« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »
"...as it should be."
(Cross-posted at 1,369 lightbulbs.)
Michelle Obama spoke, and I watched as her eyes glazed with the beginning of tears.
When Mrs. Obama stepped to the lectern last night, several goals had been put before her. Mind you, they weren't necessarily her goals, her husband's goals or even those of the party whose convention she was addressing. Mainly, it seemed that the goals were set before her by the political punditry, deeming either that she needed to buttress the racist charges against her and her family which have been miming as "questions about patriotism", goading her into proclaiming how much she loves America. Some were foisted upon her by us Black folks, treasuring the history being made as a strong, very well-educated woman, descended from African slaves, stood before America to tell us why her husband, another Black man, should be President of the United States.
But as I reflect on her speech, I realize that there's one thing that Michelle herself wanted to make damned sure that everybody knew: that she is truly, madly, deeply in love with one Barack Obama.
Now, one might think that should be obvious at this point. I mean, in theory, a woman married to a man conjures the image of love, and considering that Michelle borne him two precious little girls and been married to him since 1992. Add to that all the private patience she must have shown over the course of Barack's political career, and the campaigning she's done on his behalf over the years. It hasn't always made her happy to put outside interests in front of her family's. Put on top of that the fact that she's managed to do so while building one hell of a career of her own, as a Harvard Law grad who has worked on behalf of corporate interests and (when that didn't fulfill her) the public good. Michelle Obama is undoubtedly an accomplished woman in her own right.
Yet, she devotes herself unconditionally to her husband, and their children. And instead of talking about her professional accomplishments, she talked about them.
Witness Dalia Lithwick's observation (h/t - Sullivan):
Here is a woman with a degree from Harvard Law School, who could have talked about law and policy and poverty, and yet she talked about her kids, her husband, and her family. And she didn't do that merely to show us that smart women are soft and cuddly on the inside. She did what everyone else in this campaign is terrified to do: She risked looking sappy and credulous and optimistic when almost everyone has abandoned "hope" and "change" for coughing up hairballs of outrage. Every Democrat in America seems to be of the view that optimism is so totally last February; that now's the time to hunker down and panic real hard. Good for Michelle for reminding us that to "strive for the world as it should be" is still cool, and for being so passionate about that fact that she looked to be near tears. Good for her for speaking from the heart when everyone else seems to be speaking from the root cellar.
Making Michelle's life choices in today's society are not necessarily as natural as one might believe, since women are no longer encouraged to cast homemakers as heroes. The paradox that has been established in a society dominated by men (or at least, the societal structures that men have built) is that women have to choose between career and home, while men don't face such a dilemma. But as the daughter of a homemaker herself, Michelle clearly understands how powerful it can be to have love in one's home. She seems to be a unique combination of forcefulness and warmth, a complete American woman who might close a million-dollar deal at 5:30 and close a bedtime story cover at 9. When her stories about her messy, absent-minded husband surprised some on the trail, I simply nodded my head in recognition. I was raised by a woman like this, a mother with the kindest heart whose little boy was everything, but never let him get away with anything, a career woman who got her Ph.D. a year after her only child received his bachelor's degree. I recognize women like Michelle Obama because I grew up with one right in my own home.
I see Michelle Obamas everywhere, strong Black women who love their men and their careers, finding time for both. (I recognize such a woman in my sweetheart, the doctoral candidate.) But from the sound of it, the invisibility that applies to so many people of color in this country continues to hold these Black women in its stead, keeping them from the view of (willfully?) ignorant Americans who seem unable to understand that yes, a Michelle Obama can exist. Dealing with such a revelation can be troubling, particularly when you're so used to seeing our political contests twist women like this into angry, histrionic witches while corporate heiresses like Cindy McCain are allowed to stand there, smile and wave. The masculine nature of our politics has made female candidates into harridans and political wives into archetypes, easily consumable by a lazy American public that can't be bothered, it seems, to find out who people actually are.
Cindy McCain is the Barbie doll, non-threatening in every way conceivable. But Michelle Obama is something else. Her pigeonhole can't accommodate this sister, a. And by refusing to fit into it, Michelle becomes a threat.
So that's why she didn't do what so many expected her to do - tell her story as it truly is, the career woman who puts family first. Growing up in a situation in which that was the norm for me, I can say that there is a tenderness to these women that goes under-appreciated, and her love for Barack shone out. It's in her eyes, the passion of her diction, and the smile on her face. Watch the speech again. You'll see it.
