Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

The Coming Landslide

As most of y'all are aware, the polls have been strongly pulling for Obama the last few weeks.  However, this is just the beginning of the story.  What has been mostly undocumented is Obama's organizational advantage.  The best description of this that I have seen has been the On the Road series done by the people at 538.com.  They have been making a trip through critical swing states, such as Colorado, Nevada, New Mexico, and now Missouri.  I encourage everyone to take a look at this series to see why this year will be different.

The difference between Obama's ground campaign and McCain is astounding.  Here is some of their most recent stop, in St. Louis:

<blockquote>
We walk into McCain offices to find them closed,
empty, one person, two people, sometimes three people making calls.
Many times one person is calling while the other small clutch of
volunteers are chatting amongst themselves.
...
We stop into offices at all open hours of the day,
but generally more in the afternoon and evening. “Call time,” for both
campaigns, is all day, but the time when folks over 65 are generally
targeted begins in late afternoon and goes til 8 or 9pm. Universally,
McCain’s people stop earlier. Even when we show up at 6:15pm, we’re
told we just missed the big phone bank, or to come back in 30 minutes.
If we show up an hour later, we “just missed it” again.
</blockquote>
Contrast this with the Obama field operation.
<blockquote>
We’re getting used to this relentless Obama
operation: organizers trained in both tactics and campaign culture,
working so hard they have trouble remembering what happened 48 hours
ago – it’s too distant – and convinced that if they stay in their lane
and trust the structure it’ll pay off in the end.

Obama has 40
offices now open in Missouri, and Justin Hamilton, Obama’s Press
Secretary for Missouri, told us that while he couldn’t confirm below or
above the published reports of 150 organizers (it didn’t come from the
campaign), the campaign is only adding to its ground force. Organizers
have now recruited 2500 neighborhood team leaders statewide, folks who
do the far more effective work than any 30-second ad or yard signs,
actual face-to-face contact and persuasion of their neighbors.
</blockquote>
In comparison
<blockquote>
You could take every McCain volunteer we’ve seen
doing actual work in the entire trip, over six states, and it would add
up to the same as Obama’s single Thornton, CO office. Or his single
Durango, CO office. These ground campaigns bear no relationship to each
other.
</blockquote>
These efforts do not show up in most polling because most polling firms use old information for voter demographics, and ignore cell phone-only voters.  The Selzer polling firm is different.  Selzer is the only pollster really trying to capture the changing dynamics, as is explained again at 538.com here.

This is why the election will not be close.  I am going to go out on a limb and say not only will Obama win, but he will be closer to 400 EV's than 300.


Comments (36)

Ack, sorry for the formatting. Here is the blockquotes from article better formatted (I hope).

We walk into McCain offices to find them closed, empty, one person, two people, sometimes three people making calls. Many times one person is calling while the other small clutch of volunteers are chatting amongst themselves. ... We stop into offices at all open hours of the day, but generally more in the afternoon and evening. “Call time,” for both campaigns, is all day, but the time when folks over 65 are generally targeted begins in late afternoon and goes til 8 or 9pm. Universally, McCain’s people stop earlier. Even when we show up at 6:15pm, we’re told we just missed the big phone bank, or to come back in 30 minutes. If we show up an hour later, we “just missed it” again.
Contrast this with the Obama field operation.
We’re getting used to this relentless Obama operation: organizers trained in both tactics and campaign culture, working so hard they have trouble remembering what happened 48 hours ago – it’s too distant – and convinced that if they stay in their lane and trust the structure it’ll pay off in the end.

Obama has 40
offices now open in Missouri, and Justin Hamilton, Obama’s Press
Secretary for Missouri, told us that while he couldn’t confirm below or
above the published reports of 150 organizers (it didn’t come from the
campaign), the campaign is only adding to its ground force. Organizers
have now recruited 2500 neighborhood team leaders statewide, folks who
do the far more effective work than any 30-second ad or yard signs,
actual face-to-face contact and persuasion of their neighbors.


In comparison

You could take every McCain volunteer we’ve seen
doing actual work in the entire trip, over six states, and it would add
up to the same as Obama’s single Thornton, CO office. Or his single
Durango, CO office. These ground campaigns bear no relationship to each
other.

These efforts do not show up in most polling because most polling firms use old information for voter demographics, and ignore cell phone-only voters. The Selzer polling firm is different. Selzer is the only pollster really trying to capture the changing dynamics, as is explained again at 538.com here.

This is why the election will not be close. I am going to go out on a limb and say not only will Obama win, but he will be closer to 400 EV's than 300.

One month to go.

I'm revising my official McSame is Toast EV-margin estimate to 130+, up from 100+.

Totally agree. There are states in play this year that no one is talking about because they still haven't figured out that it isn't 2004 and Obama isn't Kerry.

I participated in the Iowa caucuses. Obama's organization here was the best I've ever seen. Hillary's organization (or lack thereof) was a disaster and the #1 reason why she lost. And I say that as someone who volunteered for her.

