Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

WHAT SEN. McCAIN DOESN'T SEEM TO UNDERSTAND

avatar

Thanks to the modern miracle of the virtual community, I was able to meet with a fiesty, funny, great group of military families via liveblogging, during the Foreign Policy debate between Barack Obama and John McCain that just wound down.

I'm referring to Blue Star (and Gold Star) Families for Obama.  They've got a great website available at www.bsf4o.com .

The motto of the organization is "Pro-Military, Pro-Obama," and what I found so, well, COMFORTING was being able to converse via the Internet with active-duty military families--many of whom had loved ones currently deployed to Iraq and Afghanistan--and the veterans who were watching with them.  (I've got one of my own here, who was also watching.)

What I mean by "comforting," is that if you live in a conservative Red-state area, as I do, you are used to gritting your teeth into powder while being surrounded by a bunch of flag-wavers who seem to think that if you don't vote Republican that you hate the troops, or that if you are from a military family, well you MUST hero-worship the war-hero.

I can tell you that there are many military families who not only DON'T hero-worship John McCain, but resent deeply his seemingly endless ability to play on his war service and navy family for political purposes while, at the same time, voting against veteran's benefits time and time and time again.

As one said, "I'm glad he keeps bringing up his support for veteran's issues.  That only gives us an opportunity to point out the facts of his record."

And so "GoldStarLMW" did just that.  Among the statistics she posted were that, among every major veteran's group you can mention, McCain's voting record in support of their interests virtually never went above 25%, although once or twice, he went along with their needs maybe half the time.

"Militarywifeobamamama" typed, "Veteran sitting beside me says McCain supports Bush; he doesn't support veterans."

When it came to McCain's sad, sentimental, soaring story about wearing the bracelet of the war dead to remind him that he never wanted to see another soldier die in vain, "GoldStarLMW" immediately posted:

"NO soldier EVER dies in vain."

The rest of the bloggers were outraged at the whole bracelet story.  To condense what several said, "We're all wearing bracelets, John.  You don't have a corner on the market on that one."

One simply typed, "This is shameless."

There was laughter, too, when Militarywifeobamamama proposed a new "drinking game," wherein we all took a swig of whatever we had handy whenever McCain said, "What Senator Obama doesn't seem to understand..."

A few moments passed, then one wag typed, "I'm gonna have to get another bottle of wine."

And when Obama said, "We have to use our military wisely," a blogger calling herself "Lawyer Mama" blogged that the group of veterans in the room watching the debate with her broke into applause.

If Obama had a mis-step, at least from the perspective of the Blue Star families watching, it was at the very end, when McCain said, "I love the veterans, and I will take care of them.  They know that I will take care of them."

So many military family bloggers hit the keys at that one that the system was clogged up for a moment.  I may have actually used the term LYING BASTARD in my comment, and yes, I did use all caps.

Most of them were upset that Obama failed to take the moment to reveal the truth of McCain's DISMAL track record in support of veterans.  He doesn't take care of them AT ALL, as I pointed out in a previous post, "Bikers May Love Obama, But Veterans Do Not."

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/deanie-mills/bikers-may-love-mccain-bu_b_117225.html

One said, "WHY WHY WHY didn't he go after his record?"  Another said, "I cannot believe he didn't go after McCain's record."

I pointed out that it was the very end of the debate, and Obama had a few seconds to wrap the whole thing up.  There just wasn't time, and McCain KNEW that.  He always wrings out the emotional rag when he knows he's short on facts or truth.

And when he mentioned, at the very end, that he'd been a prisoner of war, "Militarywifeobamamama" who was also watching with a group of veterans, wrote, "Veterans abuzz here.  Some had a bet on when he'd mention it.  I won!"

Among those troops currently deployed, according to non-partisan statistics, support for Barack Obama outnumbers support for John McCain SIX to ONE.   Veterans groups, as well, routinely rate his voting record as poor.  When both candidates recently addressed the Veterans of Foreign Wars, one vet in the crowd commented that all McCain did in his speech was criticize his opponent, whereas Obama had spelled out his vision and program and funding ideas for their needs.

"I'd've liked to have heard what McCain was going to do about all these problems," he said.

