PLEASE DON'T CALL THEM "HEROES"
The film was short, black-and-white, and presented to a film school seminar for critique and appraisal. The film-maker and star was understandably nervous because this was his first effort, and he was anxious that it be taken by the audience as a serious effort.
The film opens as the young man gets out of bed and helps himself to a beer from the fridge as his substitute breakfast. He brushes his teeth, then rinses with the beer.
The audience breaks into laughter, but the film-maker mutters, "It's not supposed to be funny."
As the story continues, the young man takes a desultory walk, but his solitude goes beyond alone-ness, somehow, so that the audience--even though they may not yet realize it--feel his alienation, his isolation, his loneliness and apart-ness from not only others in the film but others in the audience.
In the final scene, the young man sits on the sofa, surveying a coffee table laden with empty beer bottles. He reaches for a semi-automatic handgun and suddenly rams it into his mouth.
The camera breaks for a view of the table while, horrifyingly, the sound of a gunshot echoes and blood splatters over the table.
The movie ends.
The enthusiastic film-school kids rush to slap the young film-maker on the back and to tell him how good the short film was and how he seems to demonstrate a gift for the craft.
This pleases him, because he had been worried. He goes home to a house he shares with half a dozen other young people, sits down, and tells the camera that he is glad they liked his movie because now he knows this is something he can do with his life.
But unless you'd been watching the program, MTV's "Real World: Brooklyn," from the beginning, you would not know that the young clean-cut man named "Ryan," is actually a combat vet. He'd been deployed to Iraq with the army's 101st Airborne Division for more than a year, had completed his enlistment commitment with the army, and had chosen to apply to the "Real World" program as his first foray into civilian life.
Which makes the short film he produced that much more disturbing, a point which was not lost on his roommates.
They had attended the screening, of course, to show their support for their friend, but they hadn't really stopped to think--not REALLY--what the true cost of war can be for the men and women who are called upon to fight it. The guy they'd goofed around with for several weeks at that point, pranking, clubbing, hanging out--had just revealed to them, however indirectly, the depths of his depression and anxiety following his combat deployment.
And it brought them--and their viewing audience--up short.
One of his roommates, a pretty girl named Baya, told him later that night that she found the fact that he had actually been to Iraq "surreal."
Now, I'm not knocking this young woman, for the simple reason that she just expressed what most of the members of her generation--really, of ALL OF US--think about Iraq and Afghanistan veterans we may encounter.
Do you realize what a national SHAME that is?
Think about it.
This country has been at war now for SEVEN YEARS, six of them spent in Iraq.
SEVEN YEARS.
To a young person of 21, which is about Baya's age, this represents ONE-THIRD OF HER LIFE. For one-third of her life, our military servicemembers have been fighting two terrible wars, and yet, to her--to most of us--the whole thing is "surreal."
Thanks to the fact that the president who immersed us into two wars in the first place asked nothing of the rest of us but that we go shopping and continue to visit such hotspots as Disneyworld, then it has fallen to LESS THAN ONE-HALF OF ONE PERCENT OF OUR POPULATION to fight these wars over and over again in a nightmarish Groundhog Day scenario.
And for our young friend Ryan, the second day was about to begin.
In the episode following, which covers the presidential election week, Ryan tells the camera that he will be voting for Barack Obama because, "If he ends the war in Iraq, then maybe I won't have to go back."
His roommates are confused by this because they thought he was out of the army. He had to explain to them about the Individual Ready Reserve, in which, after you have completed your active-duty service, you are still committed for several more years to the armed services, which means that they can "recall" you at any point during that period of time.
They hadn't realized that, either. It just makes me sad that so many people remain unaware of that little clause in the contract that can force a young person back to war even when they have completed their service to their country and are busy rebuilding their civilian life.
Most of the roommates are also pro-Obama--which tracks pretty much with the national vote-count--but a couple of the guys are Republican. They tend to speak of John McCain in hushed tones and to refer to all soldiers and Marines as "heroes."
