« Just Curious.... | Bar Kafka's Blog | "Listen, it's here, below the building..." »

Conspicuous Absence


In the comments sections below Cafe featured columns discussing the Arab-Jewish or Israel-Palestine conflict (call it what you will), is often at least one complaint about the lack of Arab or Palestinian voices in our mix of featured columnists.  Since it is not as if there are no Arab- and Palestinian-American writing and publishing, I must agree that it seems a strange and unnatural lack of representation in a forum so widely read, respected and cited as TPMCafe.  Meanwhile, two pieces have just showed up on a casual run among my own regualr station stops along the Information Superhighway this morning.  Both, I am proud to say, come from my native Chicago:

 

Hesham Hassaballa,

 

I believe the vast majority of American Muslims and Arab Americans feel the same way I do about this conflict. They are terribly hurt by the suffering of innocent Palestinians who have nowhere to run from the Gaza onslaught, but they do not think that the appropriate response is to hurl more death and destruction at Israeli civilians in a twisted form of revenge. Like our Jewish counterparts, we also think that "there has to be another way of doing this."

...

President-elect Barack Obama, who, distressingly, long remained silent about the latest crisis, is set to take office in two weeks. He must strive for this "middle way" and work with all of us in the United States - American Jews, American Arabs and Muslims, and many others - who are pro-peace, pro-Israel and pro-Palestine....

 

Ray Hanania,

 

Have we deteriorated so much as a people, Jews and Arabs, that we can simply turn away from the suffering of the other, and even justify it when confronted by pointing to the deaths on our sides?

Uglier than the massacres and bloodied scenes filled with body parts are the crowds of people who easily come together in anger and blame the other side while never assuming any blame themselves.

...

As a Palestinian Arab, I'm a willing to stand with any Jew or Israeli who has the courage to stop blaming the other side. Stop defending violence of any kind. Stop the justification. Stop the killing. Stop the violence.

Stand together and focus on one answer. Peace. Respect for life.

We can recognize this is difficult. We can accept we have different views of history. We can accept that peace is not easy. But can we accept that not acting means more death? Can we accept that by pointing fingers of blame at each other, we are accomplices to the hatred that drives the carnage?

 

Speculation runs rampant over what can possibly account for this.  I only slightly regret that the grim idea that crosses mine is that such voices as these cannot drive enough conflict to generate the hitcounts of some of the Cafe's more regular, provacative featured writers.


12 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Bar Kafka:

I am more convinced than ever that, both in the presidential election campaign, and particularly now with respect to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, the real discourse takes place on this side of the page, with some notable exceptions. Perhaps your choices of Palestinian voices can fairly said not to be a broad cross-section of the voices of Palestine. Notably, however, you have established, that unlike the cookie-cutter presumptions that in a way is condescending--albeit in good faith--to our Palestinian brothers and sisters, Palestinians, like Jews, speak with more than one voice.

And, as to Jews, there are more than two voices, indeed thank heavens there are more voices than MJ Rosenberg and stereotypical Israel right or wrongers who spew bile like petty imbeciles on a daily basis on the left side of the page. We speak with many voices as do those in Palestine, but I believe that most of us speak in the name of peace and justice from all descendants of Abraham.

user-pic

Let me point out that, on this side of the page, there are many voices in addition to Jewish voices, with many views who should continue to post and set an example. Without meaning to offend anyone by the sin of unintended omission, I urge many folks to keep posting and setting an example on this side of the page, including but not limited to Wordie, lally, artappraiser, Flavius, Purple State, Thera P, Tintin, David Seaton, jdledell, Dan K, seth edenbaum, brad the dad, bluebell, and YBD. Again, these are just folks who I can think of off the top of my head. I'm sure there are many others.

We should set an example with what we have. We should show that this place can get hits and thrive with those from own ranks, and that we can discuss Middle East issues with passion but with dignity, and not like screaming imbecilic banshies. Thank you bar kafka, because this morning you're off to a good start in setting that example.

user-pic

Good finds, thanks.

user-pic

More Palsestinian voices. From today's NYTs, Rashid Khalidi's piece called "What You Don't Know About Gaza". Folks might recall Senator McCain, in the death throes of his campaign, engaged in the bonehead acto of trying to make hay out of the fact that PE Obama attended a dinner honoring Professor Khalidi.

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/01/08/opinion/08khalidi.html?_r=1&ref=opinion

P.S. Tom Wright is one of the names I forgot to include above but he's been keeping a fairly low profile on the I-P threads these days (perhaps wisely so:)).

user-pic

Another Chicago connection. Two friends of mine earned their masters degrees in Prof. Khalidi's Middle East Studies program at the University of Chicago. Thanks Bruce!

user-pic

Chicago is distinguishing itself lately Bar. Nice work.

user-pic

When we achieve global proliferation of 16" softball, my work here will be done.

user-pic

City of broad shoulders and big balls ????


(Thanks for rekindling fond memories of playing 16-inch back in my college days . . .)


user-pic

Hey, it's a great game for oldtimers. I played downtown last summer (Hutchison Field, site of Obama's election night rally). But I'm still trying to get a team together out in the western burbs. Are you still in the area? Do you still care about your fingers?

user-pic

I'm headed to Chicago this morning, Bar, but most days I can be found in Chicago's far eastern burbs . . . near Boston. I'd love to play, but the commute would kill me . . .


user-pic

Thanks Bar K for bringing some Arab voices--and moderate ones at that--to the dialogue. I hope Josh takes your post to heart. I know there are fewer Arab pundits and intellectuals in the US than there are Jewish--and that may be one of the reasons for the disparity in representation on TPMCafe. But there are still many good Arab or Arab-American commentators whom Josh could invite to post here (Khalidi, Khouri, and Telhami are three that come to mind as being willing to speak in public) and whose presence would broaden the dialogue.

user-pic

All of whom that you mention would be welcomed additions to the discourse. Further, beside his accessibility, Ray Hanania also possesses a talent for being genuinely funny. You can check out more of his stuff here.

Leave a comment

Bar Kafka

user-pic

Following: 10
Followers: 7

Posts
Comments & Recommends


  • Location Fox River Watershed, Great Lakes Basin
  • Party Yes, but not as much as the old days.
  • Politics Liberal and Bioregional

Favorites

  • Favorite Books The Metamorphosis, and Other Stories; Catch-22; Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas; The Origins of Totalitarianism; Desert Solitaire; Sand County Almanac; Yiddish Policemen's Union....
  • Favorite Quotes "Your flag decal won't get you into heaven anymore..." (John Prine)

All Reader Posts
How to use myTPM

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address