Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

Using the POW Argument One Too Many Times OR When Being A POW Become THE Reason He Should Not Be President

I am willing to accept the ideathat Senator McCain does not remember how many houses he owns because... 'he was a POW'. And maybe the fact that he agreed that the only way to chase Osama Bin Laden to the 'Gates of Hell' is to reinstate the draft was because... 'he was a POW'. And perhaps the reason he cannot be expected to keep warring factions of various conflicts straight is because... 'he was a POW'.

Maybe he really did need to divorce his first wife by choosing a new one while still married to the first who was recovering from a tragic car accident because... 'he was a POW'. Perhaps he offered his wife Cindy, the potential next first lady to particpate in a contest much more lude than a wet t-shirt contest because... 'he was a POW'.

Maybe he got into a physical conflict with one of his colleagues in the senate because... 'he was a POW'. Perhaps he felt embellishing the story of how he and his wife came to adopt their daughter by adding a lie that Mother Theresa had asked Cindy to take her (She never met Mother Theresa and they were caught in the lie) was because... 'he was a POW'.

Maybe the reason that McCain thinks that the economy has done well during the Bush years is because... 'he was a POW'. And then it might explain the reason that he was ready to go to war in Iraq the day after 9/11 with NO facts, it was because... 'he was a POW'. I would love to believe that the reason that he has already declared victory in Iraq twice but still is dedicated to 'winning in Iraq' is because... 'he was a POW'.

Maybe he really wants to drill 'right here, right now' wherever he happens to be when he says it and this is explained by the fact that... 'he was a POW'. It stands to reason that you could explain the reason that he is comfortable with putting nuclear waste in the state of Nevada but would not want it traveling through his own home state of Arizona and advocates 45 new nuclear plants (where does the waste go?) is also because... 'he was a POW'. He probably believes that a gas tax holiday would really help people because... 'he was a POW'.

And maybe he could not help himself or perhaps those assisting him felt it was appropriate to make sure he knew the questions he was to be asked at the Saddleback forum and was well prepared even though it might have involved 'cheating' or 'misleading' people as this was really all excusable because...'he was a POW'. There is also his recent evoking of the second 'cold war' which can be explained away by the fact that... 'he was a POW'.

Clearly having been a POW has affected McCain in ways that cause him to have a poor memory, lack competence, experience confusion, have trouble keeping the facts straight, embellish the truth, be reckless in his judgement, be challenged in his ability to lead.

My friends, I am willng to accept that McCain being a POW is a reason to explain all of these things as long as the republican party and the McCain camp will accept that they have made the case for exactly why this man MUST NOT become president. Why? Because...'he was a POW'.


Comments (28)

WOW! Kapow!!! Right in the kisser! Rec'd!

avatar

Exactly! If having been a POW is the reason for his ongoing bad judgment then he needs medical care, not his finger on the nuclear button.

Highly rec'd...right on point and a good laugh to boot!

This ought to be the substance of many, many individually written letters to the editors of newspapers across America. This ought to be the substance of every discussion where McCain's brought up. This is perhaps the single refutation to McCain's constant citation of his ex-POW status. It's clearly damaged him - he's suffered terribly. (It helps that this is true.) He's suffered so much, he's so damaged by it, that he's simply not up to the demands of the Presidency of the United States.

Thanks. I agree and would invite any and all to use this as a spring board and go for it. I don't think officials or the Obama campaign can do it but the public can and if they do, the pundits will. Caveat: Do nothing to impune POW's in general or McCain's being a POW, simply agree with the argument, obviously being a POW takes a toll on Senator McCain, and take it to it's logical conclusion.

avatar

I like that! Ex-POW. Accurate. Can't be argued with the phrasing. He isn't a POW now. He WAS. "is an Ex-POW" negates POW, while "was a POW" is more in the affirmative. John Sidney McCain III, x-POW.

