Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

McCain Ups the Ante

Two month ago, John McCain challenged Barack Obama to visit Iraq, expecting him to decline, but Obama called the bluff. He saw McCain's Iraq and raised him Afghanistan, Israel, and three European nations. Never one to fold easily, McCain raised Obama right back. Fresh from his own mission-critical visits to Columbia and Mexico, McCain suggested that Obama to visit "some of the other countries of the Americas for the first time." Obama has not yet responded to this latest challenge, but pundits suggest that in light of his inexperience in intrahemispheric relations, he has no choice but to tour Central and South America, Canada, Greenland, and the Galapagos. Fortunately for Obama, he recently vacationed in the Virgin Islands, so he can cross one remote island chain off the list.

Democratic strategists have expressed concern that McCain will next challenge Obama to visit Africa, Australia, and Antarctica, which could keep Obama off the campaign trail until November. But there are new hints from insiders at the McCain campaign that they have prepared an even more formidable stratagem. Hank Moody, one of McCain's top national security advisers, recently implied that unlike McCain, Obama has little aviation experience. According to Moody, "If you were riding in a plane that was being shot at by terrorists, I think that most Americans would prefer to have an experienced Navy pilot like John McCain in the cockpit. I mean, Obama might sound nice over the intercom when he tells you to relax and enjoy your flight, but that's not the priority when terrorists are shooting missiles at you."

Taken on its own, such a comment might be interpreted as typical political posturing, but a second comment by McCain's chief torture adviser, Fred Krueger, hints at a broader strategy. Discussing the possible closure of Guantanamo Bay, Krueger suggested that Obama lacks torture experience: "John McCain was tortured for five years by the Vietnamese. Barack Obama, maybe he's seen torture in the movies--there were some pretty gnarly scenes in Saw 2--but he doesn't have personal experience with it. I don't think Americans trust someone with zero experience to set torture policy."

Political analysts have suggested that these statements may be part of a choreographed strategy to prepare the stage for McCain to argue that Obama should be shot down over Vietnam and tortured for five years. Such a challenge would certainly offer risks for McCain. If Obama were to meet the challenge, McCain would lose one of his primary political advantages, as he would then be unable to differentiate himself based on his experience as a war hero. Moreover, if Obama were shot down over Vietnam, he would gain the credibility to openly question whether having one's plane shot down is a qualification for serving as President. On the other hand, the risk to Obama in accepting the challenge is substantial. Even under ideal conditions, being shot down is dangerous and can result in injury or death, which might impede Obama's political career. Second, there is no guarantee that Obama would be able to resist the torture. Were he to become brainwashed and leak military secrets to the Vietnamese, he would be unable to obtain the military clearance necessary to be Commander in Chief. Finally, even if it were to help him win the election, five years of torture would interfere with his ability to run the country. While technology improvements have made working remotely more feasible than ever before, there is no substitute for face-to-face meetings in the Oval Office and photo ops on the White House lawn.

Obama may yet have a face-saving way out. Though they once relished shooting American planes and torturing the pilots, the Vietnamese have reformed many of their old policies, and they may decline the opportunity to torture as prominent an American as Barack Obama. Nonetheless, the Vietnamese government remains unpredictable, and Obama might not know whether he would be shot down until he entered Vietnamese air space. Furthermore, if he were to fail to be shot down by the Vietnamese, McCain may challenge him to be shot down in a more welcoming environment where resident authorities are enthusiastic about shooting planes and torturing people, such as western Pakistan, rebel-held Columbia, and Washington D.C.

That said, Obama's nimble campaign has managed to outmaneuver McCain in the past, and they may yet have a plan to neutralize the threat of such a challenge. They may, for example, go on the offensive and challenge McCain to grow up in Indonesia and become the first black president of the Harvard Law Review. Either way, pundits are advising American voters to buckle their seatbelts, as the election campaign promises to be a bumpy ride.


Comments (32)

McCain should also challenge Obama on the care for the mentally ill...

... until Obama is provenly nutz beyond belief, he does not have the experience McCain has in this important public policy area.

I think that most Americans would prefer to have an experienced Navy pilot like John McCain in the cockpit.

Are we talking about the same John McCain that crashed three planes? Are we talking about the same John McCain who is computer illiterate? Hence wouldn't know what he was looking at in a cockpit with glass panels as opposed to steam gauges.

Hell lock the door keep him out it going to crash either way ;)

You're onto something here. Obama should challenge McCain to google "Anbar Awakening" and find "Czechoslovakia" on Wikipedia, then post a comment on TPMEC that "replies" to someone without accidentally falling to the bottom of the thread.

With that, I think the race would be pretty much wrapped up.

avatar

Hank: "Daddy's trying out a new look."
Becca: "Are you mentally insane?"
Hank: "Yes, and I'm extremely high-functioning."

- Hank Moody, Californication

1. Obama should challenge McCain to change his middle name to Hussein.

2. And his first name to, say, Adolphus.

I think being named Adolphus Hussein McCain - just til November - would enable Johnny to feel Obama's pain.

McCain to Obama: If you're so popular why don't you prove it by not campaigning at all? You should still win easily. Unless, that is, you're scared and feel like you have to campaign to even have a chance.

Even under ideal conditions, being shot down is dangerous and can result in injury or death, which might impede Obama's political career.

I don't know—if he were to rise from the dead three days later (well, Sunday is only two days after Friday, but I'm not that much of a literalist, as some people know) that might help his polling amongst the evangelical crowd.

