Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

Thank you, Larry Kudlow

Every so often, a member of the "conservative movement" offers us a clarifying moment, that illustrates the fundamental differences between the values and ideas of the two major political parties. (Phil Gramm declaring Americans "whiners" for not appreciating how well the economy is doing ... for rich people like him; John "seven homes" McCain declaring that "the fundamentals of the economy are strong," while Rome is literally burning all around him, being just two examples.) This morning on "Morning Joe," CNBC host, GOP booster, laissez-faire economics guru and John McCain sympatico Larry Kudlow, offered up such a moment.


Asked to explain the current crisis on Wall Street and Main Street, Kudlow declared that it's not the fault of the investment banks and hedge fund guys who packaged, bought and sold subprime mortgages for sport and profit, driving up demand for bad loans and incentivizing shady lending, or even the banks themselves, and their coterie of crooked appraisers and greedy mortgage brokers. It wasn't the Republican Congresses who systematically stripped the system of regualtions, thanks in large part to John McCain's buddy Phil Gramm. It wasn't the speculators or the flippers buying second, third, and even fourth homes and condos, or the price-gouging builders raising prices $30,000 a month here in Florida, or the greedy developers and brokers pushing home ownership with "no money down" as the latest fashion trend, or the combined speculative market that juiced up of home values beyond all reason. Nope. Those people are well off, and therefore they're better than you.

No, my friends, it turns out our current economic crisis, led by the massive mortgage meltdown, is the fault of liberals, who literally forced banks to lend mortgage money to poor people so they could assuage their "liberal guilt," and of course, it's also the fault of those icky, horrible poor people themselves. How dare they want to live like the rest of us! Why, they're POOR! ... and that's supposed to mean something in America!

Never mind that percentage-wise, home ownership among the poor is literally negligible, and that a huge part of the housing crisis is the LACK of affordable homes for people with little income, or that the majority of these 3-bedroom, $500,000 homes that are really worth $250,000 are being sold not to the poor, but to the middle class, often at teaser rates that mean their mortgage payments can literally can double after a few years.

Forget all that, and listen to Larry. He knows that it really was those bloody awful poor people, and the whimpering liberals who pamper them, at the expense of the downtrodden, helpless banks.


After a few minutes of this, Joe Scarborough was literally dumbstruck.

"Okay, so you're saying it's the poor people's fault," he deadpanned. Kudlow sputtered, but he had already said too much.

Going into the break, Scarborough sneered that coming up in the next segment, they'd explain how poor people were behind the JFK assassination, too.

Damned poor people. They screw up everything...


Comments (17)

...Kudlow declared that it's not the fault of the investment banks and hedge fund guys who packaged, bought and sold subprime mortgages for sport and profit, driving up demand for bad loans and incentivizing shady lending, or even the banks themselves, and their coterie of crooked appraisers and greedy mortgage brokers. It wasn't the Republican Congresses who systematically stripped the system of regulations, thanks in large part to John McCain's buddy Phil Gramm.

Try this one: http://bigpicture.typepad.com/comments/2008/09/regulatory-exem.html

The SEC relaxed leverage regulations for the "Big Five" investment banks. Three are now gone, and the other two are coughing up blood:

Satow interviews the above quoted former SEC director, and he spits out the blunt truth: The current excess leverage now unwinding was the result of a purposeful SEC exemption given to five firms.

You read that right -- the events of the past year are not a mere accident, but are the results of a conscious and willful SEC decision to allow these firms to legally violate existing net capital rules that, in the past 30 years, had limited broker dealers debt-to-net capital ratio to 12-to-1.

Instead, the 2004 exemption -- given only to 5 firms -- allowed them to lever up 30 and even 40 to 1.

Who were the five that received this special exemption? You won't be surprised to learn that they were Goldman, Merrill, Lehman, Bear Stearns, and Morgan Stanley.

And then there were two...

Great link, OG. Doesn't it sometimes feel like you're reading a history textbook about the Robber Baron age?

Aww...now I'm blushing.

This is not history repeating itself exactly, rather it's rhyming. (Mark Twin?)

I'd take it back further to earlier times. We now have Nero campaigning to follow Caligula. Rhyming again, don'cha know?

