Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

Obama's Enthusiasm Gap

Barack Obama has a growing enthusiasm gap.  Not with John McCain mind you; his support would have to completely flat-line before it would sink below the enthusiasm of McCain's supporters who have the collective enthusiasm of a group going for a root-canal.  

No, the enthusiasm gap is with his own supporters [myself included]; and their view towards Sen. Obama during the primary campaign compared to their view of him at the moment.

Sure, I don't think anyone has abandoned Sen. Obama.  I still write the occasional blog in support of Barack and will certainly cast my vote for him in the fall.  However, the frequency with which I'm donating to his campaign and expending energy on his behalf has markedly decreased.

I've been disappointed with Sen. Obama's rightward tack since clinching the nomination.  I understand why he's doing what he's doing [although I disagree with the political effectiveness of the strategy and strongly believe he is doing incredible damage to his political brand].  It seems to me that the Obama campaign, which to now has been quite forward thinking, has allowed itself to be drawn to the "center" based on what constituted the "center" in previous elections.  Unfortunately, the "center" in American politics has drifted increasingly rightward over the past thirty years; it's somewhat of a false floor.  And the only way to have the debate on Democratic Party turf is to strongly advocate progressive positions and pull the "center" back to a more traditionally center place.

Prior to this year's campaign I was a fairly apathetic [at least politically] registered independent  that leaned towards the Democratic Party, although I did not always cast my votes for a Democrat.  I gave money [for the first time] to the DCCC in 2006; a whopping sum of $50.

This year I have given the maximum $2300 during the primary campaign, blogged, did volunteer work and raised an additional $1500 through my Obama Fundraising Page.  In short, I have expended a considerable amount of time and energy; time and energy that could easily be allocated to any number of other endeavors in my life.

I did this [such as making some contributions on my credit card--I know, I'm not a smart man, but that's for another diary] because Barack was able to tap into the general dissatisfaction with the political process that many people genuinely held.  I think there are millions of others out there that were there for the political taking, but just didn't see anything worth getting excited about.  Barack expertly tapped into that dissatisfaction with Washington in general, and, politics specifically.

I started my Obama page in January.  This is what I wrote then:

Barack Obama and I are committed to changing the political process
with a campaign built on a broad base of support from ordinary
Americans.  We believe the only way to bring about lasting and needed
change in our government is by rejecting the typical Washington-style
slash and burn politics; by seeking to inspire voters by highlighting
our possibilities rather than preying on our fears; and, by tapping
into the hard work and ingenuity that has served us so well.

But
this can only happen with your help.  Today, I ask you to stand with me
and believe that government can be more than driving up your opponent's
negatives; that government can be more than lowest common denominator
partisanship.  Our government is a direct reflection of who we are. 
Our elected leaders represent us.  It is not enough to merely replace a
president with an "R" next to their name with someone with a "D" next
to their name.

Those words seem kind of overly simplistic and, frankly, silly now.  Maybe that's for the best.  Maybe the old adage that 'Democrats fall in love & Republicans fall in line' is correct.  I certainly wouldn't take any pride in some dreamy, wide-eyed idealistic losing campaign.  The most important thing is to win.

However, I have quite a bit to do during my day.  Like most people, I'm quite busy.  I also have about $100K in law school loans and can't really afford to give any more money away.  So, it's not too difficult to find an excuse not to donate to Sen. Obama's campaign.  And not that I'm a harbinger by any stretch, but I think there are a lot of people out there like me.  Sen. Obama isn't going to lose our vote.  But he can lose our enthusiasm.  In the end, that might be just as bad because it was the enthusiasm that allowed Barack to prevail over Sen. Clinton in the primary.

Maybe I'm wrong, but if I were with the Obama campaign, I'd be concerned.





Comments (32)

Speaking for myself, my enthusiasm has not waned.

Perhaps it was inevitable. It was a long, hard-fought primary.

It's possible that I simply need to re-energize.

Happy 4th of July everyone.

Keep traversing the road to a more perfect union.

Amongst many others, one thing I've always loved about this country is the constant striving to bring the often glorious, but sometimes stark reality of the Constitution in line with the idealistic universality of the Declaration.

God bless!

Perhaps, you're probably not appropriately motivated since the anticlimactic finish of the HRC Battle-Royale. Just wait till McCain gets on his chariot, er horse and buggy, to declare war on the American future later this summer.

