I'm assuming, of course, her performance last night was a comment on the current state of consumer culture. A neo-marxist critique of our spectacled society gone bad, the dropping of pretense about image and look and performance and art. A scathing remark on the culture of the celebrity, where everyone wants to be Someone, yet no One is Someone...
If not, wow, that really, like, blew chunks.
But if there's anything we learned from last night's MTV Video Music Awards, it's that the state of pop music today is...not really any different than the state of pop music at any other time in recent history.
For music "aficionados" (of course, ignore the subjectivity of music and its appreciation for now...), pop music, especially reflected in pop culture venues like the VMAs and the Grammy awards, always has a frustrating mix of marketing-driven only-in-it-for-the-money monstrosities, mixed in with some damn good talent.
And last night's show was no different. Plenty of hacks: Rhianna and the "Umbrella" song, which I just don't get; Alicia Keys, who simply bores me; the Britney meltdown, of course.
But Chris Brown's dancing was top notch (despite the overt reference to Michael Jackson: why do we need a "new" Michael Jackson?). And Justin Timberlake can actually sing! And, for my money, Kayne West, who also performed last night, is one of the most talented and prolific performers out there today. In fact, his mix of music and outspoken political activism is in the grand tradition of folk artists such as Woody Guthrie and Bob Dylan; he's just doing it with a different style. (Just like Public Enemy did, before him...)
Maybe it just seems like it gets harder and harder to sift through the bad to get to the good each year. I'm not sure how different that is, though, than the state of music over the last 30 or so years, as we lament the current state of the music industry. We remember the Led Zeppelin and REM, and seem to always forget the cheezy one-hit wonders of the day.
Today, in fact, thanks to the Internet and the rise of the indie label, there's more opportunity for bands out there, and lots of great music to choose from.
Spend some time listening to Seattle's KEXP to hear what's going on -- hardly a band you'll see on MTV.