After the election and subsequent celebrations, Ryan receives an invitation to march in the Veteran's Day parade with the Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America organization, and to attend their party afterward. He is honored by this and pays a visit to their offices, where he learns how they have fought for all sorts of things on behalf of the veterans of those wars, including the new G.I. Bill, extended testing and benefits for the war's signature injury, Traumatic Brain Injury, and better after-service care for those veterans who suffer from Post Traumatic Stress Disorder.
Ryan is impressed by the scope and heft of the group, and he enjoys marching in his very first veteran's parade. At the party afterward, he happily runs into one of his buddies from the army.
Most of Ryan's roommates have also attended the party, at his invitation, and while he is across the room, his buddy tells them what a fine warrior Ryan had been in Iraq, the commendations and ribbons he had been awarded, and tells them that they will always be safe with Ryan around.
For perhaps the first time--even counting the day they saw the movie--Ryan's roommates realize not just the cost he has paid to serve his country, but the reality of it in terms of his own service.
In individual remarks before the cameras, they call him a "hero" and marvel at how they never realized before that he'd been decorated for his service. The war came front and center to them, and they all began to behave a bit differently around him.
One young man particularly moved by this is a naive but earnest fellow named Chet, who comes from a Mormon background and has therefore led a much more...shall we say...virtuous...life than many of his roommates. He is absolutely dazzled by Ryan's achievements and begins to follow Ryan around like an adoring puppy dog. Ryan is very kind and patient toward the younger man, treats him seriously and even begins to enjoy having him around somewhat.
So Ryan happens to be alone in the house with Chet when the phone call comes.
Ryan's brother informs him that he has received an official letter from the army, and that he is being recalled back into active-duty service for one purpose and one purpose only--to re-deploy to Iraq.
Ryan is so stunned by this news that he thinks his brother is kidding and asks repeatedly if it's true--really true--and when his brother says, "Dude, Mom and Dad couldn't call you with this. They couldn't bring themselves to do it. They were going to wait until you got home but I thought you'd want to start preparing yourself."
Both of Ryan's brothers are in the army as well. Unlike his civilian roommates, they KNOW what this means.
It means no film school for the fall, which had been Ryan's intent. It means probably losing his girlfriend, who barely made the harrowing first deployment and who, Ryan thinks, will fall to pieces at the news that there is to be another one.
He staggers around the large over-priced MTV loft in a state of complete shock before his legs give out on him and he plops down onto the couch next to Chet, where he suddenly puts his face into his hands and breaks down into sobs.
Now, no one watching this program would for one minute accuse this young man of cowardice. As he makes clear almost immediately--he is trained as a warrior; it's his job and he does it well. He will step up, as he did before, and he will do his duty.
But it sure feels like crap.
The news hits the roommates like a sledgehammer.
Suddenly, the war is RIGHT THERE, in their living rooms.
In their hearts.
It was something they never really had to think of before, not really. There were video games they could play, where they could pretend to be fighting bad guys in Fallujah. There were movies they could watch where other people pretended to fight bad guys in Fallujah.
But they didn't know anybody who would actually BE fighting insurgents in Iraq.
They are all heartsick for their friend because they knew he had plans, and that now those plans are wrecked. Nobody knows how to act around him, what to say or do.
Over the course of the next episode, Ryan tries to deal with this iceburg that has struck the ship of his life. He tells the guys he rooms with that he's going to "have to get my head in the game," and recruits a couple of them to go to the gym with him and help him start getting back into the kind of shape he'll need to be in for war.
He tells the camera that he's got to get himself mentally prepared, and to start thinking back in those terms again.
It's a whole other world, the world of war. It takes a whole other mindset, a whole other skillset, to survive. Like Ryan pointed out once, the skills he drew on when deployed before were second nature to him because he was active-duty and highly trained. But he's been out of that environment for months now, and he's rusty.
You can't go to war with rusty skills.
