« Stevens Trial Juror Lied About Father Dying | Chris Brown's Blog | Breaking - Obama Brings Barber Onto Transition Team »
Media and Bloggers Hoaxed
Remember the Paling didn't realize Africa is a continent and didn't know the countries signatory to NAFTA?
The NYT reports all of the reports were hoaxes perpetrated by a couple of really creative guys and that some of the hoaxes were passed on by media outlets and bloggers after Sourcewatch had already identified the hoaxsters.
On Monday the answer popped up on a blog and popped out of the mouth of David Shuster, an MSNBC anchor. "Turns out it was Martin Eisenstadt, a McCain policy adviser, who has come forward today to identify himself as the source of the leaks," Mr. Shuster said.Remember the reports of members of Paris Hilton's family complaining to the McCain campaign for its use of Ms. Hilton's name in ads attacking Obama? Remember the reports that Joe the Plumber is related to Charles Keatings?
The NYT reports all of the reports were hoaxes perpetrated by a couple of really creative guys and that some of the hoaxes were passed on by media outlets and bloggers after Sourcewatch had already identified the hoaxsters.
Advertisement





Remember when we all thought Barack Obama won the election. Oh. Wait...
November 12, 2008 8:26 PM | Reply | Permalink
only two links allowed in a comment, so this comment will be continued in a reply below
November 12, 2008 11:56 PM | Reply | Permalink
continuation of the above
November 13, 2008 12:02 AM | Reply | Permalink
further continuation:
Not to mention "about 219,000" results on google for "Palin continent Africa"
I remember a "goodbye cruel world" post by early adopter of blogging, Chris Allbritton (BacktoIraq.com,) who said he was too disgusted to participate any more in a medium where Iraq war rumors got around the world on the internet before the truth could get its boots on. It was after some pretty pernicious rumors about some atrocities that were all hearsay and keyboard anti-U.S. warriors in their jammies hyper-analyzing fake videos or something like that. He knew the allegations to be fake from "on the ground" reporting, but he was getting blasted by lots of the keyboardists as a imperialist lackey for saying so. l He came back, but he took a couple of months before he did. And a favorite theme of his after that was: blogging is not reporting without boots on the ground, and most blogging is just like the game of telephone, where the more times a story is removed from the source, the worse for the truth.
When people brag about something going "viral," I automatically presume it is spin respun a 1,000 times until it's proven otherwise. It's no coincidence that marketers of products think viral meme spread is the best thing since sliced bread.
Related rant. I am real picky, I guess. It even irritates me when people cite secondary reporting instead of the original, i.e., an A.P. story that starts out "The New York Times" is reporting..." You know the original story is at The New York Times, don't just read and quote the A.P. on it, trusting them to get it right, go and read the frigging original. This is also part of the reason why when I read a great article, I might recommend it in a blog entry, but I am loathe to add my own spin to it to the recommend. I know that this bugs some people, but if it's good, why should I add a layer of spin? I just don't get why people want introductory spin on something already published, it truly ends up to spinning one's wheels, you're adding layers that have to be unpeeled.
November 13, 2008 12:04 AM | Reply | Permalink
On the other hand there is some stunningly good original reporting presented on blogs, such as by Laura Rozen and TPM, for example. And Brad DeLong and Robert Reich, as well as others, provide very interesting analysis relative to economic matters. Likewise if I want authoritative commentary on all things Middle East I go read Juan Cole. There are other examples related to other subjects; but I agree, in the main the blogosphere is as much of an echo chamber as is the traditional media.
November 13, 2008 12:40 AM | Reply | Permalink