« Handwritten letters to Senators | CarlBentham's Blog | List of Dem Senators who oppose, don't support the public option »

Time to consider the Nuclear Option for Health Care?


Democrats got all red in the face with indignation a few years ago when Bill Frist threatened to use the nuclear option to push through W's judicial nominees. (After the nuclear option is used, only 51 votes would be needed to end a filibuster instead of 60.)  It's a politically thorny subject, but I think it's time to be blatantly hypocritical and put the nuclear option on the table.  Democrats must go all-in on health care.  It would arguably be the most important legislation of the century, and it would justify a change in Senate rules much more than mere lower-court judicial nominations.  Also, what's the point of protecting the 60-vote cloture requirement?  It paralyzes our legislative branch and is the principal reason the Senate is the World's Worst Deliberative Body.  I would be glad to see it go, even down the road when Republicans control Congress. 

But if it's going to be done, it needs to be a suprise tactic.  If Republicans get wind of the plan, they'd immediately flood the airwaves and force Democrats to defend it.  That would be bad.  Instead, the Dem leadership should meet secretly with Democratic senators and Joe Biden to prepare them to vote for the option when the motion arises.  Then, when the bill is on the floor, Democrats can swiftly and brutally move to an immediate vote.  Game, set, and match. 

It's a long shot, and there are other ways to pass health care reform, but I do hope Democrats keep this one in the back pocket.    

Leave a comment

CarlBentham

user-pic

Following: 6
Followers: 10

Posts
Comments & Recommends


  • Location Philadelphia, PA
  • Party Democratic
  • Politics I am a progressive, pseudo-utilitarian, rationalist, pragmatist, secular humanist, and skeptic. For all of you metaphysicists, I am a mereological nihilist.

Favorites

  • Favorite Blogs Ezra Klein, Matthew Yglesias, the Wonk Room, Paul Krugman's blog,
  • Favorite Quotes *"If a human disagrees with you, let him live. In a hundred billion galaxies, you will not find another." --Carl Sagan *"[Philosophers] pose as if they had discovered and reached their real opinions through the self-development of a cold, pure, divinely unconcerned dialectic...; while at bottom it is an assumption, a hunch, indeed a kind of “inspiration”—most often a desire of the heart that has been filtered and made abstract—that they defend with reasons they have sought after the fact." --Friedrich Nietzsche *"There are two ways to live your life. The first is as though everything is a miracle. The second is as though nothing is a miracle." --Albert Einstein

Bio

My profile picture is not of me- it is of the great Carl Sagan, who was a great inspiration to me. Go read one of his books or watch his PBS series 'Cosmos'.

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address