« Cairo: George Bush gets his lipstick | David Seaton's Blog | The European elections »

"Feeling the Hate"... looking on the bright side



This is certainly the year that a lot of stereotypes have bitten the dust: of course the top of the list of broken prejudices is symbolized by our president, Barack Obama, the first person of known African descent to occupy the Oval Office and soon we will have the first Hispanic Supreme Court Justice.

This is wonderful. But the destruction of other stereotypes, though they fill the observer with wonder are anything but wonderful.

Max Blumenthal's little film "Feeling the Hate" has broken more stereotypes for me, personally, than the election of Barack Obama or the nomination of Sonia Sotomayor to the Supreme Court.

The success of either Obama or Sotomayor is no surprise to me on racial or ethnic grounds, as I have never thought that the color of a person's skin or ethnic origin had any bearing on their ability to carry out the duties and responsibilities of high office.

However, I also never thought I would ever hear Jewish people throw the word "nigger" around with such practiced aplomb as in this video.

As a matter of fact, I don't ever remember seeing a Jewish person as drunk as those portrayed in Blumenthal's interviews in my whole life; in my youth it was proverbial that, "Jews don't drink": getting roaring drunk was something that was left to brutish, wife-beating, Polish peasants and to feral Russian Cossacks.

So here, thanks to Mr. Blumenthal, we have a group of future "my son the doctor(s)" and Jewish Princesses, stumbling drunk, talking with the same disgusting bigotry as the Polish peasants and Russian Cossacks that used to rape their great grandmothers or the rednecks that spat on the Jewish Freedom riders in the 1960s or that lynched Leo Frank.

To whom do we owe this transformation, this leveling?

To the USA?

To Israel?

In the words of a great American poet, "C'est la vie say the old folks, it goes to show you never can tell".


19 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Really shocking. There are some prejudiced members of my family but not even they would feel so comfortable revealing their bigotry so openly in public or even at a family gathering. I've seen them pretty drunk and nothing this raw has ever come out.

user-pic

Reform Jews, maybe? NASCAR Jews?

user-pic

To prosperity. Now that these particular individuals feel safely ensconced on the inside, they feel comfortable labeling and dehumanizing those on the outside.

user-pic

Implicit in your post is a sentiment that I hope most viewers of this video agree with. What struck me most is that, if you move this video from Jewish Jerusalem to Daytona Beach or Lake Havasu, you'd get almost an identical reaction from the blonde and suntanned drunken Baptist and Catholic college kids.

I think this video is needlessly provocative, and and unfair slur against Jews. Uninhibited drunken post-adolescents are aggressively obnoxious wherever you find them. To suggest that the dozen or so people portrayed in the video are unique in their attitudes or the way they express them is extremely dishonest in my opinion. They are, unfortunately, more representative of smugly entitled upper-middle-class Americans than of any other group.

I, too, having been told that Jews, as well as Europeans generally, don't drink to excess like people from Eastern Europe or (my ancestral home) the UK, was quite surprised at how drunk these children of Abraham were.

user-pic

It's probably the cocaine they take. Cocaine is known to lower the barriers against over-consumption of alcohol and has led to many Jews becoming alcoholics.

By the way, the video is not an unfair slur by Max Blumenthal. Blumenthal just did an interview with an up and coming member of the Knesset, who was sober as a judge. The Knesset member, Alex Miller, portrayed the same phenomena depicted in the video. Bottom line: It's real and it's a problem.

user-pic

I did not see that as a slur against Jews or Israelis as much as an example of what we have to look forward to experiencing if this is what the next generation has to offer. Do ya think these folks were Republicans in the US? Any chance at all?

