Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

Obama is the One that made race the issue.

avatar

Obama is the One that made race the issue.

KNOXVILLE (8/5) - In a year when it may only be slight hyperbole to say that no Democratic candidate for President could lose, Obama may have made a fatal mistake that will hand the Republicans a victory.

On June 20th he made race an issue saying, “Did I mention he’s black.” Just last week he said three times in one day: “I want look like the others on the money.”

The McCain campaign fired back that Obama was making race an issue. Senator Lindsay Graham agreed. No secret campaign memo is necessary to prove this point.

These recent comments by Obama are just the tip of the iceberg.


Comments (21)

No John McCain made race an issue.

My statement is just about as substantive as yours.

avatar

Apparently, part of the post didn't take. The rest is below. I think there is substance.


http://benhoffman.wordpress.com/

Read Gene Robinson in WaPo and get back to me.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/08/04/AR2008080401824.html?hpid=opinionsbox1

avatar

Eugene Robinson is a fool if he thinks what Obama said in his "throw away line" doesn't imply that his opponents are racists. Why else would anyone say that Obama looks different if they weren't racists? It logically makes no sense. It's like saying "Hey, don't vote for the black guy."

That's racist, Eugene. Obama was implying that his opponents would use racist tactics against him. And that is the very definition of playing the race card.

That said, McCain and the Republicans (and many Democrats for that matter) are guilty as charged. Both sides have played the race card, subtly and overtly.

How bad do you think this is going to get before November? I shudder to think.

avatar

You need to get caught up here.

McCain released a web ad in JUNE showing Obama's face on US currency.

In July, Obama makes his "all the other presidents" comment.

McCain then says Obama's "playing the race card" (can we please retire that phrase?) because Obama referenced something McCain had already done.

If you don't like how Obama responded (or didn't respond) to McCain's allegation, fine. But to say that Obama started this is simply a lie.

avatar

Sorry. You need to go back further. Obama has been mentioning his race for months, going back to the early days of the primary.

avatar

You're engaging in revisionist history.

Obama tried very hard to keep race OUT of the discussion, going back to the primary. He only addressed it after the Wright sermons broke.

Obama has NO motive to talk about race. Any day that he spends discussing race is a bad day, period.

That line about Republicans trying to demonize Obama because he's different from presidents on dollar bills is hardly inciting a race riot. Besides, it's...um...true.

The McCain response is straight out of the Rove playbook - blame your opponent for something you did. If that hackneyed card got played, it was by the Maverick - and calling him on it is not only wrong, but way overdue.

And then read Bob Herbert.

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/08/02/opinion/02herbert.html

Of course he did. By simply being black. What was he even thinking, being born with darker pigmented skin than the majority of Americans?

As Greg said, Obama was almost asking for it.

But, hey, extra McCain bonus troll points for trying.

When the President of the dem party has to state he is not a racist, it is very obvious who played the race card.

The President of the dem party having to say he is not a racist is a new low for dem politics.

Disgusting and unforgivable.

avatar

Obviously, you missed Bill Clinton's treatment of Paul Tsongas in 1992.

Bill Clinton is not President of any party. If he isn't racist, then he's a racial opportunist, always ready to do whatever it takes to win.

avatar

For the record, I firmly do not see the Clintons as racists. Quite the opposite, actually - their campaign and administration hires prove that, I would argue.

However, what I said throughout the primary is that the Clintons were certainly guilty of race-baiting. They were more than willing to exploit racial divides to drive up the white vote.

Politically, this is completely understandable. But there's nothing wrong with pointing it out either.

Race baiting is even more cynical than being an outright racist. One presumes that the baiter knows better, but is willing to cross the line anyway. Such calculus even more despicable than the blathering of the ignorant yahoo who was raised by ignorant yahoos.

avatar

I get where you're coming from, but I actually didn't get too worked up about the Clinton tactics during the primary, for two reasons.