My biggest fear is Obama will pull too far ahead in the polls and voters will think he's safe and not make the effort to get out and stand in line.

avatar

Perhaps I am being too optimistic, but I don't see that happening. I don't see people staying home if they are otherwise inclined to vote.

That is why I don't worry TOO much about these closer states, I know Obama's superior ground game is STILL not being shwon, whether he is up or down those polls could never account for his groundgame.

avatar

Predictions:

Barack wins every Kerry state.

Barack wins the easy pickups (Iowa, New Mexico).

Barack wins the 2004 battlegrounds (Ohio, Florida).

Barack wins the 2008 battlegrounds (Nevada, Colorado, Virginia).

Barack wins the red states that he challenged and the Repubs didn't think would be in play (North Carolina, Indiana)

Barack may well win some of the southern states where McCain's numbers are looking surprisingly soft (Georgia, Mississippi, Texas).

Barack may win Montana.

And he may win a state that hasn't been thought to be in play but could be a suprise (North Dakota? South Carolina? …Arizona?).

Crush, baby, crush.

I just want to get 61 "Democrats" in the Senate so we can kick Joe Lieberman to the curb.

(Yes, I've just bought the industrial-sized case of hubris. Dream big.)

You forgot Missouri.

If Indiana goes to Obama, I promise you Missouri will also.


I agree. I think that's why (until now, when they're in absolute panic) the McCain campaign has ignored Indiana. They know if they lose Indiana, it's the least of their problems.

Love ya IOWA for starting this whole thing! ;)

But hey - Let's keep it up! I still think we need to go into the final week up by a solid 10% for them to "allow us" (based on their disenfranchisement tactics) to win by 3%.

Ohioans are early voting these days, right? Pick em up, drive em down to the County Clerk and buy 'em a coffee afterwards if you're in the The Buckeye state right now.

Keep it up! :)

avatar

It really is looking like Texas could be in play .
I will tell this story again- I drive folks to the airport for a living in Austin, Tx .Way back in our primary I had one high school prinicpal and five high school teachers that I was taking back to Austin Bergstrom airport after a CEE conference hear. All six were from Midland Odessa school district all six had for the first time ever voted a democrat -all six said they were also planning to vote democrat in the general election ...
Dream big indeed DAngelus ,,

Nothing would make be happier than turning Texas blue (like my avatar). Maybe they can kick Cornyn to the curb in the process.

avatar

I live in Indiana and this week it was declared a battleground state. I have never heard of Indiana described as a battleground state in a general election. What happens in a battleground state? Is there civil unrest and public rioting? Do you burn effigies, because I think I might find that cheery on a crisp autumn night. Should I be hoarding toilet paper?
I was afraid all of those republican campaign staff refugees from Michigan would end up squatting here, but they said they were just passing through on their way to Virginia so we left them alone. They looked pretty haggard. Poor bastards, almost felt sorry for them.

I think your prediction may prove correct. At least I hope so.

avatar

While I hope for a crushing victory as much as the next guy, I hope they don't get unrealistically optimistic and spread their operations too thin. All Obama needs to do is hold the states he already has. One month is a long time.

Obama has 2000 field staff and is not spread too thin. He can always move folks around as he has done already with a team that large. McCain on the other hand has 500 and that limits his options as he retreats to defeat

Obama campaign=community organizing writ large.

Great post - you saved me doing the same one. The 538 series has been great as well as there polling data is the best period.

Here is one more scenario for you as well.

How many more principal/family surrogate stops can Obama, Michelle, Joe and Jill do than McCain Palin in 30 days in key states?

McCain and Palin are stuck together due to her incompetence almost every day and Cindy and the First Dude aren't out on their own...

If each person can do 2 events and a few interviews w/ local media a day do the math. Also the national media interviews that only McCain is allowed to do restricts them as well.

To support the ground game the Obama team gets someone where they need them easily. McCain cannot.

That also does not count Hillary, Bill, Bill Richardson who are out there as well. Heck Hillary is going to Arkansas this week, hmmm

When you add the above to the ground game the incompetence of the tactical driven McCain campaign is akin to political malpractice.

375 is Obama's ceiling. That is all the Kerry states plus IN,CO,NC,FL,OH,MO and NV. So far O is up in ALL those states except for IN and has just recently been up in MO. He has to keep ratcheting up his spending and his ground game has to keep working so he can get as many states as possible. I truly think he can reach 375 this election and touch 400 the next one.

Add Virginia and perhaps an unlikely southern state and he could crack 400.

Add WV. Of the southern states, I think Mississippi, Georgia, and Texas are the most within reach.

All one has to do is look at the primary results from Georgia and Texas to see they are both in striking distance. Mississippi would just be poetic justice.

Can anyone imagine John McCain giving an honorable concession speech? I sure can't.

