Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

Ayers, Obama and the Chicago Annenberg Challenge

I've spent a fair amount of time reading up on the Ayers/Obama "connections". To spare y'all the need to do so, but to arm you with the truth, let me lay out the story, at least with respect to their connection to the Chicago Annenberg Challenge:

First, Ayers (who was from a prominent Chicago family) is a professor of education at the University of Illinois who has been active in public education issues. Ayers' father was CEO of Commonwealth Edison and a friend of the original Mayor Daley, and the current Mayor Daley knows him. Whether we like this fact or not, Ayers is part of the mainstream Chicago community leadership.

When the Annenberg Foundation announced that it was doing the Challenge grant program, Ayers got together with a couple of other education activist types (both of whom were already serving as advisors to the national Annenberg Challenge) and initiated the application for the Annenberg grant. Ayers was one of three authors of the initial application, but there was a 73-member Working Group of local activists and representatives of national school reform organizations involved in the effort. Chicago was one of five programs funded by Annenberg. The project started in 1995. It was a public-private partneship. Each funded project had to get additional 2:1 matching funding or in-kind donations. Although the project was overwhelmingly funded by Annenberg, other contributors included the Bank America Foundation, Chicago Tribune Charities, the Pritzker Family Foundation and the MacArthur Foundation.

The organization of the CAC had two parts. "A Board of Directors, composed of foundation and business executives, was responsible for fiscal operations, developing a procedure for securing matching funds and making grants, and hiring an executive director....More unusual was the body that came to be known as the Chicago Reform Collaborative, made up of the members of the original Working Group and others....The Collaborative had an important, if ambiguous role in the Chicago Challenge" which mostly ended up being "continuing the conversation among the advocates."

Ayers was the chair of the Collaborative, the touchy-feely idea side of the effort. Obama became the initial Chairman of the Board of Directors, providing oversight of the business side of looking after millions of Annenberg money. Other Board Members included the publisher of the Chicago Tribune, the President of the Field Museum and the President of the University of Illinois. As for whether Ayers recruited Obama:

"In fact, according to several people involved, Mr. Ayers played no role in Mr. Obama’s appointment. Instead, it was suggested by Deborah Leff, then president of the Joyce Foundation, a Chicago-based group whose board Mr. Obama, a young lawyer, had joined the previous year. At a lunch with two other foundation heads, Patricia A. Graham of the Spencer Foundation and Adele Simmons of the MacArthur Foundation, Ms. Leff suggested that Mr. Obama would make a good board chairman, she said in an interview. Mr. Ayers was not present and had not suggested Mr. Obama, she said.

Ms. Graham said she invited Mr. Obama to dinner at an Italian restaurant in Chicago and was impressed.

“At the end of the dinner I said, ‘I really want you to be chairman.’ He said, ‘I’ll do it if you’ll be vice chairman,’ ” Ms. Graham recalled, and she agreed."

Despite the attempts of certain wingers to make something out of nothing, there's nothing big revealed in the more recently released papers of the CAC that wasn't public before, or that contradicts the above story about how Obama was brought onto the Board. And BTW that Board included

I don't have time right now to deal in depth with their service together on the Woods Fund (but it's a similar story of two Chicago guys active in the community serving on the board of a legitimate mainstream non-profit foundation), or the coffee which was held at the Ayers' house for Alice Palmer to introduce Obama when he first ran for state senate (one of several such small community gatherings held for Obama. But the bottom line to me is that Obama's path crossed with Ayers because they were both active in the community. And that's it. There is simply no evidence that Bill Ayers is a confidant, advisor or close friend of Obama. There is no record of Obama having ever said anything indicating that he shares Bill Ayers' opinions regarding his Vietnam-era activities or his extreme radical views.

I've served on boards and been involved in community volunteer groups, and I certainly don't expect to be held accountable for the viewpoints of everyone else in the organization.

And, the thing is, it's a GOOD thing, for BOTH Obama and Ayers, that they are involved in their communities and served on these boards. Whatever other stupid things Ayers has said or done, I don't fault his being active in his community. And on Obama's side, do we really want to get to a situation where only those whose records are devoid of community involvement can be elected, because they might have a minor tie with some idiot?

BTW, Jean Rudd, Executive Director of the Wood Foundation, said of Obama way back in 1995: "He is among the most hard-nosed board members in wanting to see results. He wants to see our grants make change happen--not just pay salaries." That's a good thing.

Some of my sources:

Chicago Annenberg Challenge:

http://ccsr.uchicago.edu/publications/p0b06.pdf
http://ccsr.uchicago.edu/downloads/p62.pdf
http://ccsr.uchicago.edu/downloads/p62II.pdf
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/09/10/us...pagewanted=all
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/10/04/us...rssnyt&emc=rss
http://sonatabio.com/CAC/1998.pdf
http://sonatabio.com/CAC/1999.pdf

Reception with Alice Palmer:

http://dyn.politico.com/printstory.c...9AD5180C22FF0B

Woods Fund:

http://www.woodsfund.org/about/history


Comments (17)

Why not just do one organization in depth. ACORN has been in the news lately. Did ACORN get any Annenberg money? How much and exactly what did they do with it? Describe the project.