But even as he prepares himself for the shock of army re-entry, he can't bring himself to tell his girlfriend. She's in college, and every time he calls, she regales him with stories about all the exams she's taking and how stressed she is. He doesn't want to worry her. So he keeps this cataclysmic event to himself.
Chet and the others can't stop themselves from looking at Ryan like he's a dead guy. He could be in the near future, after all, and the truth of that is hitting home pretty hard.
WHY HADN'T THEY THOUGHT OF THAT BEFORE?
This is MY howl.
Why don't we ALL think of that?
I was once lectured by my brother about how many churches and classes were doing projects for soldiers, sending Care packages and the like, as proof of how engaged the country is in "supporting the troops." I was too exhausted by my own son's two combat deployments by then to point out the cold brutal fact that in every instance of which I am aware, Care-package drives and the like, there is always, always, at some point near the epicenter-- a military family.
SOMEONE who started that drive has a family member who is either deployed or has been. ONLY THEY know just how hard these deployments have been on military families, and in nearly every instance, it is a small coterie of like-minded people who are directly touched by the war who get the ball rolling, even if it's just, say, a church family. Many volunteers join in--don't get me wrong--but it is very rare to see such an effort spearheaded by someone who has not either deployed themselves or are married to veterans or who have warriors in their families.
The rest of us don't think about it that much.
In fact, it never ceases to amaze me when I see pundits and pontificators claim that Michelle Obama needs to get herself "a signature cause."
The thing is, she already HAS. Even during the campaign, she has done everything in her power to draw the country's attention to the plight of military families and to do whatever she can to improve their lives, but it seems that even then, people don't pay much attention unless they know someone in the military.
Which, I might point out, means that very few pundits, pontificators, or politicians will take notice. After all, it's not THEIR kids...is it? Not often, anyway.
So. I repeat. The country is not at war. The U.S. military is.
Around the MTV loft, the kids are in quiet awe of Ryan. He's a hero to them.
And this is where I have a real problem.
You see, every single member of that household was young, vital, and healthy. Those very bright young men who voted for John McCain are just the right age to step up THEMSELVES, but I didn't see a single member of that household offering to volunteer to go fight themselves.
As long as you can set servicemembers apart in your mind as "heroes," then somehow that makes them SUPERIOR to you and me, made of sterner stuff somehow, exalted, like something out of a comic book.
Ohhh, I COULD NEVER, goes the thought process. THOSE GUYS ARE HEROES. I'm just a lame-old regular nerd-person. I'd never be able to hack it.
As many of my readers know, I come from a proud military family who, at one time, had five immediate family members who were active-duty, three of whom had deployed to Iraq, and the other two to Afghanistan. And all those who were too old to be active-duty, were themselves, veterans.
And yet I have never once heard any soldier or Marine EVER refer to himself or herself as a HERO.
Soldiers and Marines are professionals. Soldiering is their JOB. No one on the face of this planet does it better. But ask any one of them you encounter any place doing anything and they will tell you point-blank that they are not only NOT heroes, but that they are uncomfortable being referred to as such.
This is because combat vets, to a man or woman, have all encountered REAL heroes in wartime. Each and every one can recount to you the story of a man or a woman they knew who risked his or her life for their fellow soldiers and Marines, or to take out a nest of enemy troops, or who gave up their lives in the effort.
THOSE are the true heroes, to the troops who have known them. I have spoken to MEDAL OF HONOR winners who steadfastly refuse to refer to their own accomplishments as heroic. Why? Because they came home alive.
Ryan, engaging and courageous as he may be, is no more heroic than any other young man or woman who shares the MTV loft. Every single one of those kids could step up and do what he did and what he is doing right now. (He was due to redeploy this month, with a Stryker brigade.)
As Ryan's friends awkwardly tried to help him forget, by taking him to Atlantic City, it was clear that, for a soldier who has been recalled, there IS NO forgetting. It was clearly in his mind, behind his eyes, a part of his soul every moment of his life after he got the phone call from his brother.
Back home after a lackluster trip to the casino, Ryan looked up his official orders online and showed his roommates what a Stryker vehicle was, since they did not know.
