Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

Sarah Palin Has Changed the Landscape of this Election

Something very distinctive happened today in the short and truly unmemorable speeches of Senator John McCain and Sarah Palin, when he announced her as his Vice-Presidential running mate. Simply put, McCain's entire campaign message has changed.

His decision on picking Palin was made on Thursday morning. This is important, as it came before Obama speech, but after both Hillary and Bill Clinton's speeches, and then of course, Joe Biden's speech.

McCain saw that they were not backing down against him. The Democrats were hitting him hard and showing him for his true colors as a hypocritical Bush lackey. There was only one way McCain could curb the onslaught he knew he would face in Barack Obama's speech, and then subsequently in the weeks to come. The Democrats had hit it home: McCain was not change, he was not reform, and he was nothing but more of the same Bush policies and politics.

So, he picks Sarah Palin, a young, attractive Washington outsider who has a (very slim) record of reform in her (very small) state of Alaska. That, my friends (snark!), is the key. John McCain is no longer going to be running on the failing message that he's most qualified to lead. He will be running on the message that he'll be going to Washington to reform it, along with his reformist pretty girl.

Essentially, the campaign has no longer become one of change vs. experience, but one of change vs. reform, concepts that to many will be seen as synonymous, but to the observant voter, will be seen as nothing more than a gimmick.

Does Palin being on the ticket essentially destroy the argument that Obama is not ready to lead? Yes, and that was precisely what McCain was counting on. But the key here is in the result. McCain will now be forced to fight Obama on Obama's ground, rather than continue to fight on his own. Who is most qualified, not to be in the White House, but to change and/or reform Washington.

In a way, Obama should be happy. This is, after all, the debate he wanted to have, isn't it? Who will actually change the Washington establishment? Perhaps, though, it's not. Obama's strategy has always been one of policy, not of character (though he has plenty). Whomever wins on policy, essentially, wins the election. I agree, and his acceptance speech confirmed it. But Palin has forced change not to be debated on what policies will be different, but simply on what character will be different.

Obama should, from this time forth, attack McCain and Palin on their knowledge, their expertise, and their abilities to face the policy challenges, both foreign and domestic, of the next administration. He has proven he has the judgment and character to lead the nation. Can his policies and positions also hold up? The answer, unequivocally, is yes, and if he can make that clear to voters, Palin's entire candidacy will seem, in a sense, absurd.


Comments (10)

Drop the "pretty girl" comment and you have an excellent post.

McCain just shot himself in the foot. maybe both feet.

Thank you.

I stand by that, as that's exactly what she is, and precisely how she's been presented to us.

I respect your opinion on it, though, and certainly understand.

Interestingly enough, Al Giordano disagrees with my thought on this. He says,

Palin will create a sideshow full of fluff, great magazine covers, and such, but won't help McCain any more than Geraldine Ferraro helped Mondale in 1984. In sum: Don't worry about it. This doesn't change the essential dynamics of the Obama v. McCain contest at all.

Perhaps he's right, but the end result is the same: she doesn't do much to enhance McCain's ticket.

http://narcosphere.narconews.com/thefield/celebrity

mccain is pandering to gain the hillary women but realize the party merged the repubs are trying to tear it apart by mccan selecting palin. however palin is not hillary and hill will step in due to she wants her health care program passed with obama. it an insult to women to think he can substitue palin for hill. the issues are too important

Rec'd

Rec'd

Rec'd

I think you make great points. Yes, McCain is apparently trying to correct course and acknowledge that, in this change election, he needs to pull back on the experience focus. I've listened to the Republican flacks today, and sure enough, the talking points bear this out.

Using Palin to dress himself as a "reform" candidate is purely cosmetic. I wonder if the average voter will pick up on that? My feeling is that Republicans are relying too much on image fixes to address the flaws in their campaign. It won't be enough, because the undecided moderate independent voters -- the bloc that will determine who wins this election -- are not going to hear much from John McCain and Republicans to relieve the economic anxieties they feel right now. I feel that economic anxiety is real, palpable, and growing, and it's going to be the single biggest motivator for this particular voting bloc. That's usually bad news for Republicans -- and this time, with economic policy being their biggest obstacle, their VP pick, as far as I can tell, does nothing to improve that situation.

I think you make great points. Yes, McCain is apparently trying to correct course and acknowledge that, in this change election, he needs to pull back on the experience focus. I've listened to the Republican flacks today, and sure enough, the talking points bear this out.

Using Palin to dress himself as a "reform" candidate is purely cosmetic. I wonder if the average voter will pick up on that? My feeling is that Republicans are relying too much on image fixes to address the flaws in their campaign. It won't be enough, because the undecided moderate independent voters -- the bloc that will determine who wins this election -- are not going to hear much from John McCain and Republicans to relieve the economic anxieties they feel right now. I feel that economic anxiety is real, palpable, and growing, and it's going to be the single biggest motivator for this particular voting bloc. That's usually bad news for Republicans -- and this time, with economic policy being their biggest obstacle, their VP pick, as far as I can tell, does nothing to improve that situation.

The issue with comments today is really getting frustrating. I guess it's slightly comforting to know others are having the same issues.

Post a Comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Book Club Calendar

Coming Soon



Nov. 30-Dec. 4



January 12-16



« Book Club ArchiveFull calendar »

Recent Reader Posts

All Reader Posts »





Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address