Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

Truth To Power. This Obama Supporter Thinks That Obama Did Screw Up His Own Message.

avatar

Senator Obama recently said that he is looking for VP candidate that will not be just a yes person, and someone who will challenge him, when he thinks that he is wrong. I wonder if he has some senior campaign people that are willing to do that? The reason why I ask that question is:

I think Senator Obama is getting careless with some of his prepared speeches. Most of you know that I am an ardent Obama backer, but I do think he should not be pointing out how he looks different. Here is my reasoning on that issue.

When he gave his keynote speech, and his race relations speech, he stressed that there is not a black America and a white America, there is the United States of America. When he then starts to draw attention to his color, and lets be honest about this, when he said in Berlin that he does not look like the previous Americans who had spoken there, of course he was talking about his racial difference. Every one who heard that speech knew that he was making that point.

I felt at the time that that was striking a discordant note with his one America theme. Why did he even have to bring it up. His skin color is apparent. He should not be making a point of it.

Now, this is where I think that his campaign staff are being sloppy. They should not have ever let him say that in Germany. Then, when returned home, as is usual with most candidates, they recycle a lot of their prior speeches, and what he said in Germany he repeated to a domestic crowd.

I would not be at all surprised if the McCain camp had taken note of what he said in Berlin about looking different, and were just waiting for him to repeat it to any American audience, and they were ready to pounce.

I think Obama made a mistake. Drawing attention to how he looks different, conflicts with his message of one America. He needs to be told that, and stop pointing out how he looks to people who can see how he looks.

I do not believe that he was intentionally playing the race card. I think that, in Berlin,  he was attempting to highlight the historic nature of his nomination, but then he got sloppy and used the same language to slip into decrying the Republican attacks on him.

That was a big mistake. His staff better get their act together. The candidate is on such a hectic schedule that he does not have any time for reflection and contemplation about the impact of such words. His staff better be doing so. On this occasion they did not. They better not let it keep happening.

This is elementary folks. The first black nominee for President should not be making any allusions to his skin color or race.  Senator Obama started out knowing that. His campaign staff are supposed to make sure that his speeches do not contradict that.


Comments (29)

I think I agree with you.

Obama lied about filibustering the FISA bill when he was campaigning in Wisconsin, he lied about opposing NAFTA when he was campaigning in Ohio, he wants to expand the horizons of the death penalty, he undermines public campaign financing and sides with the NRA about gun control, and the Obamabots think he has a problem because he alluded to his color.

Harharharhar!!!

Smart comments, liam. Obama does get pretty loose when giving speeches as if he forgets that the real audience is not there in front of him. He's got every right to be a bit self-congratulatory with the people in the room, but when it appears out of context on YouTube and CNN, it seems like he, too, is less interested in issues than in his historic candidacy. Make the networks cover sound bites that have to do with issues and McCain's soft-headed preparation to lead.

But... but .... Web 2.0 was supposed to be Obama's meat. What happened?

I agree. But do you remember reading the commentary here on TPM just after the "celebrity" ad came out? TPMers were the biggest YES men and women on the planet, refusing to concede that Obama was referring at all to his race by saying he "looked different", and so eager to play the race card against McCain just like they did against Bill and Hillary Clinton.

It's infuriating. No wonder there's talk of TPM readers and Josh Marshall as Kool Aid drinkers.

I agree with you too. There are many proudly rabid supporters around here, willing to go to any level of intellectual dishonesty for their candidate.

And all they do is harm him. No wonder McCain can now prick Obama's ego with ads like The Mighty Hand! If the mindless adulation doesn't stop soon, Obama is going to wake up not even put behind in the tracking polls.

I agree with you, though I sincerely wish he could talk about his color (and the historic nature of his running) without it being a "race card" issue. In a perfect world, it wouldn't be. Perhaps after he wins, we'll be that much closer to it not being a "race card" issue.

I think he can talk about his color, just not in the context of the Republicans will try to frighten you because I'm black. That is the race card. Period. He did it. He has now admitted he did it. Let's move on and hope he doesn't do it again.

Anyway. We now know how McCain will go after him in the debates. With ridicule and humor.

avatar

But the race card seems to be the only card David Axelrod has up his sleeve.

avatar

I agree with this sentiment, but I contend there is some context missing from this current discussion.