But all this time, you can't forget the short film at the beginning of the series. This was a young man who was suffering from depression, alienation, and anger, and he was not even going to be allowed the time to sort through those feelings and maybe even get help from such groups as the IAVA, before he was yanked back into war.
By the final episode, Ryan has accepted his lot and says he's ready to step up. He tells an old army buddy that he will be re-deploying with a unit that has never deployed. "I figure if something I can show someone, or something I can do, can save a life because I was there and could draw on my experience, then I will have served my purpose."
Still, he gets into a barfight. Aided and abetted by his MTV friends, but still, the anger and depression are right there, simmering beneath the surface.
His friends present him with a going-away gift--a journal. One of the guys tell him to write down all his film ideas, "And then, when you get back, you'll be ready to go. You won't have to wait for ideas to come to you."
Each member of the household has written a letter to him within the pages of the journal. He is touched, and it shows.
But in the final episode, the reality of the world inhabited by a man who has served in combat and who is about to do so again comes into stark, sharp focus.
On the night before everyone is due to leave, the girls decide to prank all the guys, to get revenge on the guys for pranks they've played in the past. But the pranks become mean, and one guy who has tried to stay out of the whole thing gets unfairly blamed by the girls, which causes an enormous argument between all the roommates.
Ryan gets the last word, as he finally shouts at the girls, "Right now, I need to be thinking about ONE THING. Getting my head in the game! Getting focused on things that are REAL. I need to be totally worried about getting my head focused SO THAT I DON'T DIE! I don't need to be worried about this petty little bullshit..."
It's ironic, isn't it? The program is called, "Real World."
But to a young soldier, there is only one thing in this life that is real: STAYING ALIVE. Keeping their buddies alive.
All the drama, all the bickering, all the nonsense that takes up what passes for real life these days, all the ridiculous American Idol "reality," is, to the soldier or Marine of today, completely UNREAL.
They come home and are greeted by an increasingly silly population, most of whom have no idea just how precious each and every moment of their lives should really be.
Ryan's rage at his clueless roommates is just a microcosm of the way all these guys feel each and every day they are walking around in the civilian world.
As my son said about his civilian job, "I can look at the photograph on my desk of me and my buddies in front of the Blackwater Bridge in Fallujah, and I can think, Gee, this lady cussed me out at work today but hey, at least she wasn't shooting at me."
It's time that we, the collective American WE, stepped up and did our parts. We don't all have to serve in the military, but the least we could do is stop treating those who do like they are somehow alien creatures apart from the rest of us.
Reach out. Offer one a beer. Give him or her a job if you're looking to fill one. Tell him you appreciate his service, and then go out of your way to make him a part of your world.
Make it real for him, or for her. Make it real.
Update: I would like to thank The Real World producers and camera crew for going out of their way to portray the reality of civilian life for combat vets, for highlighting the fine work of the Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America and the Iraq Vets Against the War, and for drawing attention to this terribly important issue of our times.













Umm, in perhaps a staggering incident of irony of the superficial, one particular thing stood out to me in this piece:
What the hell is he doing in a reality show?
April 3, 2009 9:30 AM | Reply | Permalink
Just trying to be a young American. For many, being on The Real World is a dream come true. What sort of preponderating self-righteousness would cause you to even ask this question?
Icons come and go. Maybe you should check your watch.
April 3, 2009 12:17 PM | Reply | Permalink
Perhaps you ought to check your logic circuit.
1. Guy's girlfriend is broken up about his deployment.
2. Guy comes back only to abandon said girlfriend to go on a reality show.
3. Guy is "worried" girlfriend will be broken up about a second deployment.
April 3, 2009 12:56 PM | Reply | Permalink
Do ya think there is something not right about him? That maybe his war experience has altered the logical development you see so clearly, that the soldier should somehow enmesh himself in his girlfriend's life 24/7? He should be there for this fragile female?