However, the frequency with which I'm donating to his campaign and expending energy on his behalf has markedly decreased.

yep. I agree.

can you explain this "rightward tack" that you've been witnessing, because i haven't seen it at all.

sounds like you're just buying into the corporate media's convential wisdom.

and if the corporate media says it, it must be true.

I second that - I think the rightward tack perception is unfounded and designed to create a horse race.

Primaries always appeal to the edges, GEs go toward the middle. That's just how it works. Let's just get the guy into office, something us perfectionist Dems can't seem to accomplish anymore.

The perfect is the enemy of the good. Voltaire

Trite, but true.

When in doubt, think George W. Bush, Dickhead Cheney, Donald Rumsfeld, Anthony Scalia, John Roberts, Alberto Gonzalez, John Ashcroft, John McCain......

Then think Barack Obama.

Absolutely.

Understand, that I am referring to DEGREES of enthusiasm and support. I will still do more than I ever have in a PREVIOUS ELECTION CYCLE. I'm just not entirely sure that it will be AS MUCH as I did IN THE PRIMARY.

You have to be supremely motivated to do that much. It was that type of motivation that allowed Sen. Obama to raise more than $50 million in February. The support is still there. Right now, the intensity of the support is not.

Doesn't mean that the motivation won't come back; just that it's not there RIGHT NOW.

Gotcha. I think we are all fatigued. And perhaps being lulled into inaction a bit by the assumption that McCain can't possibly win. We need only remember 2000. Summer doldrums are here. The convention will fire you back up. If it doesn't, watch the Republican convention and that will be sure to do it.

Very, very true.

Dear jthomascronin;
Read this and it will cheer you up a little. Our stories are similar-I am also a recent law school grad with a 6 figure debt and I have been wildly enthusiastic about Obama. His reasoned re4sponse to this FISA issue made me feel a little better. I think many of us are concerned that he does not start triangulating his positions. I am still very hopeful that the man so many of us became enamored with is the real Barack.
Anyhow-have a look at this:
http://my.barackobama.com/page/community/post/rospars/gGxsZF
Take Care and Take Heart-imagine what kind of Supreme Court we could end up with if Obama has 8 successful years! Oh to have another Brandeis or Brennen leading a "liberal" Court!

avatar

Dear jthomas,
You have been fighting the good fight and we are very, very proud of you!!! As you say, you've donated the max for the primary and you can't give another dime if you wanted to until after the convention. So give your mind a rest and let somebody else carry the load for the next month or so. Maybe we all tend to project onto our heros. And at some point it is inevitable that they'll revert to being real people who aren't our exact clones and we'll feel let down. It hits us in the gut when it happens, but usually with a little time we begin to shift back to the core issues of what we're looking for in someone. If he ends up giving his acceptance speech at the stadium, maybe you could go. There will be a lot of positive energy going on and it might recharge you. In the meantime, give yourself a break. We love and appreciate you for all you've done. Blessings.

Is anyone else tired of seeing the Bush-McCain man hug photp right next to the comment box? It makes me feel creepy every time I see it. McCain looks so little, like he shrank, and maybe like he's wearing a Yarmulke or a Speedo swim cap.

I'm still impressed with the comb-over, though. I mean, you can't get much more old school than that.

All he needs is the too-young wife [wait, he DOES have that] & a plaid sport-coat [probably still has one in the closet]. In an age where the comb-over is beyond a joke [heck, even Rudy got rid of his], McCain stubbornly clings to the big sweep.

In fact, he has the full 'pulling it over from the top of his ear', Benny Hinn comb-over. Gotta' love that.

But, I'm with you on the pick--it's actually quite creepy.

I had a psychology professor in college with the greatest comb-over of all time--we called him Dr. Denial (not to his face).

I'm still waiting for the video of the comb-over flapping up and over in the wind, back to it's natural location. It would be especially nice if it happened in the gust of a military helicopter's propeller as he was departing the craft.

avatar

Nope, I'm not tired of that picture at all. I bought "The Real McCain" book that has that photo on the cover. If I'm talking with a friend and they aren't sure what they think, I just hand them the book and let them stare at the picture. You don't have to say a word. After about 90 seconds they just look at you and say, "That says it all doesn't it?" In this case, a picture is worth many thousands of words. That book is no smear job,(which I wondered about when I bought it), it's a highly researched, documented and foot noted study of things McCain and his cohorts have said and done. But it's worth buying just for the picture. If I lose my focus, I just look at that picture and I'm Fired Up and Ready to Go Again!!!

avatar

i share the concern about enthusiasm--mine has dropped, in part, due to the end of the primary and also, I don't think McCain is much of a contender. (I think it's ridiculous that anyone thinks McCain has a snowball's chance.)

