Note to David Frum: if you can't solo, stick with the chorus
Yesterday I tuned in to Marketplace on my NPR affiliate and caught the American Enterprise Institute's David Frum opining on Obama's economic plan. His mournful lament began as expected, but midway through the stanza on the evils of government spending he abruptly launched into improvisation.
Frum smartly identified -- drumroll, please -- wage stagnation as one of our chief economic ills. To me, this seemed akin to playing Epistrophy at a Salieri concert, or uttering "Voldemort" before the Hogwarts assembly. But my man was just getting warmed up.
Emboldened, Frum then chided Republicans for not leavening their obstructionism with substantive ideas. For example's sake, he added, he'd proffer a few of his own.
I was intrigued. But just momentarily.
For at this point the soloist terminated his renegade riff and returned to the AEI songbook. His "ideas" were not substantive at all, but musty, dusty conservative standards. Deport all the immigrants and give those low-wage jobs back to the Americans that deserve them. Drive down health care premiums by attacking regulation, the medical insurance industry's version of irritable bowel syndrome.
Aside from the fact that these "novel ideas" would do little to address wage stagnation, much less expand access to affordable health care, Frum didn't finish where he should have started -- with the total inability the previous administration and its economic policy to create jobs.
Even according to (gasp) the Wall Street Journal, the Bush administration's performance on this score is among the lamest on record. Only 3 million net jobs were created during the Bush years. This is just a fraction of the 23 million jobs created during the Clinton administration. At 2.3 percent, payroll expansion was equally abysmal.
Yes, David. Government was the problem. Republicans, who with few exceptions haven't been real adept at increasing employment, tried to swap easy credit for good jobs and sustainable incomes. Result? Endemic underemployment, and household debt that is now 130 percent of income.
The Bush tax cuts made another run at trickle-down economics. But the money didn't trickle down, it trickled up. Result? Spurning the old-fashioned notion of investing money to create economic value, wealthy money managers and unregulated investment banks instead tried to make money out of money.
There has to be a better way.
To me, one of the more memorable lines in what I thought was a powerful and compelling inaugural address was this: "The nation cannot prosper long when it favors only the prosperous."
Words to the wise. It's about jobs, stupid.





Frum's designation of wage stagnation as economic ill is akin to Paris Hilton's agent waking up one Brentwood morning to realize his client has no discernable talent: Those so late recognizing commonly acknowleged reality should keep quiet about their "discovery", lest they reveal themselves dolts. I suspect this "eureka moment", as well as his turnabout on immigration policy is an attempt, perhaps, to take his neoconservative message to broader masses. Shaky, since Frum has as much love of the native-born American hoi-polloi as does the progressive elite - to whit, none at all.
January 22, 2009 1:10 PM | Reply | Permalink
Well said. Although I confess I don't spend a lot of time on the other side of the fence, I do know there is some debate in conservative circles over whether wage stagnation really exists. Kind of the economic corollary of global warming, I guess.
I do know that stabilizing the economy is going to take serious, Clintonesque job growth. After eight years of Bush brand economic policy, I don't know how anyone can seriously argue that it can be accomplished without government intervention.
January 22, 2009 2:08 PM | Reply | Permalink
Frum smartly identified -- drumroll, please -- wage stagnation as one of our chief economic ills. To me, this seemed akin to playing Epistrophy at a Salieri concert, or uttering "Voldemort" before the Hogwarts assembly. But my man was just getting warmed up.
As usual, you have presented a great post and terrific metaphor for the ages. It is much better than say, Rush presenting a paper at a conference on illegal prescription drug use with the help of illegal alien employees.
I also like the way you phrase his concern over illegal aliens taking away jobs that our citizens DESERVE. Our own people--so to speak--should be the ones breaking their backs for the lowest wages accompanied with no benefits. Because this is what Americans deserve.
Its funny isn't, how a radio show or a short piece on CSPAN can get you to thinking?
January 22, 2009 2:23 PM | Reply | Permalink
Doesn't appear to have worked with you yet.
January 23, 2009 8:30 AM | Reply | Permalink
I heard this one too... and my jaw dropped when Frum mentioned wages. Not even stagnation, but WAGES. It's too bad his solutions were just more Bushspeak. if both political sides could recognize the same problems and work on a compromise solution, things would happen and maybe work a little better.
January 22, 2009 5:33 PM | Reply | Permalink
I think Obama is working hard to make the post-partisan thing a reality. But listening to folks like Frum and my own elected representatives makes me think: we tried it your way and we're sucking wind. So shut up and sit down. Now it's our turn.
January 22, 2009 6:24 PM | Reply | Permalink
Good post, blue. I've been thinking about NPR a lot. It used to be such a fountain of information, but it has turned into what might be called a semiliterate faux news. It really ticks me off to think my tax dollars are supporting a republican news outlet. My senators are inhofe and coburn so they are useless, especially inhofe. And my representative is another useless republican named sullivan. I'm thinking about writing the DNC about it. Don't know who else to contact. Any suggestions, Anybody? And would you like to join my crusade?
January 22, 2009 5:40 PM | Reply | Permalink
CPB was pretty bent and twisted by the Bushies, who believed it (along with every other media outlet) was a liberal mouthpiece. Frankly, I'm surprised it has survived at all.
No question NPR has gone off course to the right. During the campaign, I nearly vomited every morning I had to wake up to Juan Williams giving his torn-from-the-faux-news-headlines political analysis. Shame, because he was a respectable journalist with a solid pedigree before he went over to the dark side.
But there's still a lot to be thankful for. Melissa Block and Robert Siegel -- Siegel in particular -- are experienced news hands who can do great interviews. I hope CPB doesn't fall off the radar screen and they get some folks on their board who are genuinely interested in news gathering and the public interest.
BTW -- my senators are Jim (DeMented) DeMint and Lindsey Graham and my congressman is Bob Inglis. I feel your pain.
January 22, 2009 6:04 PM | Reply | Permalink