Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

Palin Community Organizer Gaffe Provides a Golden Opportunity

Sarah Palin and her handlers made an egregious miscalcaluation when they decided to mock community organizers all across America, and the Obama campaign needs to move right in for the checkmate in response to theis foolish Republican gambit.


What Barack Obama should do today is find about ten
community organizers from around the country, representing a cross section of different
ages ages, shades and genders.  He should
line them up, stand in front of them, and say:

 

This is the guy who kept the toxic waste dump out of your city;

 

This is the lady who took on the drug dealers in your neighborhood and chased them off the streets so your kids can walk to school in safety;

 

This is the fellow who turned a vacant lot in your neighborhood into ten beautiful baseball fields and soccer fields;

 

This is the young girl who lead a peer campaign in her school to end the vandalism of cemeteries and churches in your town;

 

This is the woman who cut teen pregnancy in half in your county;

 

This is the man who lead a campaign to organize volunteer adult education classes that taught English to hundreds of new Americans, and slashed the unemployment rate in his community.

 

I was proud to be a community organizer in Chicago twenty years ago; and I am proud to stand with these great Americans today.  The men and women standing behind me are the backbone of America.   When I am president, I will be calling on them, and thousands of others to help bring changes from the bottom up, not the top down.

 

I worked hard for the people of Chicago’s South Side, and these people are working hard for their your communities today.   We’re not going to stop.  But John McCain and Sarah Palin are deeply out of touch.   It takes more than a few folksy sayings and cheep cracks to show you understand what drives regular folks across this country.  Americans are tired of smug insults and ugly, divisive,  negative attacks from the phonies on the extreme right.

 

Game over.


Comments (40)

I like the "these men and women are the backbone of America." Words like that will hit home, itwill also say Obama is the backbone of America without actually saying so out loud. MAKE IT HAPPEN O CAMP.

Amen. I was thinking the same thing. And I've got an HD camera crew ready to roll here in Florida if we get the call.

Amen. I was thinking the same thing. And I've got an HD camera crew ready to roll here in Florida if we get the call.

Palouff's statement on the issue (sent in an email to campaign supporters:

"Both Rudy Giuliani and Sarah Palin specifically mocked Barack's experience as a community organizer on the South Side of Chicago more than two decades ago, where he worked with people who had lost jobs and been left behind when the local steel plants closed," Plouffe wrote. "Let's clarify something for them right now. Community organizing is how ordinary people respond to out-of-touch politicians and their failed policies."

This is going to be interesting. I don't think she bought herself enough cover with that speech. We'll see. I think Obama's sized her up and wants her on the ticket.

I posted this suggestion earlier today on Matt Yglesias's blog, and I like the slightly different last paragraph I used on Matt's blog a bit better than the one above. This was the other version:

I worked hard for the people of Chicago’s South Side, and these people are working hard for their your communities today. We’re not going to stop until we bring change to Washington. But John McCain and Sarah Palin are deeply out of touch. It takes more than a few folksy sayings and cheep cracks to show you understand what drives regular folks across this country. Americans are tired of the insult politics, and the ugly, divisive, negative attacks on real American heroes from the phonies on the extreme right.

I would add that as a TV commercial, you could have the organizers lock arms with Obama at the end of the spot, or put their hands together in the middle of a circle like a team before the start of a game, while Obama says "I'm Barack Obama, and I definitely approve this message." Show Obama as the coach or leader of a national team of volunteers out to change America, and sweep away the crud of the past eight years.

Beautiful, Dan K. I love this post and your ideas about turning this particular right-wing Republican line of attack against them. The term "community organizer" is code language used to conjure images of inner-city non-white people -- targets of the right-wing's cultural war. It appeals to the basest fears and prejudices of the voters they court.

An ad made with real-life community organizers will humanize this right-wing target, making it dangerous for right-wing operatives to continue this line of attack. It will also be a poignant statement about some of America's truest patriots, who quietly and without glory, work to improve America, as you say, from the bottom up.

I offer only one small tweak to your ad copy. Since one of Obama's themes is being in touch with Americans' weariness of bitter partisanship, it might be better to replace the last phrase "from the phonies on the extreme right" to "from cynical political operatives who care more about winning elections than improving the lives of Americans."

From your lips--er keyboard--to the Obama campaign's ears...

Thanks, Dan K.

Dan. Brilliantly done. One addition. Shoot the individual organizers faces in tight.... and then when you pull back, slowly, at the end..... show 10-50-100 local people standing behind each one. Soccer Moms... AA neighborhoods... Citizens who lived near local landfills... That would, I think, really help give the sense of America... community.... small town values... and movement.... in a powerful way. But nonetheless, a GREAT idea and congrats.