-Parallel Universe Rove

avatar

Having been a POW doesn't qualify McCain for anything. It undoubted reinforced his belligerent nature. check out this video


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LW4msHu_9EQ

Are you kidding? What gives you the right to be this funny? Oh yeah, I forgot,


because.............he was POW!!!

avatar

He was not a POW. He was a combatant detainee. There's a big difference. Or so I'm told.

avatar

For the love of god, don't say "my friends", that shit is like nails on a chalkboard for me now!!

Anyway, check out my shot blog on the POW-card, and see a picture of it for yourself!:

http://www.thepersonalispolitical.com/2008/08/has-mccain-finally-worn-out-pow-card.html

Thanks that was funny/scary..

What really is starting to piss me off, is how often the MSM continues to protect him, even while they are acting exercised by his POW pronouncements. Just take the last two days transcripts from the left leaning Keith Olbermann show:

Countdown with Keith Olbermann – transcript, August 20, 2008

OLBERMANN: Last point and briefly, I‘m doing this out of order but it‘s either do it out of order or ask you to wait 20 minutes to answer one question. If either presumptive nominee suddenly revealed he did not disagree with the idea of reinstating the military draft, what would happen to the numbers that we‘re seeing in the polls tonight?

TODD: Well, look—already, you would see numbers move probably among young voters, but let me just go here and give McCain the benefit of the doubt on what he might have thought he was agreeing to which is—he has been a big advocate on the national service front, as has Obama as a sort of mandatory service in some form that you see a lot of politicians take. So, it is possible that that‘s what he was talking about.

Countdown with Keith Olbermann – transcript, August 21, 2008

OLBERMANN: How many houses do the McCains have?

FINEMAN: Well, am I under oath?

OLBERMANN: Do you have a staff to get back to me?

FINEMAN: Yes.
We‘ll, we reported in the magazine last year seven; now, there are some reports on the Web of eight. People have looked through lots of real estate records and so forth. I didn‘t count them all. I‘ve been in a couple of them and I was at the ranch in Sedona, by the way, before that redo. I was there I think in 2001. There was no swimming pool. The thing that, I think, got McCain tripped up is that, I think, legally, he probably doesn‘t really own them per se, himself. When he married Cindy, he married into a family empire of, at least now worth, at least $100 million. Those houses are probably mostly in her name. So, he doesn‘t really pay attention to the details, which, in its own way, is almost more damming than knowing how many houses you have.


He can't remember how many house he (er, his wife) owns, indeed, because he was/is a P.O.W. The poor suffering Prisoner of Wealth.

Of course, his wife (er, second wife) needs all those homes for all their medicine cabinets. Tough being addicted to prescriptions painkillers.

That current wrist "injury" of hers? It was required to get the next case of Vicodin. Her last supply dried up after it was revealed that Cindy, the second wife (the rich one), was skimming meds from her pharmaceutical "charity." So she allowed John to step on her wrist with his Farragamo loafers to make it look good. (Check out her swirling eyes.)

Why does the beer baroness need all those painkillers to begin with? Well, she has had children with her Little John, and ... well, just imagining it makes me want to take a little edge off!