(1) If you're playing to win, you try to get votes where you can. After the Mississippi primary, it was brutally obvious that Clinton wasn't going to crack 10% in A-A support in any remaining primary. So, that left her Hispanics and Whites - and the Hispanic population after Texas was almost negligible. So, she tried to drive up her margins with White voters. Cynical? Absolutely. Necessary? Completely.

(2) The Clintons came of age on the national political scene and went through a very tough eight years in the White House. I think the lessons they took from that are that you say or do whatever you must to win that day, that news cycle or that election. That doesn't make their actions during the '08 primary any better - but more understandable.

avatar

Obama said that his opponent would try to scare people by pointing out that he looked different than the other presidents on currency BECAUSE McCAIN HAD DONE JUST THAT!!!

Please see this thread:
http://tpmcafe.talkingpointsmemo.com/talk/2008/08/dollargate-the-washington-post.php

It frustrates me to no end that this hasn't become part of the discussion when this issue comes up. I know why Obama's camp isn't pushing it; they don't want to make it look to outsiders like they're whining and playing the victim. But why isn't this being reported by any journalists, anywhere?

A little research, and you turn this debate on it's ear. The talking heads still get to talk about racial politics, which you know they're dying to do, except they milk this story a bit, and now discuss a new angle in looking critically at John McCain's campaign.

Yet nobody wanted to disrupt the narrative they were building, which was "Angry McCain Slaps Sneaky Obama".

The entire week pissed me off.

right on.

this whole issue is such a piece of crap (jeez Lux getting vulgar) this is such a stretch, such a waste of our time.

Calling Obama "EXOTIC", that's a race card.

Calling Obama "Presumptuous" that's very close.

Showing Obama juxtaposed with some skank celebutards, that's very close.

pot calling the kettle "exotic"

avatar

Apparently only part of the original post made it. So here is full post. Sorry.

Obama is the One that made race the issue.

KNOXVILLE (8/5) - In a year when it may only be slight hyperbole to say that no Democratic candidate for President could lose, Obama may have made a fatal mistake that will hand the Republicans a victory.

On June 20th he made race an issue saying, “Did I mention he’s black.” Just last week he said three times in one day: “I want look like the others on the money.”

The McCain campaign fired back that Obama was making race an issue. Senator Lindsay Graham agreed. No secret campaign memo is necessary to prove this point.

These recent comments by Obama are just the tip of the iceberg.
From day one Barrack Obama made race an issue and has played identity politics to the hilt all the way.

Obama choose a date - on or about Abraham Lincoln’s birthday - to announce his run for president. He chose Springfield, Illinois – a home of Lincoln – as the place to announce. He even chose the very courthouse steps to make the announcement that Lincoln announced his run for the presidency. And, he spoke of Abraham Lincoln and slavery in his announcement speech.

His stump speech always mentioned Abraham Lincoln and slavery at least through the South Carolina primary. And, under a category called “hope” he made sure to revive the images of police beatings, the flailing batons and of the vicious dogs being unleashed upon blacks.

He rarely, if ever, missed the opportunity to add “and blacks died.” He said “and blacks died,” “and blacks died,” “and blacks died,” over and over again.

On the day of the South Carolina primary Obama, speaking before a primarily black audience, said, “You know how they are. The ole okie-dokie. The bamboozle.”

Spike Lee made clear in the movie Malcolm X that when Malcolm X said something similar that he was talking about “white” people.

Identity politics worked through the Democratic primaries. Donna Brazille (John Kerry’s campaign manager) threatened to leave the Democratic Party; Congressman Clyburn of South Carolina (third ranking democrat in Congress) threatened “irreparable” damage to the Democratic Party; Color of Change (boasting 400,000 black membership) made its threats; Al Sharpen threaten marches (code for riots); and certain super delegates like Diane Watson (a black Congresswoman from Los Angeles), among others, were threatened.

Obama never objected or even once said stop threatening his party; stop threatening America. He just rode the wave he set in motion and pretended it was others.

Is making race the issue a winning strategy for Obama?

Post a Comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Book Club Calendar

Coming Soon



Nov. 30-Dec. 4



January 12-16



« Book Club ArchiveFull calendar »

Recent Reader Posts

All Reader Posts »





Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address