ACORN Statement: Nevada Secretary of State "Stunt" Serves No Useful Purpose
October 07, 2008

On Oct. 7, ACORN interim Chief Organizer Bertha Lewis issued the following statement regarding ACORN's Las Vegas office:

"Over the past year, ACORN has worked hard to help over 80,000 people in Clark County register to vote. As part of our nonpartisan voter registration program, we have reviewed all the applications submitted by our canvassers. When we have identified suspicious applications, we have separated them out and flagged them for election officials. We have zero tolerance for fraudulent registrations. We immediately dismiss employees we suspect of submitting fraudulent registrations.

"For the past 10 months, any time ACORN has identified a potentially fraudulent application, we turn that application in to election officials separately and offer to provide election officials with the information they would need to pursue an investigation or prosecution of the individual.

"Election officials routinely ignored this information and failed to act. In early July, ACORN asked to meet with election officials to express our concerns that they were not acting on information ACORN had presented to them. ACORN met with Clark County elections officials and a representative of the Secretary of State on July 17th. ACORN pleaded with them to take our concerns about fraudulent applications seriously. One week later, elections officials asked us to provide them with a second copy of what we had previously provided to them. ACORN responded by giving election officials copies of 46 'problem application packages,' which involved 33 former canvassers.

"On September 23, ACORN had received a subpoena dated September 19th requesting information on 15 employees, all of whom had been included in the packages we had previously submitted to election officials. ACORN provided our personnel records on these 15 employees on September 29.

"Today's raid by the Secretary of State's Office is a stunt that serves no useful purpose other than to discredit our work registering Nevadans and distracting us from the important work ahead of getting every eligible voter to the polls."

I'll be right over to sign your petition.

It's not my petition. It's a petition being circulated by those who have known and have worked with Ayers for the last 20 years. You know, the one's who actually know the situation and don't get their talking points from Limbaugh and Faux news?

UNLEASH THE OBAMABOTS!

This is the only way McCain can win!

Give America a dose of Opus Hussein X and liam on the Evening News, and Obama will be polling in the single digits.

Ayers' little friends in the Weather Underground were building a nail bomb to explode at a dance on a US Army base, when they accidentally blew themselves up instead.

Put Opus Hussein X and liam on the Evening News and let them explain how exploding a nail bomb at a dance on a US Army base is a good thing, just like they explain it here on TPMCafe.

Then get ready to say...

Four more years!

No, Jacob, not even this would be enough for McCain to win.

I guess you're working on getting us those ACORN Annenberg Challenge projects, db. I'll keep checking back with you. I only mention ACORN since they seem so involved in everything all of a sudden. They come up in association with voter fraud, with Freddie Mae, with the $700 billion bailout and with the Annenberg Challenge. Busy. Busy. Busy. At least you can put the Annenberg thing to rest.

Sorry I haven't completed your assignment yet, Billy. I've got 6 years of tax filings by the CAC which list their grant recipients, but unless the grant recipient says "ACORN", which seems unlikely, I don't know how I'd know if any grant recipients were ACORN-related.

ACORN is apparently the new Trilateral Commission, Freemasons, etc. Who knew they had such power?

They don't have power yet. They're still just a seed.

That's a smile. I was hoping they were well-known enough that it would be easy to find out if they got money and what they used it for. My guess is it would be pretty innocuous but ineffective stuff. Certainly not teaching kids how to make bombs.

What I don't understand is why someone is not circulating a petition of support for Ayers in the liberal blogosphere. That's just crazy. They are inviting the MSM to ask Obama if he agrees with the petition. Why do that?

The only relevant question is what did Obama and Ayers do together? If they didn't do anything wrong, Ayers is a non-issue.

ooops. make that "now" circulating a petition.

Here's the link in case you want to go over and sign the petition.

http://tpmcafe.talkingpointsmemo.com/talk/2008/10/stand-up-to-gop-mccarthyism-an.php

In case you didn't notice, if you're not an educator, you can't sign it. I guess you didn't bother to read it, and instead only saw your own blind prejudice against the truth.

Isn't that question asked and answered?

Appreciate the reality check post. I "crossed paths" with Ayers a number of times in the 80's and early 90's--we were on a committee together at the University of Illinois when he was and still is a highly respected educator, scholar and advocate for inner city schools. Many of us who had contact at him at the University didn't even know about his past. He was respected for what he accomplished and worked for--advocating for the least in our society. Too bad these religious wingnuts don't pay a whit of attention to what the Gospels say about redemption and forgiveness or what Jesus called us to do with our lives.

Redemption for what? Ayers says he didn't do anything wrong. Where is the redemption in that? Rehabilitation maybe, assuming your daddy is rich. But redemption? I doubt it's only "wingnuts" who condemn terrorist attacks on Americans.

S. E. England pwns Billy Glad. Poor guy doesn't know when he's been whipped.

Post a Comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Book Club Calendar

Coming Soon



Nov. 30-Dec. 4



January 12-16



« Book Club ArchiveFull calendar »

Recent Reader Posts

All Reader Posts »





Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address