« Here's hoping to peace in Iran. | cavilling_elite's Blog | Talkback: Free market works, keep unnecessary government regulations out. »

Please Government: Protect me from myself!


With the overwhelming response of Congress to pass the US tobacco regulation bill, it gets me thinking: "What won't they regulate?"

So many things are done "for the children", so it comes as no surprise to me that the tobacco bill talks about banning even more ads that are targeting school children. What? When? And Where? I have never seen an advertisement that when I looked at it I said, "Screw my lungs and health, that is awesome!". (Where is Tony Hawk when you need him?)

But thanks to Congress' increasing distance from reality, we now will have FDA regulated cigarettes.

"Tobacco is such a serious and compelling public health problem, and we really do feel by being able to regulate tobacco and tobacco products we can reduce the burden of disease and help promote stronger smoking cessation efforts," Hamburg told reporters.
So you need this bill so you can then stop people from smoking? How about drinking? How about eating fatty steaks? In the US 936,923 people died in 2001 from Major Cardiovascular Diseases. Seems like the next "save me" bill that we need.

The facts are these:
  • To non-smokers, like myself, smoking is annoying.
  • Smoking is dangerous to your health and increases risks
  • Smoking is a turn off to a lot of people, decreasing your chances of relationships
But at the end of the day, smoking is the SMOKERS choice. They know it is dangerous, they know it can be addictive, they know it can eventually kill them. But you know what I do when I am confronted with a smoker? I move! I cross the street, I don't eat at that restaurant, I don't frequent that bar. And I support establishments that have non-smoking policies BY THEIR OWN CHOICE.*

A year or so back, President Bush vetoed a bill to tax cigarettes and give the money to children's insurance. This was another overstep of Congresses boundaries taxing a "bad" thing and giving it to a "good" thing. I supported President Bush's veto. Obama has expanded this program.

"Critics like Siegel said the bill did not go far enough.

Lawmakers could have banned nicotine as well as popular mint-flavored menthol cigarettes, raised the legal age to buy tobacco products from 18 to 21 and restricted sales to certain stores, much like alcohol, Siegel said." (emphasis mine)

I'm sick and tired of government's implied duty to save me from myself.

Well smokers, enjoy your shitty light cigarettes or go online and find some real Mexican brand cigarettes. At least until they finish regulating the internet.

*Side note:
Government should have no ability to regulate private businesses to stop allowing patrons to smoke in their establishments. Also, the government should have no ability to force a private business to make patrons do anything. It is up to the business owner and that is all. In a public/government owned building or situation, by all means.

If you want to see a change, then give tax benefits to business that allow a completely non-smoking environment.

6 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Interesting. Should the government have the ability to regulate private businesses to make them prevent customers from spitting on the floor? I mean, what if some people really LIKE spitting on the floor, and just won't go to a restaurant that won't let them? Doesn't a restaurant have the right to decide that its business model will consist of catering to that particular demographic?

How about those government regulations that require restaurants to refuse service to customer who aren't wearing shoes? Against those too? I mean, sure, it's a public-health issue, but the government has no right to put concerns about public health above the convenience of people who want to do things that are bad for other people, right?

user-pic

I hope the restaurant that lets people spit on the floor is the same one that caters to bare-foot people! Oh! And that same restaurant can also allow concealed weapons! Wow, This IS fun!

user-pic

The bill is the greatest idea since sliced bread.

The FDA will halve the allowable nicotine in cigarettes; smokers will buy twice as many packs as they did before; and government's tax revenues will double.

user-pic

I've yet to meet a non-youthful smoker who doesn't wish they hadn't started. From a freedom of choice perspective, nicotine is a chemically addictive drug. As such, nicotine itself takes away much of your freedom of choice over its use.

You might be thinking, so what's the difference between smoking and overeating, or having unprotected sex, or sky diving, or any other "risky" behavior? Well, as I once heard Mike Malloy say on air, tobacco is the only legal product that gives you life-threatening diseases when used as intended by it's producer.

user-pic


http://www.newsy.com/videos/new_sheriff_in_town

Newsy.com says the FDA is going to hurt its credibility without some sweeping changes to the tobacco industry. Tobacco is a huge burden on the tax payers who are left footing the bill for all the health issues tobacco causes.

user-pic

Do you also disagree with helmet and seat-belt laws? Because we all pay for head-injured, and broken-bodied people who flout those laws; our insurance rates go up to cover their long-term care, and eventually when they end up on Medicaid, it comes out of our taxes too.

The tobacco companies actually add in addictive chemicals, which are separate from the tobacco itself. It's not quite as simple as you portray here, elite.

Leave a comment

cavilling_elite

user-pic

Following: 2
Followers: 1

Posts
Comments & Recommends


  • Location Milwaukee, WI

Favorites

  • Favorite Blogs
    Pharyngula
    Glenn Greenwald
  • Favorite Books
    His Dark Materials by Philip Pullman
    Federalist and Anti-Federalist Papers
    God is not great by Christopher Hitchens
    God Delusion by Richard Dawkins
    The Origin of Species by Charles Darwin
    Thus Spoke Zarathustra by Friedrich Nietzsche
  • Favorite Quotes "Enlighten the people, generally, and tyranny and oppressions of body and mind will vanish like spirits at the dawn of day." -Thomas Jefferson

Bio

I am an electrical engineer at the Medical College of Wisconsin. Over the years I have grown in my knowledge, opinions and outspokenness of technology, politics and social issues.

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address