My enthusiasm for and donations to Obama have fallen because the Democratic party is so consistently spineless that I have once again become too cynical to participate productively.

The MSM covers nothing more than political gossip.

Also, I know this is tough, I really do, but Obama has to start looking like he's having a little fun. Maybe TPM can stop posting the angry looking Obama pictures.

avatar

The trouble is that Obama was always an blank slate where everyone just wrote their own agenda and then believed that he was reflecting them back.

I never bought it. I always asked please show me what he has done to merit your enthusiasm? Please show me where his rhetoric has made a difference? He has been a state senator for 8 years. How did he empower his constituents and make his district into a showcase for change? I didn't expect much just a little thing. There was nothing, nada, zilch. And the more you tried to find anything you noticed how everything he did was aimed at just one thing -running for office. Not actually accomplishing anything just running.

Obama will lose in November because 1) he barely won his base (and some would argue that if you count actual votes he did not even do that) and too many will jump ship or not vote 2) he will mobilize the repug base even if they don't particularly care for McCain if not because he is black then because he is too liberal 3) real independents cannot stomach his lack of actual accomplishments when compared to someone like McCain who has a reputation for being a maverick and 4) the Kool-aid drinkers (at least some of them ) are waking up and like someone said during the primary wow that was a great speech but now that its over I can't actually remember anything he said.

You are absolutely correct it was that huge enthusiasm that got him the nomination because some states have caucuses and that works there. I said it once before, in terms of attracting new waves of supporters Obama peaked back in Feb/Mar. Democrats will be analyzing this election for years to come and I look forward to all the pundits on election asking can the democrats ever win the presidency again.


I would urge you to read his books, listen to his speeches, and pay closer attention. He is anything but a blank slate, in fact, the opposite. He is not playing the traditional political game. If you're paying attention, you will get it. He is relying on the intelligence of the American people, so don't play possum.

You sound bright but I apparently you are not intellectually curious. Compare Obama's legislative resume with Hillary's or any other Senator with combined state and federal legislative experience and it stands up pretty damn well.

Additionally-his life path exhibits true concern for social justice. After Harvard he could have named his price and by now he would be a multi-multi millionaire partner in any law frim in the world, but he chose public service instead.

And anyone who actually listens to him talking-although they may well disagree with his viewpoint if they are a conservative, cannot help but see that he is turned on, and that cannot be faked.

Is he perfect? No. But a neutral and careful analysis of his organizational skill reveals a brilliant man.

You are right about one thing-they will write volumes for decades about President Obama's revolutionary campaign!

avatar

You really owe it to yourself to get to know the Democratic candidate a little better. As one who assumed I'd be voting for Hillary in the primary, I must say that I'm glad I took the time to read Obama's books first. Then I googled and read as many articles written about him as I could find -- especially the ones written prior to 2007 (a good one can be found in the Chicago Reader, which was written at the beginning of his first campaign for State Senate). I paid close attention to the kinds of things people said about him -- colleagues, associates, former opponents and former students -- and I've been deeply impressed with the esteem and high regard he is almost universally held by so many different kinds of people. Most importantly, I believe that given his contemplative and insightful nature, he is not likely to ever forget who he is and where he came from. As a former community organizer/activist, that remains one of the most compelling reasons to believe in him. By the way, I'd recommend reading his speeches before watching them. I loved the commencement speech he gave at Knox College in 2005. I'd recommend William Finnegan's New Yorker article, too (May 2004). And Michael Lerner's article in Tikkun.

avatar

I don't think there is an enthusiasm gap.

Many of his biggest critics now were not in fact supporters. They wanted Edwards but settled for O when it was him or HRC.

Perosnally, I am taking a bit of a break. It was a long primary, so I need a break. I've been deliberately avoiding the MSM because of its aggravating nature. I plan to get revved up late Summer for the general.

avatar

Let's hope his enthusiasm for us hasn't diminished.

It's up to his supporters to keep him energized and to motivate each other and his campaign.

Just think how tired and dispirited he must get - day in and day out with all the media crap and naysayers in his face 24/7. And all the armchair critics who know oh, so much better than him and never hesitate to shout it out and him down!