I love that quote by Plouffe at the end. "Community organizing is how ordinary people respond to out-of-touch politicians and their failed policies."
That should be in a commercial.

Email to the Obama camp...this is priceless and again puts an exclamation point behind American's fighting for America, one neighborhood at a time. WE work together for change. This IS about us, not him.

I like it! Not game over, but it could help, I think...

Dan, I really admire do both you and Obama for taking the political high road to counter McCain/Palin. I hope it works. Still, I do think an Democratic surrogate or 527 needs to consider a lower road, just not the ones many are using right now.

While watching Palin last night the movie Mean Girls came to mind. I noticed in Recent Posts today that I am not the only one Sarah Palin reminded of that movie. McCain is the male counterpart. It could be extremely effective to tie McCain/Palin to their adolescent personalities, Punk McNasty and Sarah Barracuda, in a funny pop culture way.

this is great.

Palin was a "real leader" because she lead a small town in the middle of no where. Inner city communities with big problems need leadership beyond "mayor" because we don't have one mayor per 6,000 people. Does Wasilla realize we have that many people on one block in New York?

this is great.

Palin was a "real leader" because she lead a small town in the middle of no where. Inner city communities with big problems need leadership beyond "mayor" because we don't have one mayor per 6,000 people. Does Wasilla realize we have that many people on one block in New York?

Great Stuff Dan! You gotta send this to Obama's people.

Hopefully, one of his people will read it here. But based on the Plouffe email, it sounds like they are already thinking along roughly these lines.

It was too early for Palin to take on the smarmy smirky too-Dick-Cheney kind of slimy attacks and insults.
Who does she think she is, a republican?
So she can memorize talking points and loves being in the limelight...that doesn't give her intellectual muscle, she flatters herself.
She's in way over her head..GOOD!

It was too early for Palin to take on the smarmy smirky too-Dick-Cheney kind of slimy attacks and insults.
Who does she think she is, a republican?
So she can memorize talking points and loves being in the limelight...that doesn't give her intellectual muscle, she flatters herself.
She's in way over her head..GOOD!

I agree. She is indeed in over her head. She won't do well in debates or in press conferences. The Republican Party won't be able to manage her contact with the media and press indefinitely.

A different take on this is up at DKos: A Photo History of Community Organizers.

Then there's this guy. Meet community organizer Jesus of Nazareth. He advocated for the poor, for the sick, for the socially excluded...and continues to help provide people solace during their "quiet storms." His community helped found the religion known as Christianity. He said "Do unto others as you would have them do unto you."

When I first read this post, it was several of te names on that Kos link that popped into my head and in addition blogosphere coverage, I think the idea could be dispensed with a couple of examples by the talking heads.

And, while a 527 could definitely put together an ad like Dan K suggested, I'd probably do it as a series of 15 seconds. I'd highlight only those local "organizers" who have received awards or kudos from an established (and recognized) government, or maybe from a local television station and I'd only run them in the communities where the "organizer" has made a difference.

Otherwise, a national or poorly targeted buy could run the much greater risk of alienating "Reagan Democrats" than it would benefit the party, especially because this disparagement was most likely the theme for just one night and maybe only a week's worth of speeches.

That's a valid point, agio, but I hardly think it's in Obama's interest to compare himself to Jesus!

The republicans do. Just saying.

They could leave Obama out of the ad, just making it about the Jesus being part of the group she just trashed.

Saul Alinsky, in some ways the founder of modern American community organizing, wrote in "Rules for Radicals" that the greatest community organizer of all time was Paul. The organization he founded around 2000 years ago now has over 2 billion members.

Yes. A thousand times yes.

This is how you win elections. The other side has only hate and fear. We have love and hope.

I like our chances.

Check it out Dan. Not quite what you suggested, but a good start. Best thing about the internet: we don't have to wait for the campaigns to pick up our ideas - we can get out there and do it together.
http://organizersfightback.wordpress.com/

Dan, I would so love to see the Obama campaign make that ad. Great idea! I'd love to see them work in the "service" theme, as well ...