The "dollar bill" reference to which the GOP has manufactured their faux outrage du jour was originally brought up...by the GOP.

avatar

i love it when you people say he shouldn't bring attention to his race, but yet he is getting creamed on the sly by the smarter folks who do bring attention to it every chance they can...

obama camp did make a huge mistake---THAT mistake was in denying that race is a huge issue in this race....Mccain doesnt have to come out and obama is a n_g-e-,muslim, outsider, his surrogates don't have to use those exact words either..instead they say, he cannot connect with bigoted america, he is unpatriotic by accusing him of treason, inject his middle name every chance they get to scare off those who already inclined to be bigoted, repeatedly call him an empty suit even though he has thus far outsmarted and upstaged his accusers and now they are copying his policies, he is exotic which is code word for "foreign, un-American, MUSLIM/osama bin laden long lost relative!!!

Obama is making a mistake everytime he pretends this is not happening...i agree he needs to polish up his speeches...lately, he has been grating on my nerves with his "slow way of talking", but i think he and his campaign are out of synch..obama is hell bent on calling Mccain and company out on B.S. but his campaign (white men) are running away from the reality of this and they are denying it at every turn and making Obama look stupid!!

avatar

cher, Muslims are not a "race."

avatar

First, learn what "truth to power" means. Second, it is asinine to think that Obama can ignore the fact that his skin color is a major factor for millions of voters. (It probably is the only factor for most of them.) He has a delicate task trying to assauge the brainless fears of white America and maintain some integrity, but to ignore it entirely merely confirms the national psychosis. Remember when John F. Kennedy frankly confronted anti-Catholic prejudice in 1960? Funny: no one accused him of playing the "Papist" card.

avatar

John Kennedy did not go around talking about how he was different than every other president on the dollar bills.

Senator Obama did the same thing as Kennedy did, when he spoke to the Protestant ministers about his faith, when Senator Obama gave his major speech on race, after the Rev. Wright uproar.

Kennedy did not continue to draw attention to his religion after he made his major speech. Obama should do the same on the issue of race. To keep trying to score some points at campaign events on the issue is actually creating the conditions for the McCain camp to play the race card while being able to use the cover story of Obama being the one that keeps mentioning it.

Senator Obama had it right when he ran on the One America, neither black or white America, theme.

He should stick to that sheet music. Political campaigning is no time for improvisational jazz riff that are not on on the score. Too many chance to hit some sour notes.

He planned the play. He needs to get back to playing the plan.

avatar

jaja MANDY, you nailed it...WHITE america want to brush the race thing to the side at every opportunity, but in the shadows, it is often the most important factor in deciding important issues...no one wants it to dominate the conversation, but if a black man cannot say he is black, then we have a problem!!! so what do we call it when a white man or men or white men and white women on the other side and on our side use euphemisms for "black"? is it still the race card???

at this moment, i am having a huge problem with camp obama (those white men who think they know better on how to deal with the fact that obama is BLACK and that fact makes a lot of us squirm in our pants/panties..it is a fact...acknowledging that fact is smart...people need to understand that Mccain and company are not trying to knock out their opponent, they have a delicate task of reminding all of america that a black man with a muslim sounding name, who is too smart for his own good, is a threat to the legacy of all white people in america!!! at least when hrc said it, she was just trying to win and was dirty enough to do just about anything to win (i truly believe that), but the other side have a blatant racism handicap that has dogged them for an eternity, so there is no reason why we should expect that obama's race wouldn't be fair game...

where were you guys when that cartoon character of michelle and obama came out? oh i remember, that was harmless humor....if you are white, you will never ever understand what life is like as a non-white..it unfathomable to think of a world where you wouldn't be automatically revered b/c of your skin...i am a foreigner and i am well-read and travel all over..one thing rings true, deep inside all non-whites cling to that 1/18th bloodline that was white and they guard it with great earnst...

i really take offense when we say obama should not draw attention to his color...hello one cannot help but notice that he is indeed DIFFERENT from the prez on the dollar bills..that is a fact! now that we know this, let's not let the other side scare us into thinking that is enough to disqualify him for the CIC post...

I am surprised at you liam!!!

avatar

Well, I am trying to make sure that he wins, and I think that if gets defined as being the candidate that represent just his race, he will have no chance to do so. Every time he talks about looking different, at campaign events, he is providing McCain more cover to talk up racial differences and to define Obama in a racial context.