From what I see, this soldier was making some very momentous efforts. He was taking a very emotionally radical experience, going from wartime to peacetime overnight and staying with it as best he could. He was struggling to make a successful transition. The wounds of war will take a great deal of time to heal, and now his country has asked for him to open them again.
It may be that soldiers refute the notion of hero so that they not be seen as more then human. They wish to be allowed to feel the pain they neglected when in combat, as that would put them and their fellow soldiers in jeopardy. But feelings have a way of remaining and returning until they are met, and Ryan has a world we cannot grasp, so he simply asks that we be with him as a brittle human being.
April 3, 2009 2:58 PM | Reply | Permalink
Your have not even come close to providing any evidence for assertion 2. You fail to understand that a major component of assertion 1; reaches farther than the actual deployment, as the return is a part of it.
Nice example of linear dialectics though...
April 3, 2009 4:17 PM | Reply | Permalink
Keep up the hapless fight.
April 3, 2009 6:37 PM | Reply | Permalink
Hi Karl the Marxist,
I can't speak for all veterans of course, but the ones I have known from the Iraq/Afghanistan wars come out of the military sort of shell-shocked by the real world. For those especially who were line units, meaning, infantry or artillery or another type of job assignment that meant being exposed daily to enemy fire and IEDs--some of them have trouble finding jobs, especially if they went right straight into the military out of high school, as so many do.
They may drift from job to job for a few months, trying to adjust to civilian life and to their veteran's status and to any injuries or psychological wounds they may have suffered, or they may try school, not fit in at first, drop out, and so on. It often takes a second try to get serious about school.
This is not every single one by any means, but it seems to take them, on average, about a year to get adjusted to their new lives. Military life is extremely regimented; you are told where to live and what to wear and what to do and when for four years of your life, and then you are flooded with choices--while, all the time, worried that you might get called up.
I imagine young Ryan fit that description to one extent or another and thought this would be fun and would give him purpose for a while as he sorted out his options and figured out what he wanted to do.
The film seminar seemed to focus him, and his plans had been to enroll in film school in the fall of '09--the new GI Bill benefits for Iraq/Afghanistan vets kicks in then--but he got recalled and had to ditch his plans.
The Real World producers thought that having an Iraq vet in the house would expose their young audiences to another segment of their varied population. They did not know, of course, that the army would have its own plans, but the recall that took place was very instructive for today's young fans of the program.
April 3, 2009 10:37 AM | Reply | Permalink
It's funny that you get all these recommends, but so few comments...People will give you a pat on the back, but still don't quite get it.
April 3, 2009 12:38 PM | Reply | Permalink
Which I think is precisely the point that Deanie is making about the vets. Pats on the back, but the reality is just so difficult to grasp in the context of our everyday lives that people are left kind of speechless, with nothing to offer but meaningless generalizations.
Wow, Ryan, you're a hero. Wow, Deanie, breathtaking article. I'll get back to you on the deep implications as soon as I get the dog to stop eating my kid's homework.
Ca va?
April 3, 2009 1:34 PM | Reply | Permalink
Dorn76 THANK YOU FOR NOTICING!!! I wondered about that too.
April 3, 2009 1:27 PM | Reply | Permalink
Deanie: I think it's not so bad that people don't know what to say. The whole situation leaves many of us at a loss, speechless. And, as you know, I have a stepson deployed right now. I can't talk about it, it's too raw, but I can read your words and find comfort. It's hard to make generalizations about the conditions of those returning home despite the comfort of doing so. It depends on what they saw, what they did, how long they were there, what they left behind, whether they face another deployment. But we do know that many are not coping and we aren't doing enough to help them. My sense is people reading here are humbled by these stories. Recommending without commenting is like putting your hand over your heart, taking off your hat, bowing your head, and shedding a tear. Maybe too little, but for some, including me, it's all we can muster at times. Thanks for another thought provoking post.
Kate
April 3, 2009 3:18 PM | Reply | Permalink
KateO, God bless you dear. You are so incredibly eloquent, always. I know what you mean about the rawness of discussing a loved one who is deployed. You're just so damn terrified all the time.
