Giving in to the urge not to make this a horse race...
Edwards clearly had the best performance last night. Not a Breck Girl, but articulate, bold, and substantive. Huge points in my mind for talking about raising taxes.
Hillary was...well, Hillary. Solid. Polished. (The chatterheads on MSNBC appeared stunned that she is not a frothing liberal. Duh.) But I don't think she at all changed minds about her.
Obama? A real disappointment. It wasn't until the end, when he got a bit confrontational and mixed it up, did he start to shine. His strength is his smarts, along with his ability to speak to us "regular" folk, and that did not at all come through. He unfortunately sounded like a politician.
Biden was actually pretty good, and he may just have the best idea on what to do about Iraq. Richardson also had a good performance, and I think left us wanted to hear more from him.
Kucinich may be a lot of things, but he does not come across as a "Healer" for America. I thought that really bombed. If he wants to be taken more seriously, then he needs to stick to the Constitution-in-his-pocket tack.
Dodd needs to distinguish himself.
And Gravel? Really, who let that guy on the stage? He just seemed angry, and the notion that America has no enemies was just way too far out there, even for a bleeding heart liberal like myself.
As far as the format, it was terrible, and a real disservice to the candidates. Too rushed and too made-for-TV, it did not allow for substance and debate, encouraging instead soundbites rather than ideas.