Senator Obama started out knowing that he had to stay above racial debates, and to run on the one America theme. I think he is making a huge mistake if he abandons his original sound judgment that has served him well.

avatar

ok alright, i concede it sounds more eloquent in a formal lecture...i just think he needs to refine his rebuttal to mccain..in order to that, he must call a spade a spade....

he cannot say the words racism, but he can say and should continue to say that mccain camp is out to scare people into think obama is a risk bc he is well, DIFFERENT!!!! he can throw in a few, "one america" lines to take the edge of the 'dirty truth'

avatar

that was some terrible posting...i wish we had an edit button or a preview post button.....i didnt anything too important so no need to repost....

I'm sorry, but you've got it the other way round....I'm all for Truth to Power, but the Power is really the entrenched political and media interests that are doing a Swiftboating to Obama right now, taking his quotes out of context and changing their meaning, driving the negative publicity by repeating ad nauseum McCain's ads and talking points as if they're great news.

Once again, we're blaming the Candidate, why can't Kerry be less "effete", why did Gore say "He invented the internet"?, and NOT the forces that are unfairly stacked against them.

avatar

What did you think was going to happen?

avatar

I actually believe it takes a wildly convoluted construction of Obama's "dollar bill" comments to suggest he was playing the race card there. He probably should be a little more careful but I am tired of this tiptoe around attitude or PC gone bonkers world we live in. Last night on the Charlie Rose program I saw Barbara Walters talk about her decision to keep secret her 1970's affair with a MA. senator who happened to be black (He was also married though he did get a divorce from the wife he had at the time.) She talked about it in her autobiography to show how ridiculous the prevailing social mores of the time were. We will look back on this election decades from now with the same disbelief about how silly so many were.

avatar
I actually believe it takes a wildly convoluted construction of Obama's "dollar bill" comments to suggest he was playing the race card there.

Well, Obama admitted he did play the race card, so I guess it's not so wildly convoluted after all.

avatar

I am not willing to just accept your word on that.
Provide proof that he admitted doing so. I do not trust you.

avatar

To my knowledge, Obama hasn't admitted any such thing.

In fact, David Axelrod commented on the furor - and his remarks were interpreted two different ways, by two different right-leaning sources.

ABC had Axelrod (and, hence, Obama) admitting they "played the race card". RealClearPolitics, though, had a headline saying, "Obama Denies Playing Race Card" - citing the same Axelrod interview.

And Obama's brought this sort of thing up before - in fact, as early as 2004 at the DNC, where his keynote talked about being "the skinny kid with the funny name".

Look, McCain has TONS of material that are just as sensational. I assure you that I can blow up the "100 Years in Iraq" "Bomb, bomb, bomb Iran" comments if I get enough talking heads around on a TV show. I'll even ask if he's trigger-happy, or mentally sound to even publicly declare such a thing. I'd be saying, "We're stuck in a war that the American people want to get out of, is he proposing that we double down?" "Is he a reckless gambler?" "Did Vietnam damage him in somme way?" I'll show pie charts, I'll quote McCain's associates, I can make a truly juicy series out of this that would grab headlines. I can make McCain look like the senile, reckless gambler, PTSD victim he really is. I CAN, seriously.

If it's about ratings and audience, McCain is much richer fodder as he made so many gaffes, but these are all STUDIOUSLY avoided by the MSM, just think about it. They have *their* candidate, and all the mone we raised for Obama cannot pit against this media juggernaut.

At least I now take comfort in the fact that Obama is DEFINITELY NOT one of them, not one of the Powers that be. McCain is their pawn.

The first thing anyone in the media would do, unless they CHOOSE not to do it, is to look up the context of Obama's words to see what he was really trying to say, and what he said expressed overt humility instead of what they're splashing across the headlines.

The talking heads and the MSM have a target and right now, they're rejoicing and patting themselves in the back. How easy it is to shape Public Opinion, even yours, and they're right.

avatar

Both campaigns have been accused of playing the race card. But what about the media? When will they be called out on this? I mean, have you ever seen Sean Hannity? He thinks Obama is a black muslim terrorist. He says Obama is anti-American. He's different. He can't represent "real America". And it's not just limited to Fox.

Joe Watkins, an MSNBC correspondent has said "white people are running away from Obama in droves"

And it's the media that plays this narrative, and others repeatedly, as if they're instigating the stuff.

I think an example has to be made about the media perpetuates and at times, creates news, as opposed to reporting it.


avatar

Didn't Obama make comments similar to this long before this current brouhaha? I could have sworn he used the comment about the funny last name.

avatar

You are correct. In fact, the comment you refer to was near the end of his keynote address at the 2004 Democratic National Convention.

Post a Comment

Inside Cafe

Recent Reader Posts

All Reader Posts »





Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Claire Wilcox



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address