The telling moment comes when she describes Barack driving his wife and newborn daughter Malia home after her birth. I'm not a father yet, but in listening to her tear up as she recounted how Barack nervously checked on his wife and brand new joy in the backseat, driving ever so carefully home from the hospital...there was nothing more that needed to be said. That's love.
I know my lady saw the same last night as we watched Michelle at the lectern. During the speech, I looked to her beside me, listening with an intensity that I see every so often, unshakable as I selfishly tried in vain to steal a moment for our eyes to connect. All she could seem to say was, "She's so amazing. She's so amazing." I saw this woman my lady so adored and, whether she realizes it or not, is becoming herself.
Michelle Obama spoke, and I watched as her eyes glazed with the beginning of tears.
The historical import of the moment was palpable, yes. But it was the love that Michelle showed that reminded us of that which exists in so many households all over this country, love that remains unspoken as America tries to pigeonhole itself and its women. She loves her man, and that is beautiful. The number of degrees, her salary, the size of her home - none of that mattered. Michelle could reach heights her ancestors never dreamed of with her education, drive and talent, but damn it all if she couldn't have Barack by her side.
As for us men? For those, like me, who recognize Michelle Obama in our mothers, grandmothers, sisters and sweethearts, her speech served as a pleasant reminder to me how much I value the women who found time in their quest to better themselves and loved us all the while.





Comments (25)
Beautifully written. Thanks for pointing out what might seem obvious, but isn't and shouldn't be. I got the feeling from Michelle Obama that no matter what happens, this family has each other, and that's what makes them who they are, and they will be fine no matter what. We should all be so fortunate. So refreshing after the dysfunctional families that have inhabited 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue over the years.
August 26, 2008 4:44 PM | Reply | Permalink
Can I also just say that she is stunningly beautiful? Her poise, the way that she expresses herself, her gestures,...I just loved everything about her.
August 26, 2008 5:00 PM | Reply | Permalink
I second that, a beautiful woman, in all ways that can apply
August 26, 2008 5:35 PM | Reply | Permalink
Very Rec'd!
August 26, 2008 5:48 PM | Reply | Permalink
Sci, what a beautiul post. I was so proud to see Michelle Obama speak last night and have the opportunity to show what an amazing woman she is.
August 26, 2008 5:56 PM | Reply | Permalink
And hopefully, tonight, Hillary Clinton can do the same.
Good to see that avatar back. Thanks for the props.
August 26, 2008 6:11 PM | Reply | Permalink
Michelle absolutely rocked.
August 26, 2008 6:15 PM | Reply | Permalink
Sweet expression of appreciation...
August 26, 2008 6:17 PM | Reply | Permalink
There were lots of tears last night, not only during Michelle's but also during Maya Soetoro-Ng's short intervention. All this means so much at so many levels to so many people.
August 26, 2008 7:18 PM | Reply | Permalink
exactly right. some deep emotions came up for sure.
August 26, 2008 7:28 PM | Reply | Permalink
Yup.
August 26, 2008 8:19 PM | Reply | Permalink
Wow. What a beautiful tribute and sentiment to Michelle, your lady and your mother, too. She is fortunate to have someone like you and vice-versa. And you are fortunate to have a wonderful mother.
I have always admired Michelle Obama but last night made me appreciate her even more. She is an amazing beautiful woman inside and out.
I "see" Michelle and Obama walking into the WH as First Lady and President with their 2 children in January 2009.
August 26, 2008 8:33 PM | Reply | Permalink
I liked her brother's basketball analogy as well and her reference to it at the beginning of her speech.
And, yes, she rocked!
August 26, 2008 9:20 PM | Reply | Permalink
Thanks for this. I'm surrounded by women like this too, and they are an inspiration. Sounds like we have a lot in common, though I've watched my hard nosed professional, soft-hearted nurturer and doctoral candidate give birth three unbelievable times. When Michelle told the story of Barack driving home from the hospital I was a helpless weeping wreck, while she sweetly laughed her ass off at me.
August 26, 2008 10:04 PM | Reply | Permalink
Loved this, Scientific. Thanks.
August 26, 2008 11:07 PM | Reply | Permalink
Great post --- and there was another bit of love presented last night in that story: Michelle's mother's love for her husband. It struck me at the time and I find I keep remembering it at odd moments. It was clear that she (and his children, and Barack too) miss him so much.
August 27, 2008 12:25 AM | Reply | Permalink
Wonderful observations!
I teared up a bit at the end of Michelle's speech too, then almost did again as you recounted you & your lady's reaction to the same part of the speech!
