Right off the bat, Judge Sotomayor is a very shrewd pick. but not only that, she is going to confirmed and she is going to be a very good Supreme Court Justice.
Having said that, she seems to be offering conservatives what is perhaps their first real opportunity since the election to get a hearing from from the American people, to leave a message with independents and with some of the white working class base that deserted them in November... if only they can avoid being loud, vicious and nasty. This is a tall order for a party which seems to be bent on its self-destruction, and totally in the hands of the Libaughs and Gingriches but maybe if they listen to the few of their number who still have some functioning gray matter left, they might just pull it off.
I found it interesting that perhaps the two conservative opinion mongers with the most bandwidth, Peggy Noonan and Charles Krauthammer coincide in their analysis of the opportunity that Judge Sotomayor offers the Republicans.
Peggy Noonan
lays it out, all sweetness and light:
Don't grill and grandstand, summon and inform. Show the respect that
expresses equality and the equality that is an expression of respect.
Ask and listen, get the logic, explain where you think it wrong. Fill
the airwaves with thoughtful exchanges.
In case you don't catch her drift, Charles Krauthammer, as is his wont, goes for the carotid artery right from
the first line of his column:
Sonia Sotomayor has a classic American story. So does Frank Ricci.
Ricci is a New Haven firefighter stationed seven blocks from where
Sotomayor went to law school (Yale). Raised in blue-collar Wallingford,
Conn., Ricci struggled as a C and D student in public schools
ill-prepared to address his serious learning disabilities. Nonetheless
he persevered, becoming a junior firefighter and Connecticut's youngest
certified EMT.
After studying fire science at a community college, he became a New
Haven "truckie," the guy who puts up ladders and breaks holes in
burning buildings. When his department announced exams for promotions,
he spent $1,000 on books, quit his second job so he could study eight
to 13 hours a day and, because of his dyslexia, hired someone to read
him the material.
He placed sixth on the lieutenant's exam, which qualified him for
promotion. Except that the exams were thrown out by the city, and all
promotions denied, because no blacks had scored high enough to be
promoted.
Ricci (with 19 others) sued.
That's where these two American stories intersect. Sotomayor was a
member of the three-member circuit court panel that upheld the
dismissal of his case, thus denying Ricci his promotion.
If the Republicans can only not forget to take their meds, they have the chance of turning the the Sonia Sotomayor hearings into the Frank Ricci hearings.
As Krauthammer tells it, it is one of the most unfair things I have ever heard in my life, you would have to have a heart of stone to be unmoved or angered by it, if all there is to it, is what Krauthammer tells.
So the Democrats had better be prepared to defend the Ricci decision, without trying to personally trash Frank Ricci. Fireman Ricci is not,
repeat not, to be confused with Joe "the plumber".
Noonan describes Sotmayor thus:
Politically she's like a beautiful doll containing a canister of poison gas: Break her and you die.
The same is perfectly true of Frank Ricci, "break him and you die".
This game will have to be played with care.