The Smarting of America
Someone needs to tell Susan Jacoby about hyperlinks.
In last Sunday's Washington Post, she techno-moralized that the rise of video (which according to her includes "every form of digital media") has led to the fall of "print culture" and Americans' inability to read books and poems and locate things on maps. Her sociology is, as Peter Suderman points out, imperfect at best. The trends are not as uniform as she suggests, and she takes liberties with the studies she cites, assigning causality where it's not at all clear it exists and making personal logical jumps ("[it]seems to me") where even that falls short. But what's worse, she seems to have missed the biggest media story of the last decade. It's a story you probably have a pretty good grasp of if you're here: the rise of the networked public sphere.
Jacoby's basic misunderstanding comes from her unwillingness to treat the internet and television as two distinct media phenomena.