I encourage everyone to think big this election cycle. I believe we have an even chance to take down the RR '80 EV total of 489 and an outside chance of besting his '84 EV total of 525.

The latter is going to require a collapse by the McCain campaign, which leads to droves of his voters across the South resigning themselves to defeat and staying home on Election Day. The former is already underway with the 50-state strategy and the McCain campaign in retreat across the map. There are two facts we know for sure right now: the black vote is being undercounted by the pollsters and the Latino vote is too. Add those two facts to an energized performance by the under-30 voter demographic and we are talking 65 Senators and 275 Representatives.

I'd say it is the under 40 crowd who have been under-represented in polling. Why? We haven't been turning out for the last 20 years. They are going to be very surprised this year. Gen X finally woke up. Sorry it took so long!

Personally I am taking nothing for granted and acting like Obama is behind in the polls.

Gallup poll does poll cell phones. What I find most encouraging is that the age weighting of current polls is based on 2004 turnout. While it's pretty safe to say there will be more youth turning out I think it's very risky to simply assume it will be huge. Ever since rock the vote started youth turnout has always been predicted to be much higher than the last time and generally been over estimated. There is another problem here that some people are simply assuming Obama will win. Those people are less inclined to go and vote because they think it's in the bag. I met some of those people last weekend when I was registering voters at a busy night life strip here in Seattle. They were young and hadn't voted before. I was alarmed and reminded them that it won't happen if people don't vote based on that idea and also that we have to turn out in large enough numbers to override voter suppression efforts.

The previous over-estimations were disproved by the time the primary rolled around.

Based on this year's primary turnout, not to mention the 2006 general election turnout for the mid-terms, the long-hyped "youth vote" is certainly materializing this year. The spread for the voting population is 18 to 40 as well, which is the biggest percentage of mostly new voters since the Voting Rights Act was passed.

Rock the Vote is almost there, it just took 16 years and 8 years of Bush before it sunk in.

Another danger of assuming he has it in the bag (let alone landslide) is it's effect on the ground operations. There are thousands of volunteers across the country who have registered voters, made calls and are walking their neighborhoods. We are taking the time out of our busy lives to make a difference and it isn't always easy. Assuming we will win will cut heavily into that workforce as people will relax their efforts.

Or perhaps it is a rallying cry that their efforts are panning out. We are so near the end, that seeing the landslide shape up gives us more energy to finish and not less.

I am not worried. There will be a landslide because all these volunteers are so hard working. This will make them work harder, not less.

avatar

I got polled by Gallup last night. I told them I was voting for McCain because I don't want ANYONE thinking this is in the bag! Maybe we'll look back on it and say it WAS in the bag by early October, but we would be idiots to look forward a full month and assume it already is!

IF IF IF IF

Everyone keeps working hard for this election and Obama's field operations stay as good as they've been and the youth vote turns out in historically big numbers and the black vote turns out in historically big numbers, maybe it'll be a big win. It will not rival Reagan's EV totals - its crazy to even start thinking about that. Lets lock up the handful of states he really NEEDS to win and, after that, the rest is gravy. I wanna see the damn pot-roast before I start planning on the gravy.

I am worried?

Here in Ohio, Ive voted for Gore, Kerry, and the now the slime is getting ready to be dumped on Obama in the last 4 weeks thanks to the McCain campaign. If any of the polls in OH, MO, NC, VA, FL, or CO are still within the margin of error to go to either candidate, Im worried!!!!

I volunteer here in Missouri and I don't think the McCain campaign has any clue what is going to happen on November 4th.

We are winning this election block by block, street by street. They thought community organizing was hilarious, but when community organize the country and win this election they won't be laughing.

Nice comment. All it took was a community organizer to bring the vast silent majority into focus.

avatar

Its being reported that there is a thirty percent increase in early voting in Georgia -the voting is heaviest in traditionally democratic precints.
Plus the anti -incumbent groundswell is also being fed by no gas for cars in Atlanta since Ike came ashore ...
And froglegs it does look like Noriega has a good shot at upsetting Cornyn down here in Texas - Any of you all got any spare jingle Noriega sure could use your donation today ...

avatar

I hope you are correct, but don't forget that the Republicans have their own community organizations. They're called churches and in 2004 they were "leveraged" very effectively by the Republicans (through the likes of Rick Warren) to win the election by suggesting it was unchristian not to vote for Bush because Kerry was pro-choice, pro-gay etc.

I know this, because I sat in a church when such a political sermon was given right before election day, 2004. I have since chosen not to be a part of a church. The politicization of religious beliefs is inconsistent with my faith.

Don't forget folks that this is a powerful apparatus for the right, who are now more enthused because they have "Bush in a skirt with lipstick".

No complacency. Donate and get involved.

The effect of the religious right was measured extensively in 2004 and accounted for in the polls. Everything the polls are missing is from Obama's ground game.

As I said earlier, there is no complacency. The desire for a real smack in the nose is motivation enough.

Post a Comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address