Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

The Fall of Conservatism? (with thanks to the Help desk)

avatar

Does anyone else see the eerie similarities between the end of the USSR and what may well be the end of the USSC (as in, US Stubborn Conservatives)?  Obama called the current crisis the result of a “failed ideology.”  But if you are a true believer, a card-carrying Party member, this is a whole lot worse.  In fact, in some deeply, er, faithful conservative corners this is the End of Days stuff. 

So cast your mind back to the glory days of that most revered of former USSC Supreme leaders –  Reagan – and remember:

- The army had been hunkered down in Afghanistan for years
- Military spending, poor central planning and rampant corruption had the economy teetering on the brink of disaster and the average comrade scared to death
- There was a moderate old party hack floundering around trying to rescue Orthodoxy from the supreme incompetence of the current Supreme leader
- The hard liners became ever more recalcitrant, and fell back on platitudes of dead leaders from a bygone era (Old Joe wouldn’t let this happen!)
- There was an ideological war at the Parliament building … where the turn-over rate, incidentally, was actually greater than the US Congress
- There was wild speculation that the country’s fundamental political structure was being legislated into oblivion
- And worst of all, in the face of just too much real-world evidence the central tenets of the Party philosophy were being judged an abysmal failure

Hyperbole?  Consider this: once we get past all the fireworks associated with this “bail-out” bill, Congress is likely to turn its attention on the task of stabilizing our financial markets for the long term.  Hmmm, it all ends with the rebuilding regulatory walls to free us from the tyranny of market abuse?  That just might turn the toppling of the Berlin Wall into one of the most post-ironic metaphors of all time … or at least this month.
 
I dunno know.  Maybe I'm the only one shouting at the Republican TV-talking heads: it’s your world view, stupid!  But I kinda doubt it.


Comments (5)

avatar

Why is this not showing up under Recent Posts?

Conservatives will fade back a while, then come back stronger like bacilli. This time now is like the time when they all got so ashamed of Nixon and his evil totalitarian ways. They got scared and ashamed. I don't think conservatives today are scared enough or ashamed enough. And judging from the younger ones waiting in the wings, they will come back without any pre-Reagan memories of any time when homeless mentally ill were cared for in publicly funded institutions or when the Army did not outsource washing its underwear to Halliburton. It's like a pendulum; everytime it swings in their direction, we have a closer brush with totalitarian rule that greases the skids for the capitalists, only they market it as "patriotism."

And we should bear in mind that this is not the death knell of conservatism that we are hearing - it's neoconservatism.

That said...they aren't going anywhere. There like cockroaches. They'll retreat into the shadows to plot their revenge and return w/new, even more vile plots.

avatar

The next tactical move they will try is to convince the electorate the need to have checks and balance.

Consider this; they realize their standard bearer McCain loses.


All is not lost though; blame Congress for all the ills. They’ll say “we need to boot them out of office everyone of them”

Consider this, they realize their standard bearer Mccain loses. Except they know they have members in safe seats, knowing that it looks like the Democrats will gain seats, the Republicans can confuse the electorate. Taking the victory out of the jaws of the Dems and in the process pick up more seats, than they expected.

Don’t fall for it, you’ll end up with more obstruction.

Cal Thomas the opinionist stated something to the effect, Republicans are chastised and will not repeat the same mistake again, Trust them again.

Read the fable the Frog and the Scorpion, or as Bush tried to explain Fool me once shame on you, fool me twice, shame on me.

avatar

I think Mr. Thomas' argument has great merit: there is a clear analogy between the last days of the CCCP and the Republican Party today. But analogy is not identity. The Republicans have not ruled the nation for 70 years with an iron hand. Rather, they have governed it for the last 8 years with a shopworn, ideology -- one held together, one has to imagine, by faith. And abundant prevarication and self-deception. They have proved the "invisible hand" is invisible because non-existent. Their faith content is ultimately anarchic: no taxes and rampant cut throat competition.

But even in the Russia there are still devotees of the old Communist regime; and there will continue to be those whose fealty to the conservative ideology will persist even in the face of logic and reason. The conservatice ideology's passing will eventuate with the passing of its adherents -- much like Thomas Kuhn's hypothesis about how old scientific theories are cast aside in favor of the newer, better ones: the proponents of the old theories simply die off. Until then, we will see periodic bouts of the infection.

Post a Comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Book Club Calendar

Coming Soon



Nov. 30-Dec. 4



January 12-16



« Book Club ArchiveFull calendar »

Recent Reader Posts

All Reader Posts »





Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address