user-pic

Blumenthal's subsequent post adds some good context to the video. In fact, it's much more persuasive than the video itself:

http://maxblumenthal.com/2009/06/censored-by-the-huffington-post-imprisoned-by-the-past-why-i-made-feeling-the-hate-in-jerusalem/

user-pic

Thanks for this link. It is very illuminating to read what Max has to say about the video. Upon reflection, I think the vid represents a particular kind of attitude I see in lots of young Americans who are essentially ignorant,selfish, self-absorbed, but loudmouthed fools. Still, the video is very disturbing and I think should not be dismissed.

user-pic

I don't know that one can make the assumption that they are republicans as you seem to imply. One person in the video claimed to have worked for Obama.

user-pic

I think what makes this video more relevant than a bunch of drunken frat boys acting up in Florida is that, as we have seen in Gaza, the Israelis are "acting out" on what we see expressed here.

user-pic

There can be nothing unfair about filming what you see and broadcasting what you film, as long as you don't present the film as being something different than it is. When Blumenthal posted the film on Mondoweiss, he said that the video showed "rowdy groups of beer sodden twenty-somethings, many from the United States, and all eager to vent their visceral, even violent hatred of Barack Obama and his policies towards Israel."

That seems to be an entirely fair description.

user-pic

The problem is that we have seen so many people simply talking out of their ass we have lost our respect for the truth. Truth is optional. The PoliSci major knows what she is talking about, but doesn't know who Netanyahu is?!?!? Her lips were moving, but the sounds were coming straight from her ass.

user-pic

Good comment. Palin said in recent days the Feds would lend money to states, then bail them out to take them over so everyone had better be scared. When political leaders (of sorts) have so little concern about about what might be true and what might not, what are we to expect from 20-year-old drunken jerks?

user-pic

We owe this to the fact that everyone is human and no group is immune from adopting bigoted, ignorant attitudes about other humans, etc... Being a member of a particular group does not determine whether or not one will or will not display bigoted stupidity. Young, drunk people never represent the best of whatever group they may belong to has to offer...

Whether it is part of the Borat film with the young drunks in the RV or Girls Gone Wild or one of the Princes of the UK, people say and do stupid things all the time, especially when drinking, that they would likely never do otherwise. Still, it is not a pretty picture, but then such behavior never is.

user-pic

They were American Jews, at least one of whom didn't know who Netanyahu is. Perhaps that's the difference.

user-pic

'in vino veritas' applies to beer, too. While some of those interviewed may well have acted out a bit, unless the interviews were staged the sentiments are clear. They are very afraid of losing something, and that fear leads them into aggression.

user-pic

So do you have anything to say about the election that just happened in Spain where The Right-wing Popular Party gained 42.2 per cent of the votes winning 23 seats in the European Parliament compared to the ruling Socialist party's 38.5 per cent and 21 seats.? Is it really only the U.S. that is fucked up in your opinion, as it appears from the general record of this blog? (A reminder: George Bush lost the majority vote in his first election and won by a squeak in his second. And we currently have a healthy Democratic majority in both houses of government as well as a Democratic president.)

user-pic

In the European elections abstention is very high and the party in power usually get whipped by the the mobilized base of the opposition party coming out en masse. This has had the perverse effect this time of consolidating the conservative leader, Mariano Rajoy, who is so unattractive that even most of his own party think he has no chance against Zapatero in the general elections three years from now.

In general the problem right now with the European left is that they have not shown that they have a coherent critique of the system, which is what the voter of the left really wants from them. Until they produce that critique or the ultra-right makes more significant gains that frighten them sufficiently many left wing voters will simply abstain.

You could say that the years of Thatcher-Reagan-Friedman have intellectually castrated the left. This is a problem in Europe, whereas the progressive voter in the USA is quite happy with neutered tom cats.

user-pic

It's important to clarify that the USA's Democrats are not really a party of the "left" in European terms. The reforms that the Democrats timidly put forward, like universal(?) health care and reasonably tight financial regulations are defended by European conservatives.

It is also interesting to note that the one figure of the left who did well in the elections was the "Green", Daniel Cohn-Bendit, who couldn't be fitted into any American party imaginable.

Leave a comment

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address