Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

Obama or McCain: Who's the Better CEO? And Why?

Wesley Clark's inept challenge of John McCain's "executive" capabilities by minimizing--some might even say, trivializing--the candidate's military career have cost Clark any chance he had the the O-VP.

But through a fortuitous bit of timing, it may have opened up a space for Team Obama to raise some serious questions regarding McCain's ability to manage a large organization.

The complete top-down reorganization of the McCain campaign is a real issue.

Neither Obama nor McCain have any real "executive" leadership experience. That's a concrete fact that one cannot get around.

Their first tests of running a complex organization has come in the campaign itself, namely, running their own campaign organizations.

How have they done? (Should this be rhetorical question, as the answer is so obvious?)

The most expert and objective critique of O's performance would come from two people who share the same last name and were his adversaries just a short month ago: Hillary and Bill.  Barack ran a tight ship and kept its command structure intact during the primary season, and continues to do so today.

McCain?  He was forced during the primary season to do a draconian overhaul in his campaign management as his ship was sinking. Now, early in the general election phase, his ship has again begun to take on water. And again, commanding officers are replaced, strategic management structure is fundamentally revised, "outside" help is brought aboard.

If there's going to be a debate about who is the better executive, who is more adept at putting together and leading a winning team, the campaign thus-far has put Obama far in the lead on this issue.

Now, O's PR group has to find a way to exploit this, without a word about the Navy; in other words, it should not be done with blunt instruments like Wes Clark...but it should be done.

MyBlog: http://ProteanPerspectives.blogspot.com


Comments (4)

avatar

Excellent. And oh, so 'on the mark'.

Happy Fourth!

AS,

Thanks. And Happy 4th to you too.

Fred

PS-How you like my new avatar?

avatar

"Neither Obama nor McCain have any real "executive" leadership experience. That's a concrete fact that one cannot get around."

The following things exist in some people, whether they have a little experience or a lot:

Quick grasp of concepts and details large and small
Good listening focus; articulate speaking ability
Delegating talent
Hiring judgment
Ability to prioritize and efficiently direct activities
Natural leadership ability

Anyone who has spent time with Obama will tell you he has those characteristics. That's a concrete fact that one cannot get around.

WR,


Nice list, but it doesn't refute my paragraph in any way, assuming that was your intent.

FB

Post a Comment

Inside Cafe

Recommended Reader Posts



Cafe Features


September 15-20

Book Cover

September 22-27

Book Cover

September 29-October 3

Book Cover

October 6-10

Book Cover

October 13-17

Book Cover

October 20-24

Book Cover

December 1-5

Book Cover





Book Club Archive



Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Claire Wilcox



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address