Privately, my sister accused me of generalizing too much, explaining that many young people really don't know that much about the war, etc.
She may be right, but if I do so, perhaps it is from a place of my OWN anger, my own residue of Post Traumatic Mom-Stress, so to speak. My son was deployed during some of the worst violence of the war; Marines were dying daily, including those he knew, and people kept regaling me about their opinions on the war when I felt like they didn't know what the hell they were talking about.
All they were doing was spouting off support-the-troops crap from the latest Republican talking points, or conversely, from the other end of the spectrum, blaming the troops for being stupid enough to volunteer during a time of war, even though some were already in the service when the war began, and some, like my son, thought they'd be chasing terrorists around Afghanistan but instead wound up in the Anbar. And some just wanted to be able to afford college, you know?
I stayed angry for years and am only just now coming to some sort of grip on the issue, but I suppose...residuals remain.
I will remember your stepson--and you--in my prayers.
April 3, 2009 3:43 PM | Reply | Permalink
Deanie, it's difficult enough thinking about bros from a long time ago. When it is about kids being affected with the war sickness, it reaches almost too deep to express feelings, and I do not desire clouding up the present with the past.
Kind of related: this pissed me off when I first read it, and still causes a bit of ire when thinking about it.
April 3, 2009 4:34 PM | Reply | Permalink
PseudoCyants, that was a fascinating link. Actual minutes of a subcommittee meeting, if I read correctly (always got the news on in the background), and the two pieces of business were to (a) stop referring to life insurance payments of war dead as "death gratuity" and start referring to them as "fallen hero fund" or somethinng like that and (b)setting aside yet more millions for yet more huge Defense industry fat-cat contractors.
I didn't notice the date on this, but of course Sen. Stevens is no longer there, thank God, and I do think that SecDef Gates is trying to buck that system of procurement and do what he can to streamline the DoD budget, as is Obama. Notice has been served and contracts are already being scaled back.
That said, I totally understand what you are referring to about the sadness of seeing the young suffer as you guys did; it makes you feel bad all over again. I have spoken to a pschologist who is in charge of a clinic employing something like 75 shrinks, and some of the work they do is with vets, and he told me that there is no question that all of this is hard on Vietnam mets.
You did not say you served but I know you did and I thank you for your service, my friend. And don't worry about these kids. Most of them are going to be all right, as were most of you guys.
April 3, 2009 5:20 PM | Reply | Permalink
The date was October 5, 2005. It's an HTML mark-up of Congressional Daily Records, when the McCain anti-torture amendment to the Department Of Defense Appropriations Act, 2006 was ratified in the Senate 90-9. It's my work, and is titled "Nine Senators of Shame". The reason should be obvious...
If you have javascript enabled in your browser, you should see a moving navigation bar on the left. If not, scroll to the top of the page, and it should be visible stationary there. You might enjoy my Op/Ed regarding this. Against All Enemies, foreign and Domestic. Even when they are nine immoral Senators.
April 3, 2009 6:29 PM | Reply | Permalink
I think there are so few comments because most people, like me, don't know what to say.
Most of us are not touched by these wars because such a small percentage of the population is bearing all the sacrifice (1% of U.S. population is serving in Afghanistan and Iraq).
I had no idea there was so much mental anguish in the veteran populaiton. Although I have participated in drives to provide CARE packages to overseas military, I don't know anyone in the military. I now realize how oblivious I have been.
It's true, no sacrifices have been asked of me -- my taxes have been cut and I have not had to bear any overt monetary sacrifices to fund these wars. I may pay a price later, but I'm not thinking about that now.
I think if the American people had more input, e.g., sacrificing time, money, etc., we would be more engaged in the sacrifices that our military is making.
How quickly we move on. Just last week President Obama held a press conference and there was not one question about Iraq or Afghanistan.
I guess I, like a lot of Americans, have moved on.