This election is bringing out the sap in me & I'm embracing it instead of deriding it. There are truly some beautiful flowers under all this manure we've been submerged by ;)
August 27, 2008 3:33 AM | Reply | Permalink
Can i just say: i'm yakking here with how incredibly saccharine this post is. I'm sorry i'm soulless enough that politicians and their families don't make me tear up, but please, stop embarrassing those of us who live abroad by making all americans look like hero worshipping yokels. And for god sakes, why do we still feel the need to prove to ourselves that professional accomplished women are all adoring, self-abasing supportive wives underneath in order to respect them. gahhhhhh!
August 27, 2008 5:53 AM | Reply | Permalink
Heheh..., wicked, cynical, cheese-eating surrender monkeys...I second that. Was it just me or was it sounding like noun, verb, "working class"?
August 27, 2008 7:03 AM | Reply | Permalink
If it's so insufferable, why, exactly, are you responding?
I didn't assert anything you claim I did. Not one.
Not that Michelle Obama is some sort of hero. She may be to many, but my point was that she is breaking the mold that many women just like her find themselves in every day. And in the manner in which she conducted her speech, Michelle gave voice to those women, women like my mother. I'm sorry if that makes your life abroad tougher because of all the embarrassment it causes you, but I'm dealing with the reality I know here in America.
Not that all accomplished professional women need to be proven as adoring, self-abasing supportive wives, either. I was talking about one wife - Michelle Obama. And she didn't need to do anything. I was remarking that by employing the approach that she had, she did reveal that there's more to this particular accomplished professional woman than the steely, angry stereotype that Republicans would love to cast her as.
Look, all writing is not for all people. I'm not asking you to agree with me, or even like my post. But I do ask that you not mischaracterize it so recklessly, for whatever reasons you have.
August 27, 2008 9:33 AM | Reply | Permalink
I admire Michelle. I admire you for pointing out some of the feelings I had watching the speech Scientific.
August 27, 2008 10:40 AM | Reply | Permalink
Oh come on, she's surely capable of a Gettysburg Address/"I Have A Dream" stirring speech for our age as we try to shed the Bush carnage - it is obvious she's dumbing it down to "connect" with TV Nation, "heartstrings orchestra" "working class Huxtables" " a thousand points of light" stuff, mindful of the repurcussions of the Tammy Wynnette-"stay home baking cookies" moments that haunt Hillary to this day.
What is sad is that our Harvard educated prospective First Lady needs to resort to this type of kabuki to please the masses, god knows what slivers of visible intelligence might do to her husband's career.
August 27, 2008 1:26 PM | Reply | Permalink
Wow, that wasn't pompous at all.
First, none of the things you have in quotes were in my post, so I have no idea where you're headed with that.
Secondly, I merely made the point that she revealed that side of herself to America, and that it and her professional career woman side were not mutually exclusive. And I sure as hell don't think she did it to "please the masses". She loves her husband, her family and she doesn't care if there's people like you who seem preternaturally disposed to value one side over the other. That was made plain. Only you seem to assume that being a homemaker, baking cookies, etc. is a sign that a woman hasn't any "visible intelligence". If you didn't see intelligence in that speech because she didn't talk about her career at length, then I don't know what you think this is. This is the convention. Like it or not, she had to talk to us about her husband, the dude running for President.
It's funny you mention the Huxtables. There was a depiction of Black family life that included both career and family, and the parents seemed to balance both very well. I really fail to understand, sarcastic or not, how a comparison between the Obamas and the Huxtables could be an insult.
August 27, 2008 1:36 PM | Reply | Permalink
Um,...I hope you do see the irony in the fact that "the Huxtables" is complete fiction? TV Entertainment?
Oh nevermind, you won't get the sarcasm about the "cookies" either.
I'm happy for you though that you're obviously a well-fed, well-loved and pampered boy by your mom and sisters.
This part is sincere, don't read any more to it.
August 27, 2008 1:56 PM | Reply | Permalink
Well-loved, yes, but wrong on the other counts. Pampered? Where on earth did it say that in my post? We grew up poor while my mother struggled to put herself through school as I went to high school. I busted my ass working so that I could afford college when she got a scholarship to get her doctorate at the same time I was in undergrad.
You don't know the first thing about me, guy. You don't want me to read into your comments? Then don't make assumptions about me.
Oh, I got the "cookies" reference. And where you see irony in the Huxtables thing, I merely see a reference to what you brought up! Dude, what about me saying that they were a "depiction" of Black family life did you not understand? Maybe you missed that, being in such a hurry to be a smartass.
August 27, 2008 3:38 PM | Reply | Permalink
Post a Comment