Dan K,
Good judo. It is a perfect set up for Obama to ask: Just who are the elite?
But the limit of how far the denigration by Palin can be played against the Republicans has perhaps been best measured by C Wright Mills back in the Fifties:

But the corporate rich of the forties and fifties, in their economic and in their political aspects-there are no such stereotypes of them; they are rather cynically accepted, and even secretly admired by members of mass society. No negative stereotype has been widely formed of the corporate rich and the political outsider; and if one or two should crop up in popular imagery, they are soon vanquished by the 'forward-looking' energetic clean-cut American boy as executive.
Given the state of the mass society, we should not expect anything else. Most of its members are distracted by status, by the disclosures of pettier immoralities, and by that Machiavellianism-for-the-little-man that is the death of political insurgency. Perhaps it might be different were the intellectual community not so full of the conservative mood, not so comfortably timid, not so absorbed by the new gentility of many of its members. But given these conditions of mass society and intellectual community, we can readily understand why the power elite of America has no ideology and feels the need of none, why its rule is naked of ideas, its manipulation without attempted justification. It is this mindlessness of the powerful that is the true higher immorality of out time; for, with it, there is associated the organized irresponsibility of the American system of corporate power. (from The Power Elite, page341-342

The backlash against Palin's dismissive comment about community organizing is already a major topic on USA Today's political webpage.

I've already contributed TheraP's killer line in the comment section:

Jesus Christ was a community organizer.

Pontius Pilate was a governor.


I just luv watching the right-wingers squirm so soon after coming off their Palin high...

Just add the line that organizers don't "have" responsibility--they act responsibly to better life in their communities.

Dan. Brilliantly done.

One addition. Shoot the individual organizers faces in tight.... and then when you pull back, slowly, at the end..... show 10-50-100 local people standing behind each one, fanning out. Soccer Moms... AA neighborhoods... Citizens who lived near local landfills... That would, I think, really help give the sense of America... community.... small town values... and movement.... in a powerful way. But nonetheless, a GREAT idea and congrats.

Today NPR Talk Of The Nation had Wall Street Journal columnist John Fund on and he critisised Acorn and voter fraud.

He also talked about Obama being employed and their attorny. He implied that the Democrats had advanced voter fraud and other such lies.

This of cource is the cover for them to steal the elections again. Go to the NPR site and lisen.

http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=94282256

Talk of the Nation, September 4, 2008 · With the Republican National Convention in full swing in St. Paul, Minn., Talk of the Nation continues its series on the significance of this moment in the nation's history. Wall Street Journal columnist John Fund weighs in with his thoughts on the 2008 presidential election

Excellent post.

HAHAHAHA!!!! ITS amazing how the Obamanation Cults are panicking about SARAH Palin... Now you are getting a taste of your own medecine!!! ObamaNATION finally met his match..HAHAHAHA!!!! go go PALIN, YOU ARE BREATH OF FRESH AIR.

There's no need to panic, but there's no good reason to allow this thing to grow either. Hillary made that mistake with Obama, not attacking him enough early. Palin has a huge number of weaknesses, 18 million cracks I called it, but if her version of reality gets set in stone, it will be hard to undo it. She's fresh, she's vulnerable, she can be taken out easily. Now.

And this community organizer stuff won't fly. It just sounds too goody-two-shoes. These are Republicans we're running against now, the people who think it's manly to shoot someone in the face.

What does that matter? Obama isn't trying to get Michael Savage, Anne Coulter and the hard core nuts to vote for him. He's trying to get everyone in the middle to vote for him.

I agree Palin is very vulnerable. I think the main line of attack is to show that while she might remind you of your neighbor, your friend on the PTA, or the lady who brings the sandwiches to the road hockey games, her ideas are extremist and don't represent America.

Her ill-advised anti-organizing crack is a great place to start. It's hard even to guess who she is trying to appeal to, since I suspect most Americans admire and respect the people who work to get people together to improve their communities.

Maybe I should start my own post, because I have not seen anyone else address this, and I'd like to get this out, but Palin hired a township administrator. For a 7,000 person town. Ask all these small town people they keep alluding to which one really runs the town.

I like your suggestion. You should send it to barackobama.com. If you make a web based comment, they will read it and respond. I disagree with the idea that it's too "goody two shoes." We need to point out how unappealing and unproductive Palin/McCain's attacks are. They are attacking because that is all they can do. They certainly cannot defend the repub record.

Community organizers are the one's who push out the special interests who dominate politics in Washington. That's why Obama gets his money from lots of small contributors and doesn't use 527's. His whole campaign is about community organizing at a national level.

Post a Comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Book Club Calendar

Coming Soon



Nov. 30-Dec. 4



January 12-16



« Book Club ArchiveFull calendar »

Recent Reader Posts

All Reader Posts »





Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address