April 3, 2009 2:42 PM | Reply | Permalink
Thank you for your honesty, DeeCee, and I think you are right. This is the first war in American history where, not only has there been no war-tax to help pay for it, but there've been tax CUTS. I think no small part of the anger I mentioned to KateO had to do with warmongers being only too eager to pose with the troops if it made a good photo-op or campaign ad and then privately cutting any kind of real support from them. In my son's first deployment, the Battle of Fallujah in Nov. '04, those guys not on foot patrol rode around in open-ended unarmored Humvees without proper body armor or firearms...and they'd watch the Blackwater pirates parading around in state-of-the-art gear.
Like I say. You just stay mad for years. Don't mean to take it out on nice people like you!!!
April 3, 2009 3:47 PM | Reply | Permalink
Mad is good. That's where you are now that you are no longer paralyzed with fear every day all day. Those of us with family still there want you to be mad. Keep reminding people, keep telling the stories. As you know, when it's happening to your family, you use all your strength in the moment. You've paid a high price in your family--you have earned the right to be mad as hell. Don't stop.
April 3, 2009 3:57 PM | Reply | Permalink
Thank you so much for that, KateO.
I'm going to start writing a great deal on the war in Afghanistan from the POV not just of the troops but of Obama's plan. I was so busy with the election that I saved up 6 months of back articles on it to read, and read them all in chronological order at a place where my car was being fixed. It gave me a great perspective, along with the books and stuff I'd already read.
And my family members who've served there or are likely to in the future.
I think Afghanistan has been horribly neglected--forgotten, really--and I intend to turn my attention there because, again, I keep reading opinions of people who really don't understand anything. At least that's how it strikes me.
Not that I have all the answers, but I do have family still directly affected by policy, which gives me great motivation to understand, or try to, anyway, as best I can.
I don't know if anybody will be very interested, here in the 8th year of the war and all, but I'll give it my best shot.
April 3, 2009 5:11 PM | Reply | Permalink
Deanie you mentioned that returning vets feel "alienation" and are "shell shocked by the real world." That is really key to understanding how returning veterans feel. I served a year in Vietnam. While there, we called the United States "The World". The implication was that while we were in Vietnam we were not in the real world. However, upon returning, most vets have feelings that are exactly opposite. The United States seemed sureal. Reality feels like acting in a school play. The things people are laughing at aren't funny. Vets, especially combat veterans, feel very detached. There is something about being in a life and death situation that makes reality "super real." When that "super real" situation ends, a kind of down, sureal feeling follows. I think this happens to other than combat veterans. People in bad car wrecks, or who were taken hostage can have similar feelings. That feeling subdues after a passage of time.
April 3, 2009 6:28 PM | Reply | Permalink
Faroff, you described it perfectly; thank you for that.
And yes, the feeling does tend to get better over time. My husband coped with his Vietnam combat experience by going out to West Texas and working on one of the huge ranches for several years, riding horseback all day. It was as real as it gets but eased him back into being around lots of people, which is also difficult for returning vets.
My son hiked the Grand Canyon and then climbed Pike's Peak--all in his first week out of the service! He tried several jobs for a few months, including off-shore drilling, before settling down, and again, being more or less alone for a while was helpful, as was a patient and understanding girlfriend and accepting family. He now has a steady job and is applying for graduate school. He says it takes about a year to get your equilibrium back.
But my husband says that, to a certain extent, combat vets feel set apart from everyone else pretty much all their lives. They can lead successful, social lives, have happy marriages and so on (as he has done), but they will always look at the world, well, differently. And appreciate it more.
Cleaning off a bookshelf recently, I found some Vietnam mementoes of his, including this quote, written in his own hand on the page of a notebook he carried as a young platoon leader:
FOR THOSE WHO FOUGHT AND SAW THEIR COMRADES DIE FOR IT, FREEDOM HAS A TASTE THE PROTECTED WILL EVER KNOW.