If we want him to keep goin' strong - best take a shot of Vitamin 'B' - because the truth is, it's just as much up to us as it his up to Obama.

Too many are micro-managing their own 'campaign' for him - losing sight of the ever so critical goal.

If we want him to be and do better, then shouldn't we apply it to ourselves too?

Too many are bitchin' about problems and seldom, if ever, putting forth solutions. Stop it. If you don't, our country will be the biggest loser.

And a sincere Happy Fourth of July! Have some iced tea and chill!

avatar

"Just think how tired and dispirited he must get - day in and day out with all the media crap and naysayers in his face 24/7. And all the armchair critics who know oh, so much better than him and never hesitate to shout it out and him down!"

You said it.

He's "not black enough" and then later "too black".

The netroots claims he's "not really a liberal" at the same time the GOP is calling him the "most liberal senator in 2007"

I admire his perseverence and calm in the face of all the naysayers and cynics.

But have no worries -- how sweet it will be on January 20, 2009 when Barack Obama is sworn in.

I'm still as enthused as ever. Obama has disappointed me, sure. But... For every "disappointment," something comes along that makes me remember why I supported him in the first place, and those disappointments wash away. That's the thing. Some people dismiss that as failed logic, or call me an "Obamabot," tell me to "drink my kool-aid," or try to invalidate my continuing, and strong support, as cult-like. But the thing is, as much as Obama has done things to surprise me in a negative way, he has done so much more to surprise me in a positive one. If you truly have doubts, then take it upon yourself to read this article: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/bob-cesca/senator-obama-in-the-summ_b_110545.html

It energized me. Maybe it can re-energize you. Best of luck.

avatar

My enthusiasm hasn't waned but I read his books and was also pretty clear-eyed about his positions, his judgment and the quality of his mind. When I read his speeches or listen to him, I hear a man of reason, a man who thinks through the issues. I might disagree with his conclusions or wish his positions mirrored my own but on the most important issues (#1 being getting these Republican assholes out of power) for me he's right on target.

I've also worked on enough hard Democratic campaigns in Red States to know that getting Democrats elected ain't always pretty and your conscience ain't always singing a sweet song. I've worked for candidates who had some individual positions that made me want to puke. But they had positions on healthcare and the economy and a host of other issues that were far better than the Republicans running against them. And I knew that in that state that would make a real difference to the people who lived there.

So just think of all the people who will be affected by this election. The people who need healthcare, the people who can't find a job, the
soldiers who will die . My own concerns with Obama look small compared to the consequences of not doing everything I can to help him be elected. I just think of all the destruction that happened in the last 8 years because some fools in the year 2000 couldn't see a difference between Bush and Gore and didn't see the coming disaster that was right before their eyes.

Gore wasn't pure enough, he was too centrist, he was a liar, wasn't a true progressive- all the same shit I've been hearing people who should know better say about Barack Obama in the last two weeks.

And before people start on this slippery slope of Naderite thinking again just remember every awful thing that the Bush administration has done in the last 8 years and remember that there was a point where reasonable people could have stopped it but they wouldn't because they thought their candidate, who we have all now seen is the most decent of men, needed to be taught a lesson about progressive ideals. And what a lesson it has been.

I've relaxed because the primary was close, but McCain doesn't have a chance. Maybe I'll send more money later, but Barack is moving to the center which is more effective than the netroots donations that brought him this far. That gets him a thousand votes for every one that switches to Nader. Barack's one smart cookie. We'll all be fine. My mom says his spots are on everywhere on Fla TV. Drives her nuts.

"Barack's one smart cookie"
um..he is one huge slime
"We'll all be fine"
Says you.
Trashing the 4th is cool.
"We'll all be fine"

I have abandoned him. He is a sellout. He lies about pacs. He purposely confuses the FISA issue by claiming the stupid worthless criminality portion means something. He marginalizes followers of the constitution like we were wrestling alligators for god. He throws decent people under the bus for "the greater good." Would anyone like to have a discussion of his "Chicago style" use of pacs? He is more dangerous to Americans than McCain.

I guess I'm part of the radical left or some troll. Either way, no more bake sales for this asshole.

Post a Comment

Inside Cafe



Cafe Features


August 18-22

Book Cover

September 1-4

Book Cover

September 8-12

Book Cover

September 15-20

Book Cover

October 6-12

Book Cover





Book Club Archive



Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Al Shaw



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address