avatar

Whereas I would honor any of our men and women who have ever served our country, McCain's tenure as a POW should disturb everyone with respect to his mental capacity to be President. In order to mentally survive torture, assault and physical abuse, whether at the hands of parents, rapists or, in this case, your captors, the human mind pretty much has to compartmentalize what's going on -- allowing the "real" person to retreat from reality in order to maintain sanity and separate from what is being done to them. McCain obviously suffered severe physical torture. No one knows what it did to his mind. Post-traumatic stress syndrome is not something that goes away or resolves easily. I remember a friend whose husband came back from Viet Nam and would never talk about his experiences. However, any time a car backfired on the street outside the home, he would instinctively throw himself on her or the kids to protect them. McCain was a womanizer before he went to Viet Nam and obviously afterwards. He got into Annapolis on the basis of his father's and grandfather's ranks as Admirals (which McCain was passed over for years later). He ranked about fifth from the bottom of his class of 900. Learned a lot about military history and tactics, did he? However, he clearly sees the world through the eyes of a warrior, as his first response to a political probelm is to destroy the enemy. His temperment and inability to control his temper are well-documented. He has been extremely disrespectful to his first and second wives (calling Cindy a C___ in public for teasing him about going bald, wet T-shirt contest, etc.) and is on record as not supporting a single so-called woman's issue that he has ever had a chance to vote on. He is a compulsive craps player and has had to be pulled back from the gaming tables in Vegas lest someone get the wrong (right) idea. Craps is a game of pure chance and epitomizes the rush of the gambler. His so-called Maverick appeal has been more attention-getting behavior or political positioning than anything else. So let's see, he is not particularly intelligent, he survived five years in captivity at an unknown cost to his psyche, he is a womanizer from way back and is disrespectful of women in general, he has never held a private sector job (other than as a beer distributor, presumably for Cindy's father), he is a compulsive craps player, a political opportunist of the worst kind nand his first impulse is to attack a problem militarily in a world of complex nuances. Did I mention that he was a POW?

Oy vey, sweet, it looks like your post is full of excellent points, but I can't read it without paragraphs and am a little too wound up to cut and paste it into Word and then reformat it...

Be kind to your old fogey colleagues with lousy vision!

Remember how quick and eager and fierce the McCain camp trotted out the argument that Obama was "playing the race card"? They're obviously trying to discourage Obama from ever bringing up the subject of race again, even when it might actually be to his advantage. They're trying to take one important aspect of Obama's biography off the table. They're trying to purge that biography from the public discourse.

So from here on out, every time the McCain Camp trots out the "McCain was a POW" meme, the Obama camp needs to bring out a Democratic ex-POW surrogate who roughs up McCain for "playing the POW card". Say he's trivializing and exploiting POWs for political gain.

Two can play at that game.

Joe, that's brilliant. I can't remember which one it was, but way back in the old days, maybe 2 months ago, a pro-Obama general got bullied by a reporter into saying that having been a POW isn't a qualification for the presidency. He got creamed for it, with lots of media disgust at the idea of 'belittling' McCain's suffering.

But now McCain's opened the door and, so long as it doesn't come directly and blatantly from Obama, tearing down the POW defense will start to expose McCain for who he is: a very, very scary guy.

avatar

He gives POWs a bad name.

My friends, the POW-card for the McCain camp is his "tell" to use a poker analogy.

Any time the McCain campaign trots out any variation of the phrase, that should be the signal to "go all in" from an attack perspective.

Adding - it should also be a signal for the press to serisously look into McCain's stance/background/etc on whatever that issue happens to be.

Not that I will hold my breath for that, though.

Sorry, I feel the same way about the phrase but in this instance I was trying to go along with 'their' argument so I felt it was appropriate to use this under the circumstances.

Oh yes, I love the post! In fact, we could probably make some kind of a mad-libs kind of game out of it. :)

"Perhaps he offered his wife Cindy, the potential next first lady to particpate in a contest much more lude than a wet t-shirt contest because... 'he was a POW'."

Lauren, did you spell "lewd" this way because you are (al)luding to another drug problem we haven't yet heard about? I wouldn't put it past you.

It may have deserved it's own line, the drug thing, but I don't reall know enough about it... is it possible that she has a prescription drug problem because... he was a POW? I suppose but honestly I probably just mispelled it. Sometimes when I am feeling heated about something I get careless as you can see there are a couple of mistakes but it's funny that it works in this context.

I'm ashamed to read this kind of garbage.

avatar

Ashamed? For McCain? For yourself? For the blogger? For society? Please explain.

You have a right to 'feel' however you may. I think I convey a valid point here. But clearly we disagree.

Post a Comment

Inside Cafe

Recent Reader Posts

All Reader Posts »





Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Claire Wilcox



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address