Morning Edition on NPR: Big Health Insurance with no response
Here's the NPR promo for the segment:
Here's my comment posted to NPR and on Facebook:
Many of the nation's health insurers are opposed to a key part of the Democrats' plan to overhaul health care. Supporters call it the "public option" -- which means the government would offer a health insurance plan for individuals. Dr. Sam Nussbaum is chief medical officer for WellPoint, the nation's largest health insurer. He explains to Steve Inskeep why his organization is against the public option.
Here's my comment posted to NPR and on Facebook:
One would think that in the interest of fairness a representative of the opposite point of view, one with medical credentials, should be given equal time. I suggest Dr. Howard Dean. I also suggest that your research department (I'm assuming you do have a research department) actually look at the data out there. Dr. Nussbaum made points which have been refuted more than once. Had your interviewer that information at hand, he could have let less snake oil be sold.I wonder if a deluge of similar comments might just get the good Doctor Dean on. Delugers to the rescue!!!
Advertisement
















I've been so disappointed in both NPR and C-Span. I don't know where they're coming from these days, but most of their political discussions revolve around the people who want to keep essential services to the minimum so that the money can keep flowing to the private interests.
Thanks for the link, aMike. Your comment was right on, too.
WellPoint was one of the insurers being grilled at the House committee hearing. They're scum, just like the rest of them.
http://ramonasvoices.blogspot.com/2009/07/fight-for-health-care-part-2-my-man.html
July 15, 2009 10:52 AM | Reply | Permalink
These days I just think of it as National Propaganda Radio.
Haven't watched C-Span in a while, but I know it is paid for by the cable industry, and in this world you generally get what you pay for.
July 15, 2009 9:55 PM | Reply | Permalink
I listened to this asshole this morning. Snake oil salesman was right on the mark. If the con men in health care currently were going to make these "improvements" why haven't the done it in competition with each other?
This asshole went on about how the public plan would have an "advantage" and would set lower payments to the health care providers and have an unfair advantage; the insurance companies already have this deal with the doctors and hospitals and labs that they pay now. Who pays so that they can the lower rates, the uninsured.
I had a hip replaced 2 years ago. The receipt came and showed that the insurance company was to pay $24,000, I was to pay $1,000 and that the bill would have been $50,000 if I was uninsured. Now, who do you think pays the most for services, and who has a discount with your health care providers? Hint: It's the insurance companies!.
July 15, 2009 11:20 AM | Reply | Permalink
I listened to this asshole this morning. Snake oil salesman was right on the mark. If the con men in health care currently were going to make these "improvements" why haven't the done it in competition with each other?
This asshole went on about how the public plan would have an "advantage" and would set lower payments to the health care providers and have an unfair advantage; the insurance companies already have this deal with the doctors and hospitals and labs that they pay now. Who pays so that they can the lower rates, the uninsured.
I had a hip replaced 2 years ago. The receipt came and showed that the insurance company was to pay $24,000, I was to pay $1,000 and that the bill would have been $50,000 if I was uninsured. Now, who do you think pays the most for services, and who has a discount with your health care providers? Hint: It's the insurance companies!.
July 15, 2009 11:22 AM | Reply | Permalink
My own tail of woe is nothing quite that dramatic. I had dental work done a year ago (reminder--floss regularly). Anyway, half the work was not covered as "elective"--I preferred implants to a permanent installation. I knew that in advance, didn't like it, but coughed up the bucks anyhow. BUT Delta Dental was supposed to pick up the tab for a significant portion of the rest. It took my dentist three applications before the bureaucrat (yes private insurance companies have those--and their only job is to make sure the customer is always wrong) would approve the work the Dentist. Did.
I'm sure those guys work who question claims on the behalf of big insurance do so for free. Yah, sure. Yah, right. Yah, in a pig's ear.
July 15, 2009 11:35 AM | Reply | Permalink
I heard it too, and was screaming at the radio. I even did a web search when I got home trying to find out what this VP's salary was from WellPoint. I'm guessing it's considerably more than the $197k/yr maximum salary that a Cabinet "Secretary of Health Care" would receive. And there would be only one Secretary. How many execs like Nussbaum are there who are so fearful of competition from a gov't program? This is only one way in which his preferred system introduces expensive inefficiencies that he simply cannot justify no matter how much spin he gives.
Gawd, he was insufferable... and incoherent. So much so that he inspired me to write and post my own blog on the topic.
July 15, 2009 12:06 PM | Reply | Permalink
Amike, I just finished sending off my comment to NPR. Your post was the swift kick I needed to take action. Thank you. Like many others, I was driving when the interview aired. It was unsettling, to say the least.
A cursory search of NPR's website turned up empty on segments concerning public option other than the one that ran this morning. I had hoped they might have had a proponent on recently to provide some balance, but no.
The gist of my comment was that anytime there's to be a discussion of a major issue, experts from both sides should be present. The host should serve as moderator. To do anything short of that implies bias and is a disservice to listeners.
Something else I discovered while at their website, the NPR library is sponsored by U.S. Trust, Bank of America Private Wealth Management.
July 15, 2009 1:20 PM | Reply | Permalink
Oh, and I included a plug for Dr. Dean.
July 15, 2009 1:23 PM | Reply | Permalink
The Reich has managed to infiltrate NPR. What can we do to get it back to being the inquisitive news organization it one was!?!?