Maybe he should stay down for four days. That'd pretty much clinch it I think.

Since we're being irreverent, I loved Jon Stewart's reporting yesterday that Obama had toured Bethlehem "to revisit the manger he was born in."
One of your best posts, Genghis.
Unfortunately, you've given the McCain campaign some ideas I'm sure they will put into practice. They have so few left.

avatar

For a little historical reference-

Missouri U.S. Senate election 2000:
Mel Carnahan-D (as in deceased): 1,191,42 (51%)

John Ashcroft-R (I'm not dead yet): 1,142,552 (49%)

avatar

LOL! Priceless! Great post.

Would not Senator Obama in fact be the better pilot, since it is a matter of historical fact that the Vietnamese have as yet been unable to shoot him down?

Excellent satire, Genghis.

I've noticed that, along with some of these wild statements coming from McCain surrogates, there's one thing that McCain has settled upon - a message of deep maturity from a man of experience: "He's wrong!" It is universal. Applies to everything Obama does, and parses well in a headline. Brilliant strategy.

Prime snark. Thank you Genghis.

avatar

OBAMA WANTS TO LOSE THE WAR IN IRAQ
I'm puzzled that Obama didn't mention this issue in Berlin. It's so central to his Mid East policy. Although he hasn't elaborated the method to this his madness, we can imagine what he has in mind.

He wants to lose the election, in the hope that, at some point during the next eight years of neo-con greed and destructiveness, the country will revolt and resurrect Zapada(sp?) who will put Billy Glad, Desidero, and a few other like minded folks in his cabinet. Then, a conflagration to end all holocausts will decimate the earth so that Hillary, the only survivor, can begin rewinding her biological clock and initiate the world's second immaculate conception. Perhaps then, Obama reasons, the world will finally become a harmonious, Left Wing entity.

Sorry, I'm not buckling my seatbelts. I want to see the tomato soup and I like to live dangerously.

I think we should make them spit watermelon seeds. Who ever spits it the furtherest, wins the keys to the kingdom. After the keys are handed to whoever wins, then that person has to give a kneecracking speech. Otherwise, back to the spitting seeds.

McCain will challenge Obama to go to Mars:

http://blog.washingtonpost.com/the-trail/2008/06/05/mccain_wants_a_man_on_mars.html

Hey, when is that series of town hall debates supposed to start?

avatar

Senator Obama does not have any Time Travel experience and therefore can not be trusted to pilot The Way Back Machine, should the need arise to start The Surge at a much earlier date, again.

McCain has been there, and done that.

avatar

McCain next challenge to Obama:

The Green Screen Challenge

McCain already did his version a month ago. How about Barack go up in front of a smattering of apparently drunk people, to grimace and awkwardly smile in front of a big bright green screen. Colbert can then animate their backgrounds.


McCain's mom is 97. God only knows how old his ante is.

Oooh, well done.

Intrahemispheric. Yes, I remember seeing them open for Menswear in '95.


Hera has challenged Obama to fetch the girlde of the Amazonian warrior-queen Hippolyta. This might involve four solid quarters of one on one basketball.

For chrissake, lbp, come back to the cafe already. It's barely worth reading without you.

PS Was your comment a reference to Dowd's column? If not, I'm afraid that she's a couple weeks ahead of you.

[Attention shoppers: You may now begin Maureen Dowd slamfest. The Billy Glad slamfest is in the other room.]

Thanks Genghis- I have almost returned. Let this be a lesson to all of you: if comedy is tragedy plus 15 years, then near-death-experience is Maureen Dowd minus 1 month.

Nicely done, Ghenghis.

Personally, I have always wanted to see the President selected through a process guaranteed to produce the best possible outcome: a reality show. The candidates would be tested in new and unpredictable ways, subject to the scrutiny of a panel of experts, and exposed as never before. The networks would benefit from stratospheric ratings - far higher than the stodgy and uninformative debates - and it would guarantee a record turnout.

I've always wanted to pitch a related concept: "Who wants to be a Third World Dictator?"

Been there. Done that.

Chavez has his own TV show. The descriptions of it are quite funny in the recent profile in the New Yorker [another potential slamfest].

Chavez and Castro are known for delivering speeches that sometimes last as long as a typical miniseries. Could you imagine Bush giving an eight hour stemwinder? Perhaps when Obama is elected he can stretch the American attention span beyond the sound bite?

Genghis

You left out the "experience" card "Joe Lieberman and Phil Gramm as your surrogates/advisors". That would have surely driven Obama raving and certifiable mad thereby eliminating the competition in one swell.

Well....Obama didn't graduate at the bottom of his class either.

avatar

". . . . in light of his inexperience in intrahemispheric relations, he has no choice but to tour Central and South America, Canada, Greenland, and the Galapagos. . . ."

What have you against Tiera del Fuegons?

I knew that this was going to happen. I name representative locations in the hemisphere, and some little jerk (I mean that in an affectionate way) whines about the one place that I didn't mention. Well Tiera del Fuegons can kiss my ass. Along with Uruguay, Jamaica, and the Aleutian Islands. Especially the Aleutian Islands.

Post a Comment

Inside Cafe



Cafe Features


October 20-24

Book Cover

October 27-30

Book Cover

November 17-21

Book Cover

December 1-5

Book Cover

Book Club Archive



Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Claire Wilcox



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address