Yeah, I guess what we really need to fix this country up right is a good, old fashioned Holocaust. Let's just get rid of all the poor people, they're just dead weight anyway.

Would that be A Modest Proposal?

Delicious irony! And excellent lunchtime reading. Thanks, OG!

http://www.uoregon.edu/~rbear/modest.html

avatar

The right-wing economists really don't have a good response to the situation. The 'It's the poor's fault' certainly is original.
The most common response I've heard is that the market still is too fettered, even after 30 years of deregulation. They're saying "We need the whole load, not the half-loaf we got."
But if the bread itself is poison....

I saw one of those poor people who ruined our country. They tried to get more than a trickle. Where is the outrage???

Don't they understand how our economy works? If we can't blow this bubble back up fast, our benefactors will be forced to raid 401ks and pensions. Free markets require this. The purity of capitalism demands it. And, a goverment for the people will ensure that we give our children the opportunity to pay for any losses that go beyond this. It is only right!

Poor people jsut because you're continually offered a stream and encouraged to drink doesn't mean you should. A trickle is enough for you.

That Kudlow looked like he was uppers last night on CNBC. One eye on the election the other on the ticker.

This from Crooks and Liars:

I hope these work….Contact Larry Kudlow here: Larry.Kudlow@cnbc.com Larry.Kudlow@nbcuni.com Call 877-251-5685 up until 7 pm EST and let him know how you feel in a respectful way.

avatar

I'm confuse about Scarborough.
I know he is of the Right, but on occasion recently he seems so disgusted with his co-righties that he just can't contain himself and the truth slips out.

avatar

Don't be fooled. Scarborough is a former GOP congressman from Florida. Any play to his being independent is laughable. He is a conservative Republican. Period! O'Reilly tries that trick every so often as well and it's just as laughable. Don't believe one bit of it.

Great post! Morning Joe is on ridiculously early where I live -- like from 4 am on -- I watched that this morning and could not believe my ears...

...those wretched, wretched poor people. Perhaps Dickinsonian workhouses, alms for the poor, and cold boiled potatoes are in order.

avatar

Larry Kudlow has always been a big cheerleader for Reaganomics. He's a supply-side touting, deregulation loving, free-market evangelist.

Kudlow is now faced with clear and convincing evidence that those economic policies are deeply flawed. So, how does he resolve this obvious conflict. Does he sanely reassess the correctness of his beliefs? No. He must find something else to blame. Liberalism.

Whether on religion, or foreign policy, or economic policy, conservatives are characterized by zealotry. Kudlow is just another insane, closed-minded conservative zealot. His zealotry is economic policy.

avatar

Pleas take a look at one of my recent posts
here
http://tpmcafe.talkingpointsmemo.com/talk/2008/09/the-myth-of-the-trickle-down-s.php

It explodes the MYTH of Trickle Down economics, I found a GREAT explanation of that MYTH by a guy named Jeff Alworth. It really makes the LIE of Trickle Down VERY EASY to understand.

And if nothing else lets start calling Trickle Down Economics what it actually is
"PISSED ON ECONOMICS"

avatar

Yoos can call it "Trickle Down," or yoos can call it "Supply Side," or yoos can call it "Bushitonomics," but ya doesn't have tuh make it complicated:

1. Spend all your savings,

2. Quit your job, and

3. Your income will INCREASE!

avatar

"No, my friends, it turns out our current economic crisis, led by the massive mortgage meltdown, is the fault of liberals, who literally forced banks to lend mortgage money to poor people so they could assuage their "liberal guilt," and of course, it's also the fault of those icky, horrible poor people themselves. How dare they want to live like the rest of us! Why, they're POOR! ... and that's supposed to mean something in America!"

So, let me get this straight: all those brilliant conservative saints -- they do the greed so we don't have to -- who made all those bad loans are (1) not liberals, and (2) not responsible for their actions.

So what's new in that sociopathy?

Post a Comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Book Club Calendar

Coming Soon



Nov. 30-Dec. 4



January 12-16



« Book Club ArchiveFull calendar »

Recent Reader Posts

All Reader Posts »





Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address