McCain has always acted as if he takes the military and veteran's votes for granted.  That they would automatically support him just because of his war-hero narrative.  This is every bit as insulting as the idea that most all women will vote for him because he chose a woman for a running mate.

He seems to think if he just tells a tear-jerker story, waxes patriotic, waves the flag a time or two and says things like, "Veterans know that I will always take care of them," that somehow they will believe him even though they know better.

It's not the case, and I've met many troops and veterans who not only don't support McCain, but are angry at him for his policies and outraged at some of the things he says that they know are not true.

And they fully support Barack Obama.

But I'm afraid that's just something that Sen. McCain doesn't seem to understand.


Comments (9)

Your post is exactly why Obama had no need to confront mcShame on his lies.

Over and over I've seen that Obama can simply absorb the lies. He knows the Truth will Out.

It's what I call the principle of simmering. The Obama campaign lets voters think for themselves.

Simmer. Simmer. Simmer.

Then BOIL or WHAM - take your pick. Once the lie has been thoroughly simmered. Then they just put out an ad, which doesn't really need to explain much. Just reminds everybody what they've already concluded on their own.

Thanks so much, Deanie. For doing your part in the simmering. And thanks to the great group you're part of. When I heard those lies, I just felt calm, cuz I knew the military and their families would kick into gear and WHAM!

Thank you for this post Deanie. Your perspective on this election is very much appreciated. And I'm grateful, too, to the hear the thoughts of other military families.

About the blog that you mentioned. It should have been"Bikers may love MccCain". He went to Stugis to meet the bikers and offered his wife as contestant for Miss Buffalo something.

avatar

Great post, rec'd.

He always wrings out the emotional rag when he knows he's short on facts or truth.

I'm glad people saw that. The pre-converted will suck up the last 2 minutes, but the middle may decide McCain's comments were only missing a wavy flag in the background with some cheesy musak.

Maybe next time, aides will come out to wrap McCain in the flag -- literally. It may look like this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H5aVhLjT7UE

Thank you very much Deanie...My son is a veteran and I've always considered us a military family, even though he is now out of the Army. I appreciate knowing that there are lots of other families like ours that find McCain so despicable.

Remember, Obama pointed out that he had his own bracelet, from a Mom who wants Obama to end the war.

I'm glad Obama didn't go after McCain very much. It showed grace, and it underlined his calm, his civility, and his control.

I think the metaphor "going off half cocked" is absolutely apt for McCain. Because it means McCain's gun is already pulled, even though there's likely no reason for it. Obama will keep a well-maintained gun in his holster, where it belongs, because he understands the cost of firing that gun, even when fully prepared. He will only pull that gun when it's absolutely necessary, but he will not hesitate to use it to defend us.

I think the current and former military understand this. It's not personal military experience that matters in a commander-in-chief; it's the willingness and ability to listen to the generals, weigh the situation carefully, and make a deliberate, thoughtful decision about what to do, keeping everything that's at stake in mind. His decisions will combine rationality with compassion, not rashness with emotion.

Thanks, Deanie. I am so heartened by the military's take on this; it's hard to imagine how they can be from what I hear about Fox News and Rush Limbaugh being piped in over their airwaves constantly. BTW, do you know if that is true?

Obama still has time to bring up McCain's lack of support for the troops and veterans. After his very forceful triple-play of "You were wrong" about Iraq it might have looked like beating a dead horse to thrash him with all the veterans' groups that are coming out against McCain.

I am curious about how McCain, who couldn't manage to look Obama in the eye, will manage to do so in the next debate. Surely his campaign will work with him on that, but it looked to me as though he simply COULDN'T do it; not that he was refusing to. It seemed almost cowardly to me.

Keep filling us in because you do it in such an informative and empathic way. Thanks again for a great post!

I read this before watching the debates yesterday, then read it out loud just now to my husband (who works with vets and returning soldiers); what a joy to hear that McCain's shameless display of faux patriotism isn't fooling anyone (or at least not these families). Keep up your reports. I'm finding them a real antidote to thought that this man could end up in the Oval Office, which just sickens me.

Post a Comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Book Club Calendar

Coming Soon



Nov. 30-Dec. 4



January 12-16



« Book Club ArchiveFull calendar »

Recent Reader Posts

All Reader Posts »





Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address