July 15, 2009 2:09 PM | Reply | Permalink
I would be happy to scrape the money together to donate to my local NPR station again if they brought Edwards back. Wonder if others would do the same. His professionalism might help restore it to the inquisitive news organization of which you speak. And, I do miss that voice!
July 15, 2009 4:08 PM | Reply | Permalink
This is typical of NPR these days. They have time after time interviewed gop politicians about the issues-of-the-day without a word about Dems' views. or presenting a Dem defense. The lead in is always something like "republicans are concerned about the size of the [fill in the blank] on [you name it]... Senator blowhard, tell us...."
July 15, 2009 3:44 PM | Reply | Permalink
I have heard TONS of discussion on NPR regarding single payer vs. public option vs. 'leave it alone'. Granted there's not much 'discussion' on Morning Edition and All Things Considered, but those are more new-oriented shows with interviews. You have to listen to some of the other programming to get a broader picture.
I will say that on ATC on Monday, Robert Siegel really let Chuck Grassley have it regarding Sotomayor and the Republican's silly argument about empathy. The TLDR version is this:
Siegel: Why are Republicans such hypocrites?
Grassley: Uh, is that Elvis? *ducks*
To The Point from KCRW and PRI is carried on the AM station broadcast by my local NPR affiliate. That is the best current-events program on the radio right now in my opinion. They seem to do their best to get 2 or more people on various sides of an issue and have them go at it. You get arguments and counter-arguments, and all parties have time to express their viewpoints. Also, Warren Olney is a badass and he won't let people sling BS on his show without calling them on it.
That show really highlights just how full of shit the health insurance industry is, because when they have a frank discussion with educated opponents their FUD becomes frighteningly obvious.
July 15, 2009 4:34 PM | Reply | Permalink
I have to plead some ignorance about other National Pubic Radio news programs. My local station only broadcasts these, plus The World from Public Radio International and The Takaway. Else, it's classical music and jazz, both of which are a blessed relief.
(Oh yes -- The Morning Business Report, can't forget the Morning Business Report).
July 15, 2009 5:57 PM | Reply | Permalink
I happen to think nobody should be on the national airwaves who is an executive or in the employ of any for profit organization without a person holding an opposing view also being there at the same time to offer listeners both sides. This should not be prohibited.
I also think none of our elected officials should ever be permitted (legally) to meet with constituents, who are also political contributors, at any venue, at any time to discuss anything at all unless there are opposing parties also invited.
July 15, 2009 4:57 PM | Reply | Permalink
I agree. Part of the problem is public radio's increasing reliance on "underwriters" (at least my local station, WGBH is honest enough to call them sponsors). Some of these underwriters are insurance companies including Liberty Mutual ...though I don't know if health insurance is included in their offerings.
July 15, 2009 5:52 PM | Reply | Permalink
It's not. They are property, casualty, and life.
July 15, 2009 10:20 PM | Reply | Permalink
Thanks for the information and taking the time to share it with me. I know something I didn't before.
July 16, 2009 6:43 AM | Reply | Permalink
Thanks to the internet, you can check out some of the clowns that NPR has on, Stephen Moore of the Wall Street Journal editorial department is a frequent favorite of the otherwise excellent Diane Rehm
Diane always neglects to mention that one of Mr. Moore's signature works was a book from 2004: Bullish on Bush: How George Bush's Ownership Society Will Make America Stronger Yes, this guy is still a pundit, and still employed by The Wall Street Journal!!!
A background on Moore and other NPR guests is mandatory to educate the listener as to guest bias! Thanks for pointing this out.
July 15, 2009 5:43 PM | Reply | Permalink
I posted a comment, but it hasn't been published after several hours. Perhaps they didn't like my opening line which read something like this: "I hope NPR got a really big donation from WellPoint for running this infomercial."
July 15, 2009 6:31 PM | Reply | Permalink
UPDATE I just (9:29 p.m. e.s.t.) went back for a check at the comments on this segment. 117 comments have been posted, of which 94 are critical of the interview, Dr. Nussbaum, and the private health care industry. A couple of others were indecipherable.
The most interesting were from physicians, one of whom said that dealing with private insurers was "hell". Go take a look. Interesting reading.
Thursday is the day they read from listeners comments. I wonder if they'll choose one of the critical ones. Any bets?
July 15, 2009 9:33 PM | Reply | Permalink
I don't expect much from National Plutocracy Radio these days.
July 15, 2009 9:53 PM | Reply | Permalink
I just tried to find a way on the wellpoint site to "contact us". They obviously don't want to be contacted.
July 15, 2009 9:57 PM | Reply | Permalink
Hey, hey, NPR how many babies died today because of lack of health care?
NPR will not talk about death and dying of those who do not have health care.
Gorilla Theater and shades of the 60’s, Dian Rehm only has conservative guests on the show when there are social discussions. It is time to take the dying to them or at least
the signs and the chants. Remind them that this is not about them and their organization. It is about us, our friends and those who have already died for lack of help.
Hey, hey, NPR what if you did not have health care?
July 15, 2009 10:16 PM | Reply | Permalink
Congress and the President need to reinstate pre-Gingrich funding of public radio and television.
July 15, 2009 10:29 PM | Reply | Permalink
NPR news sucks. I stoped contributing years ago. It's a mish-mosh of gee-whiz right wing apologias, interspersed with 9-minute long stories about things like bee-keeping in South Carolina.
July 16, 2009 5:18 AM | Reply | Permalink