I'm an Orthodox Jew and I know Rashid Khalidi
Here's my Rashid Khalidi story:
In around '99 or 2000, Prof. Khalidi's daughter and I turned a bunch of double plays together for the Cambridge University Baseball Society (CUBS, get it?). She played shortstop and I was on second base. At the time, I was a graduate student studying Hebrew Literature and also the Executive Director of one of the two main Jewish student groups on campus, the Cambridge University L'Chaim Society.
She was a great girl and a heckuva ballplayer, one of the best players on the team (and the only female). When her dad came for a visit, I took advantage of the situation to have him come to our student center for a debate with a Hebrew University scholar on the 'Future of Jerusalem.'
I picked up Prof. Khalidi from Heathrow and drove with him up to Cambridge. We had a good, intense discussion about the peace process, Arafat, the War of Indepence vs. the 'Nakba', etc... At no time during our private conversation or during his public debate did Prof. Khalidi ever condone the use of violence to achieve political ends, nor did he ever resort to anti-semitic attacks against the Jewish State or ad hominen attacks against Jews. And he was absolutely more critical of Arafat than even some of my yeshiva buddies. To be sure, I vehemently disagreed with much of what he said, but that's exactly why he was invited - to offer an alternative viewpoint on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. He debated it, defended it, took questions from the mainly Jewish audience, and that was that. He was very kind to accept our invitation and has my gratitude and respect.
And if you're out there, Khalidi daughter (I don't want to bring her name into this) - Do you think we had any success bringing the American pastime to the cricket-loving Brits?
In around '99 or 2000, Prof. Khalidi's daughter and I turned a bunch of double plays together for the Cambridge University Baseball Society (CUBS, get it?). She played shortstop and I was on second base. At the time, I was a graduate student studying Hebrew Literature and also the Executive Director of one of the two main Jewish student groups on campus, the Cambridge University L'Chaim Society.
She was a great girl and a heckuva ballplayer, one of the best players on the team (and the only female). When her dad came for a visit, I took advantage of the situation to have him come to our student center for a debate with a Hebrew University scholar on the 'Future of Jerusalem.'
I picked up Prof. Khalidi from Heathrow and drove with him up to Cambridge. We had a good, intense discussion about the peace process, Arafat, the War of Indepence vs. the 'Nakba', etc... At no time during our private conversation or during his public debate did Prof. Khalidi ever condone the use of violence to achieve political ends, nor did he ever resort to anti-semitic attacks against the Jewish State or ad hominen attacks against Jews. And he was absolutely more critical of Arafat than even some of my yeshiva buddies. To be sure, I vehemently disagreed with much of what he said, but that's exactly why he was invited - to offer an alternative viewpoint on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. He debated it, defended it, took questions from the mainly Jewish audience, and that was that. He was very kind to accept our invitation and has my gratitude and respect.
And if you're out there, Khalidi daughter (I don't want to bring her name into this) - Do you think we had any success bringing the American pastime to the cricket-loving Brits?




