« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »
Yahoo Headlines
Right now, the second and third "top headlines" on the Yahoo homepage read as follows:
-Obama: Patriotism means 'faith in one another as Americans'
-McCain: Patriotism is 'putting the country first' before all else
I did not read the articles. I refuse.
But I submit this as further evidence that we are all, in fact, in third grade. The teacher has just handed out the construction paper and asked the students to tell us all "what patriotism means to me."
You have ten minutes and if you finish early, please sit quietly at your desks and wait until the others are done. Then we'll have a snack and play some kickball.
There is so much evidence of this that I don't know where to start. Not just the inane flag lapel pin questions, or, for that matter, the entire ABC debate (the final one) between Obama and Clinton, but in all forms of national "journalism."
Anyone see the recent network interview with the Iranian official? (I believe it was the Foreign Minister, but I only caught a snippet.)
I sat aghast as the interviewer basically said "There's rumors Israel is considering an attack on your country. What will you do if they attack?"
What?!! This is journalism? Diplomacy? Now I didn't catch the whole thing and there might have been a more substantive discussion somewhere, but this was the "money question."
"Psst, that guy over there said he can kick your ass. What you gonna do about it?"
I'm not so sure this is an insult to Americans' intelligence. I'm starting to thing this kind of crap really resonates with the majority of people. Are they just giving the people what they want? I'm thinking they're TELLING the people what they want and THEN serving it up to them, all the while reassuring them that they are, in fact, "thinking for themselves."
So tell me, class, what does patriotism mean to you?
I'll start: Not answering fatuous, inane leading questions.








Comments (3)
"No matter that patriotism is too often the refuge of scoundrels. Dissent, rebellion, and all-around hell-raising remain the true duty of patriots."
BARBARA EHRENREICH
July 3, 2008 4:37 PM | Reply | Permalink
Patriotism begins to be defined by recognizing what it is not:
1) It is not flag waving, breast beating mob chants of “We’re #1”;
2) It is not wearing a flag lapel pin while rationalizing:
a) subverting the constitution;
b) invading and occupying another sovereign nation;
c) subjecting any human being to torture;
e) shutting down immigration;
f) ?
Patriotism, in the positive sense, is:
1) realizing, every day, that you won the birthright lottery;
2) reminding yourself, frequently, what equality means and then living it;
3) stepping up and speaking out on issues that can enhance or erode your country's future;
3)exercising your right to vote, in national and local elections, and feeling proud to be part of your country’s process;
4) respecting the sovereignty and the patriotism of other people in other countries;
5) traveling or living in another country and loving its people, admiring the things that country does well -- sometimes better than we do – and, yet, yearning to be “home” again, anyway;
6) recognizing that the future well-being of your country is the one thing – other than the well-being of those you love -- that you would, in fact, give your life for;
7) ?
July 3, 2008 5:09 PM | Reply | Permalink
This is perhaps veering off course but may be the in the underpinnings of patriotism: Where does sovereignty reside? Does it reside in solely with the federal government, the people or the several state governments? Does it reside in the federal government and the people, the federal government and state governments or state governments and the people?
July 3, 2008 5:46 PM | Reply | Permalink
Post a Comment