« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »
Swiftboating McCain
the standard interpretation of this affair seems to be that the McCain camp has seized on Gen. Clark's comment because they see political advantage in insinuating via allegorical leaps that Obama is somehow contemptuous of McCain's war record--painting Obama as one of the 1960s hippie/yippie troop-hating radicals who have been foils for every Republican campaign since Nixon '68 even as they gradually turned to straw.
which makes sense, but I think there is something else going on here. the McCain camp was initially described as "furious" at the remark, and I am sure that McCain was as well. if you assume that Clark was implying the positive by stating the negative (which I do not, by the way), "McCain's war record does not make him qualified to be President" becomes "McCain's war record makes him unfit to be President." that isn't much of a misreading. I suspect that the McCain camp really did think that Clark was obliquely "swiftboating" McCain by linking his war record to his qualifications to be President.
Why misread what Clark actually said and then fly into a rage? Because McCain has been swiftboated before: by Karl Rove's people (probably) in the 2000 primary race and by fringe operators in the 2008 primary race. There is a great deal of material on the web stating that McCain broke under torture, that he attempted suicide, that he has Post-Traumatic Stress Syndrome, that he received preferential treatment when he was a POW, that he exaggerated his war record, that he reduced a POW/MIA widow to tears during a Congressional hearing, etc. etc. (see links below). All to imply that he is not a hero at all, that he's mentally unstable, that he's anti-vet and that he may be some sort of Manchurian Candidate foisted on us by the Commies.
Note again that I am not suggesting Gen. Clark -was- swiftboating McCain, but rather that McCain and his camp are highly sensitive to any -critical- use of his war record in political discourse. Such criticism is currently at the far fringes of such discourse; McCain as super-patriot hero military man is an unquestioned narrative and at the center of his campaign. Is there substantive reason to doubt this narrative? The McCain camp would -hate- it if the media started to investigate that question.
The McCain camp may be pushing back so hard on this not because it sees opportunity, but because it is afraid of someone exploiting a real political vulnerability.
http://tpmmuckraker.talkingpointsmemo.com/archives/005084.php
http://www.commongroundcommonsense.org/forums/lofiversion/index.php/t89373.html








Comments (2)
My husband said the same thing...McCain is actually scared shitless!
July 2, 2008 12:30 AM | Reply | Permalink
Obama defended Clark against the "Swiftboating" tag. It's complete B.S. that the Republicans (Fox News included) hope will somehow stick. It won't. McCain knows that this isn't on the level of Swiftboating of John Kerry or nowhere close to the disrespectful, below-the-belt treatment that Karl Rove and Bush gave him in 2000.
The key is to get hot head McCain publicly pissed off again like he did during the primary against a NYT reporter on his (Cindy's) campaign plane when she asked him about his flirting with being on the Kerry ticket as VP in 2004. The truth gets him furious when he has no answer for it and it goes against the mythological narrative he's trying to create.
He has a lot in common with Bush in his miliary service. He was cocky and had a sense of entitlement because of who his father was. He was wreckless (literally) bringing down millions of dollars in crashed jets that he could not handle.
I don't think he's scared sh*tless. I think he's a cocky "little jerk" who has bought into his own myth and is angry that someone would call him out on it. His wreckless side is showing and he was stupid enough to jump right into the fray and even dumber for calling out Jim Webb into the fight. Clark and Webb have more military brains that McCain and will show it.
There are bound to be more examinations now on the reality of McCain's military service-beyond his authentic heroism in the Hanoi Hilton.
(See this NYT article: http://www.nytimes.com/2008/05/29/us/politics/29mccain.html?pagewanted=1&_r=1&partner=rssnyt)
July 2, 2008 4:45 AM | Reply | Permalink
Post a Comment