Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

Why McCain Chose Palin (Video)

Video

I regularly post videos on YouTube and I regularly read TPM, but my two worlds rarely cross. This vlog, however, I feel is particularly relevant to both.


Comments (18)

avatar

Interesting analysis, Dan. While we know that McCain is not nearly so clever, we know that Rove is.

Rec'd

avatar

My thought exactly!
Or almost exactly;

I think Rove's Protege, McCain's advisor, Steve Schmidt came up with it.

This particular kind of genius isn't that hard to teach once the student slips the bounds of his soul.

Good work! Nice analysis. You got a pimple on your forehead.

Interesting. The Obama campaign is not taking an aggressive stance on Palin and as you point out that's a good way to go right now. It works to the Dems advantage if they don't go aggressive with it because then they can use it as a defense when McCain attacks on experience. Focusing on judgment makes calls into question the wisdom of McCain's choice and also we have to look at a history of decisions made by Palin, we do have to get a sense of what her judgment is. To say humans didn't cause global warming raises some eyebrows. Her administrative history is slim and managing an economy that is awash in an oil tax surplus poses no challenge economically beyond how to spend the excess money. The tax she put through was a good move, but it's a windfall profits tax, which is a position Obama supports and McCain is against. It will be interesting to see how the two reconcile that, but I'm sure they have a good spin for it.

There are enough people and pundits out there that are alarmed at the very real possibility of Ms. Palin as POTUS at the whim of a malignant mole. There is no need for the campaign to jump on it.

Wow! You lose sleep over politics? Must be a privileged place. I lose sleep over my private and financial affairs.

I have to disagree with your analysis. She is a bona fide conservative and shores up right wing fundamentalist support. McCain agreed to picked her despite the fact that Palin's lack of qualifications or experience undermines his criticism of Obama on the same grounds.

Dan, I thought you did a good job in that piece of explaining your thoughts in an entertaining fashion -- good work. I think you may have a point. Don't know if this was a 'planned' strategy or just the result of the situation but the advice stands.

If he did pick her for the reasons you state, he completely failed

I have been reading comments quite a bit today and there are a few women out their who are going to vote for him now just because he has a woman on his ticket. They don't care who she is.
Some are still in shock and wondering WTF is going on. Some conservatives are very happy that there is a prolife, progun, etc woman on the ticket and that seems to be all they care about. There are a lot of rebuplicans and independents and I would say more women than men who are angry and feel this decision was reckless and demonstrates his judgement and they will NOT vote for him. Overall it looks like he will lose more than he gains.

avatar

My personal (cynical) analysis is this:

McCain chose Palin because the RNC didn't want to give up any Senators or Representatives, (it looks like they are going to lose too many as it is).

Palin accepted because she knows Obama is going to spank McCain in November and she jumped at the chance to put Alaska in the limelight.

If McCain goes down in flames BECAUSE of Palin - she's put the nail in her political coffin. I'm trying to see the best of intentions in that perhaps, just perhaps she is sacrificing herself for the good of Alaska?

Dwelling on the bad intentions also - I just can't understand how she justified accepting this nomination with a new baby and a new administration with a massive project (the largest in N. American history) in the works?

People here in Wasilla, Alaska think it's her ego that made her do it. All this time I thought it was envy talking when they would accuse her of ego-mania - but, I think they were right.

By the way, as a woman, I can tell you that women, in general, scrutinize other women far more than they do men.

Women are hard on other women, but high standards of ethics and women's rights demands that we are.

As a post-feminist woman raised by a feminist - we hate the sellouts more than the hypocrits.

It's why Hillary couldn't quite make it through that glass ceiling - she was seen as compromising her ethics to maintain a mutually advantageous marriage.

Hillary was also seen as an enabler of Bill's pattern of blatant sexual harassment in it's worst form - using his position of power to win sexual favors from subordinates. Bill didn't have affairs - he preyed on young women whose jobs he had control over.

I really appreciate your analysis of why Hillary didn't make it through because I've always thought that woman, like me, viewed her with some sympathy but also scorn that she put up with his very public philandering, and that it did make her seem more ambitious than real. We'll never know if she could have had a political career on her own after giving him the heave-ho, so I guess it's useless to speculate, but it's an interesting thought. Personally, I felt that she was robotic and unreal in her persona, no matter what she might be as a human being.

avatar

Thanks.

I think Hillary's story about being supremely qualified for the presidency but held back by questions about her motivations (and compromises) makes her uniquely qualified to speak to this issue.

What I find really disappointing is that she has made those questions 'off limits' and personal. I think any woman could have a lot to learn from the thought process that led her to 'forgive' Bill - and whether or not she ever fully appreciated the fact that so many women would see it as morally compromising instead of an act of personal strength.

As an Alaskan woman I am deeply saddened that Sarah Palin has allowed herself to be used as the poster child for the extreme right wing at the peril of Alaska.

As an atheist I admired her refusal to resort to religious right wing talking points to get elected - that admiration disintegrated early Friday morning. I naively believed Palin (and Alaska as a whole) rose above talking point politics.

Boy was I stupid.

I truly believed Alaska's Republicans got elected without the Jesus vote - and now our most prominent Republican just pandered to the NATIONAL Jesus vote?

I fear Alaska will not be understood (finally) but that the misunderstanding will deepen and the frenzy that is national politics will hurt more than help.

I take back any defense of Republicans I've done in the past.

I still believe that the 'good' Republicans still believe in basic Goldwater principles, less government, free markets, rule of law vs. nation building, religion in schools, out of control spending on purely ideological concepts.

I also think that with the nomination of Palin for VP - Goldwater conservatism has died, once and for all - ironically murdered by another Arizona Senator.

True conservatism has been hijacked and Palin is the martyr wearing the suicide vest.

Watched and enjoyed the video! God, I love your enthusiasm.

Spot on, Dan The Man!

Hey Dan, that was great! I agree, she is to be the distraction that serves to highlight McCain's supposed "strength" and conversely focus attention on Obama's supposed "inexperience." Your vlog was fun to watch. The unconscious analogy they are striving for is if Palin looks insignificant next to Biden in the debates, then Obama looks similarly callow next to McCain. Fab analysis!!!

The only problem with that idea is that Obama will not be diminished by McCain. Side by side, with questions that they HAVE to answer, I can't imagine McCain soaring to any heights over Obama.

No matter who likes or doesn't like Palin, does anyone here really think that of the people left who haven't made up their minds whom they will vote for, that this VEEP pick will bend them in McCain's direction? It seems to me the only positive for McCain from a November 4th standpoint is that the far-right won't stay home. If they were going to vote, they would always have voted for mcCain.

Very sassy vid. Good analysis. Rec'd.

I think this video sums up what John McCain was really hoping for... he thinks Sarah Palin will be his Wonder Woman. Check out the cool spin move on the cover of vogue

don't know how to embed, but, here's the video.

note the lyrics. hilarious.

http://david-sullivan.blogspot.com/2008/08/why-john-mccain-picked-sarah-palin.html

Hey, Dude. Did you know that youtube is running a McCain/Palin campaign gear ad at the bottom of your analysis? Amusing.

I think your idea has merit. I think we should leave Palin out; just marginalize her and continue to go after McCain for his bad judgement, temperatment, and decision-making.

Post a Comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Book Club Calendar

Coming Soon



Nov. 30-Dec. 4



January 12-16



« Book Club ArchiveFull calendar »

Recent Reader Posts

All Reader Posts »





Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address