a single integrated school teaching
28 students [Catholic and Protestant] in Northern Ireland twenty-five
years ago, May Blood achieved through grass roots activism 58
integrated schools teaching over 20,000 students in 2005.
Geraldine McAteer who is now Chief Executive of the
West Belfast Partnership Board is another woman who remembers the
importance of the Vital Voices Conference:
“As First Lady, Hillary Clinton was extremely
supportive of the peace process in Northern Ireland, and in particular,
of the women who live here. In her visits during the peace process
negotiations she met with women from a range of backgrounds and she
recognized there was a real need to strengthen and support the voices
of women in the post conflict context and get the needs of women and
communities to the forefront of the new political agenda. She
recognized that this would be best done through building the skills of
women here. Through her Vital Voices Conference in September 1998, I
and others were able to develop our skills for the betterment of our
communities.”
In 1999 Hillary became the first woman in history of
the award to receive the “Freedom of Galway” city. In this honor she
joined former American Presidents John F. Kennedy and Ronald Reagan.
She also visited the National University of Ireland, Galway, to deliver
a lecture on “Our Obligations to Each Other: the Continuing Quest for
Peace” and to receive an honorary degree. In her acceptance speech of
the Galway award Hillary said that since she first visited Northern
Ireland in 1995 she had seen how far people had moved from history to
hope in the agreements reached, in the conviction of political leaders
and in the economic growth of the six counties. She said,
“The silencing of the guns, the release of the
prisoners and the election of a true representative assembly, were all
fulfilling the promises of the Good Friday agreement.”
But she added that the country needed the ordinary
citizens of the North and South to keep up the everyday work of peace
in their homes, schools and workplaces and communities.
The past century has taught us that hope is the only
answer unless we are to give in to evil and indifference. Economic and
social progress are possible, but only when people of different
backgrounds and religions let go of the past and their differences and
decide that the future offers greater promise than indifference or
antipathy.
Returning to Northern Ireland in 2000, Hillary
declared her everlasting commitment to the peace process and the
rebuilding of Northern Ireland.
Women know there is no going back.
Speaking at a conference at the Grand Opera house in Belfast, Clinton said:
“I know that building peace anywhere is never
easy and there are always people who are the self appointed doom
sayers. They would rather throw up their hands than roll up their
sleeves. But sleeves have been rolled up because woman after woman,
daughter after daughter, mother after mother, grandmother after
grandmother has made it clear there was no going back.The memories are
too fresh of a time when women would worry if their husbands, sons,
fathers, would return home alive after going out to work or to
socialize.”
The scars are so fresh… it takes no effort to pick up an automatic
weapon compared to picking the pieces of one’s life and building a
better future.
Clinton compared those who wanted to return to the
days of the Troubles, when people “knew the rules” to the followers of
Moses who wanted to return to Egypt rather than travel through the
desert to the Promised Land.
“There is always a back to Egypt committee or,
in this case, a back to Troubles committee but none of us can afford to
let that happen. History won’t let us. The looks on our children’s
faces should not let us. This is one of those special moments when we
have the chance to defy generations of hatred, a kind of moment that
comes to all of us but is not recognized by many. It has been
recognized here.”
A day earlier Hillary had outlined her proposal to
convene a gathering of women parliamentarians from Northern Ireland,
Britain and the Republic of Ireland:
“This convening of parliamentarians is a follow
up to the Vital Voices conference which we held in Belfast two years
ago, and is part of our ongoing efforts to make sure that women play a
critical role in the peace process in Northern Ireland and in building
a peaceful and prosperous island.”
In her speech on Wednesday, Clinton added details
about an information technology conference to be convened next year to
ensure women do not end up on the wrong side of the “digital divide”.
So she announced it is also intended that politics and media experts
from the US will travel to Belfast to hold seminars for community
activists in the province. CLICK HERE
All of the preceding is why the Irish understand
Hillary’s role in the Irish peace process and are incensed by the
incorrect notion that Hillary Clinton did not help win the peace. John
Hume, the Catholic architect of the Good Friday agreement and recipient
of the Nobel Prize has said he is surprised that anyone would question
the importance of her work,
“I can state from firsthand experience that she played a positive role for over a decade in bring peace to Northern Ireland.”
But I think that in order to fully appreciate
Hillary’s role in the peace process, one must fully appreciate the
scope of the Troubles which began in 1967 and marched unabated through
four decades. In that time the warfare became institutionalized at a
level of violence that was both intolerable but apparently irreducible.
It pitted Protestant gunmen and the Royal Ulster Constabulary–who had
pretty much declared open season on all Catholics no matter age or
sex–against the Catholic Provisional Irish Republican Army who condoned
violence against Protestants by virtue of being “at war.” The British
Army brought in to restore order after 1972 was both attacker and also
attacked, sometimes by both sides. Before the Troubles ended 3,600 men
women and children had died as a result of bombs, executions and
paramilitary parades and 40,000 had been wounded. Young people it was
found later had been at the highest risk of being killed, with almost
26 percent of all victims aged 21 or less and the 19-20 age group had
the highest death rate for any age group in Northern Ireland.
