Good luck, Senator McCain. After your speech, I really think you're gonna need it.
During my small break from TPM while it got over its absurd and blatant Palin panic, I have been pondering the overall success of the Republican Convention. The issue, of course, is how we measure "success". I personally believe that success, for both Conventions, was the ability to bring in undecided and independent voters. Simple enough, and I think that's how most would define it.
That was obviously what the Democrats were trying to accomplish, and by all accounts, did a fantastic job. I have seen nothing to suggest that the Democratic Convention did not meet, exceed, and then blow away all expectations.
Which is why I was slightly worried about the Republican Convention. Certainly after the DNC, the RNC would push itself to be better, right? Perhaps. But I personally think that the RNC failed in a major way. Rather than forming itself to be new, inclusive, and painting a picture of a new and better America for all people, it formed itself around the notion of pure partisanship. That's why, despite my original worries going into the RNC, I am more confident than ever in Barack Obama's ability to win this election.
As we all know, Registered Democrats far outnumber Registered Republicans. So the only way John McCain was going to successfully run his campaign, was to appeal to those hard sought-after "swing voters". But is that what the RNC did? I find it absolutely impossible to argue that it did. The major speeches highlighting the Convention were fiercely partisan. The ones the voters will remember were not only fiercely partisan, but fiercely negative.
The two most important speeches of the Convention, Sarah Palin's and John McCain's, were both failures. There's no arguing that Palin successfully expressed herself and her ideas, but I again find it difficult to argue that she made any huge inroads to bringing in new voters. But that speech has been dissected enough.
The real big speech was (supposed to be) McCain's, and since people vote for the top of the ticket, it's the one that should have made the most impact. But it didn't. It was horrible, and it did nothing to allay the fears that so many voters must be facing right now concerning the economy.
I think of every analysis I've thus read on the speech, Al Giordano hit the nail on the head.
"John McCain delivered a terrible speech tonight, and as I said in the previous thread, it was reminiscent of Jimmy Carter's in 1980 for it's brain-dead platitudes atop a milquetoast delivery, all with the stench of a born loser, that left Independents and swing voters empty handed, wondering what the fuck?"
I highly suggest you read the rest of his entry.
Where some may be praising McCain's speech right now, praise within the moment and the partisan attitude of the Xcel Center is different than the impact the speech will have on undecided and independent swing voters in the long run. I have no doubt that McCain will see a bounce in the national polls in the next couple of days. But in the long run, which is always what Obama has been planning for, McCain is going to have a very difficult time convincing the voters he needs to convince to vote for him.
McCain has decided, after a summer of hammering Obama as an inexperienced elitist celebrity, to now, at this time, try to disassociate himself from that message, and instead claim that he, not Obama, is the real person to bring change. But he's running on an Obama-lite message under the assumption that 2008 is 2004. And it's not. I cannot kick the fact that two themes pervaded the Republican Convention: "Obama is bad" and "We need to fight the terrorists".
Why so little focus on the economy? Why so little focus on actual policies? Because McCain, like Bush in 2004, is trying to rally his base in order to win, and his base doesn't care about the policies, nor do they consider the economy and the middle class as the most important issues. But this is not 2004. Democrats are excited about their candidate. They are going to vote in higher numbers than they did in 2004. They are more excited and committed to winning. They do realize what's at stake. And more than that, the American people as a whole hunger for change, and hunger for a better America than the one they've had since 2000.
McCain, who had a chance to really prove his independence, to prove himself as a maverick, and to offer real solutions to America's economic troubles, blew it. McCain and the Republicans may believe this election is not about the issues, but the voters they need to win do. And unfortunately for McCain, he blew his best chance to win them over.
Yes, there will be debates. Yes, there will be other events in the coming weeks that could drastically change the direction of the campaign. But McCain blew his last chance to establish his candidacy, and the true message of his candidacy. Good luck, Senator McCain. After your speech, I really think you're gonna need it.