April 3, 2009 7:03 PM | Reply | Permalink
Apathy and what Gore Vidal coined as "American Amnesia" has afflicted US citizens throughout the history of the Nation. From John Brown to Malachi Ritscher, individuals have attempted to shock folks awake.
Who is Malachi Ritscher?
"Malachi Ritscher envisioned his death as one full of purpose. He carefully planned the details, mailed a copy of his apartment key to a friend, created to-do lists for his family. On his Web site, the 52-year-old experimental musician who'd fought with depression even penned his obituary.
"At 6:30 a.m. on Nov. 3 2006-- four days before an election caused a seismic shift in Washington politics-- Ritscher, a frequent anti-war protester, stood by an off-ramp in downtown Chicago near a statue of a giant flame, set up a video camera, doused himself with gasoline and lit himself on fire.
"Aglow for the crush of morning commuters, his flaming body was supposed to be a call to the nation, a symbol of his rage and discontent with the U.S. war in Iraq.
""Here is the statement I want to make: if I am required to pay for your barbaric war, I choose not to live in your world. I refuse to finance the mass murder of innocent civilians, who did nothing to threaten our country," he wrote in his suicide note. "... If one death can atone for anything, in any small way, to say to the world: I apologize for what we have done to you, I am ashamed for the mayhem and turmoil caused by my country."
"There was only one problem: No one was listening."
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malachi_Ritscher)
I think we need to listen more and do something about it.
April 3, 2009 6:49 PM | Reply | Permalink
That reminds me of the Bhuddist monk who set himself afire outside the Pentagon in 1968 for the same reason.
It didn't change anything then and it won't change anything now. While my heart goes out to this tortured man, the fact remains that there are certainly smarter ways, and more effective ways, to end a war.
April 3, 2009 7:08 PM | Reply | Permalink
What needed to be said was largely said in the piece - I wouldn't take the lack of comments relative to the number of recommends as more than agreement with readers being perhaps somewhat at a loss, and not necessarily having anything to contribute.
The one thing that occurred to me is something Al Franken used to emphasize in his radio show. If this effort (minimally defined as stabilizing Iraq, Afghan/Pakistan sufficiently that they don't harbor organizing forces capable of attacking the US) is as important as Pres. Bush & Cheney were saying it was (and it was and IS, especially after they [political leadership] botched it and made things worse) - then why weren't they preparing the American people to really 'fight' this like a new cold war level effort.
Not tax cuts and go shopping (while we hide the costs in monetary and human terms).
Not minimize the impact of the war on the public to cheap yellow ribbon on your SUV patriotism and bullshit bravado that can be drummed up to label Republicans Patriots and critics as unpatriotic.
Not continue to feed money into the whole region to folks who DO have reasons to hate the US and will use some of that money to support terror and insurgencies (instead of using the willingness of the American citizenry after 9/11 to do something like BEAR the costs of reducing our reliance on oil).
To DICK and George and the gaggle of Neocon thinkers who NEVER served in the military for real... the military - their volunteers, fuck 'em, their a tool just like a ship or a plane. Hey, why not even privatize and outsource it so we don't even have to worry about 'veterans'.
US Servicemen and Women were tools and props to those fuckers... trying to actually recruit, enlist, and use American resources on a scale effective to the task might have caused a few too many people to actually question the decision and more quickly reduced the support the war.
April 3, 2009 7:22 PM | Reply | Permalink
jofga--WOW, you make me feel better by expressing my own rage in no-nonsense terms.
I was so outraged that the architects of this war were chickenhawks, and so enraged that even Iraq vets who criticized the war were attacked by yet more chickenhawks as not having somehow been REAL.
(I'd like to see just ONE of those mofos spend a DAY on the streets of Fallujah in '04 or '06 as my son did and see how long it took them to run screaming as fast as they could.)
And it pleases me no end to note that it was Al Franken NOT RUSH LIMBAUGH who repeatedly flew into harm's way to entertain the troops in Iraq and Afghanistan, many times.
You know how I feel and thank you for that.
April 4, 2009 11:38 AM | Reply | Permalink