But in talking about the Troubles it is important to
remember they were essentially a battle over civil rights for Catholics
in Protestant dominated Ulster, and a war between the Protestant
majority who wanted to unite with Great Britain and the Catholic
minority who wanted to unite with the Irish Free State. Eventually in
1972, in response to the escalating strife, Great Britain dismissed the
government and took over direct control of the province. This return to
British rule was brutal. Bloody Sunday is when a Catholic march for
civil rights including an end to internment of political prisoners was
attacked by a British Parachute Regiment killing 14 unarmed civilians
in January of 1972 in Derry. Many believe it was possibly the IRA’s
biggest recruitment drive ever on one single day. The Battle of Bogside
was a three-day riot between unarmed Catholic residents of the Bogside
section of Derry and the Royal Ulster Constabulary. Hunger strikes by
IRA internment detainees or suspects detained without trial began in
the early 1980’s and before it ended ten prisoners starved to death,
among them Bobby Sands in 1981. Bloody Friday is when 20 Provisional
IRA bombs took 9 lives. The deaths of 29 unarmed civilians in Omagh
have already been cited. But the hard fact is someone or many some ones
died or were injured every day for close to 40 years. Northern Ireland
was a war zone where children as young as three threw bottles and
understood they were at war. The country was held up everywhere as the
world’s most intractable conflict equal to that of Israel and Palestine.
In this hopeless situation Hillary Clinton traveled
there repeatedly to hold out hope and the promise of a brighter future.
She reached out to the women who were the victims, but certainly not
the architects of the Troubles and everywhere she traveled she brought
inspiration, assistance and attention.
Joanna McVey, former CEO of the Fermanagh-published Impartial Reporter newspaper and chair of the Fermanagh Trust said,
“She turned empathy into action, her iconic
address to the first Vital Voices conference in Belfast in 1998 was
truly inspirational and her ongoing support for women’s roles in peace
building and the transformation of economic and political life in the
North was manifested through other initiatives and her own personal
involvement.”
John Hume has declared many times:
“She visited Northern Ireland, met with very
many people and gave very decisive support to the peace process. In
private she made countless calls and contacts, speaking to leaders and
opinion makers on all sides, urging them to keep moving forward.”
But it was Hillary more than any other established
political figure who understood that it was the women who would make
the difference. And she knew this by listening to them. Scores of women
had virtually no lives left at all. The Troubles had swallowed them
whole. And so she saw this as the critical place from which peace might
not only spring, but also go on to endure.
This is from an American student’s essay on women’s role in forging the peace:
Catholic women got the first wake up call by the
troubles with the introduction of internment. Their husbands were often
taken away for over a year. For the first time, these women were alone,
needing to support themselves and their families. They had to find
their independence. Realizing the depths of their isolation, many young
mothers reached out to each other to try to cope with their new
circumstances. These conversations often started on the cramped mini
bus trips to visit their husbands in prison. Together they moved past
self-preservation to community organization. Women would patrol the
streets at night to identify which young men were picked up by the
British Army and where they were taken. This would be the only
information parents would have about their sons.
The women soon wanted to be proactive and started
evening programs to get the teens off the streets and away from the
temptation to throw stones and to heckle police and soldiers. The women
provided support for themselves and their communities to face the daily
traumas of fear and violence. They became community leaders.
SOURCE
And these are the women Hillary reached out to,
supported, and endorsed. Clinton’s visits to Ireland and her work for
Irish peace is the subject of a book being published later this year by
Stella O’Leary, the Washington DC President of the Irish American
Democrats. O’Leary has said,
“Starting with the Christmas visit to Belfast in
1995, Hillary Clinton recognized that the participation of women was
critical to bringing about an end to the conflict, and she set about
inspiring women to become politically involved.”
The following is an email submitted by Rekha Varma
on Jan 10, 2008 at 01:13. It raises an absolutely critical point. In
this important primary season as America chooses the Democratic party’s
standard bearer, if we falsify and deny Hillary’s role in Northern
Ireland, we may end up denying ourselves her leadership in working with
Iraq:
Please can the someone from the US Press share
this information with Americans, because they are completely unaware of
the international role that Hillary played as 1st lady, and the US
Press is making no sincere effort to do any research, ridiculing her
role in N.Ireland as just sipping tea with women & watching her
husband negotiate with leaders. Hillary played an overlooked
independent role in working with the community to achieve de facto
peace, via creating opportunities for and encouraging Catholic &
Protestant women & the young to unite over universal social issues
that concerned them such as the safety of their families, the role of
women in politics (causes that Hillary herself was passionate about)
etc, Many feel that Hillary’s experience in N.Ireland would be useful
in suggesting how the Iraqi government can work with the various
divisions within the community to unite over shared concerns of their
children’s future after the war ends. I’ve provided a list of primary
sources below as evidence of her contribution to the N.Ireland peace
process found via a simple google search.
All sources mentioned in this article, unless otherwise listed, are from newspaper and magazine stories found on HILLARY WORLD WIDE, a meticulous and careful compilation of Hillary articles in the Irish press by a committed Irish woman.
©2008 Lin Farley, of SAVAGEPOLITICS.com. All Rights Reserved.
