Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

It's Official; The Press Turns on "Presumptuous" Obama

avatar

I guess the Uppity One on a World Tour was just too much for their lily-white hearts. There are, after all, rules. In the Willa Cather world the Washington press corps inhabit, decorum is life. Birth and breeding will out. George Bush has the sense and sensibility of a trailer park whore, but he's got Barbara's genes and a political pedigree -- like an expensive dog. John McCain makes George Bush look like the cover boy for the Journal of the Mind, but he was a Soldier who shows the press proper deference and never suggests that he's brighter than they are. They love him in return.

The Los Angeles Times highlighted a study by the Center for Media and Public Affairs at George Mason University showing that, "ABC, NBC and CBS were tougher on Obama than on Republican John McCain during the first six weeks of the general-election campaign."

It's not just the networks. The press pack has turned. The unfortunate Maureen Dowd provides a rambling column of nitpicking negatives that ends by repeating the narrative that Obama should be winning by a landslide, and since he is not, needs all the help he can get.

She points a finger because he does not personally pick out the trinkets he brings to his daughters from the road. Hearing that he saw his daughter perform in a play of The Odyssey, she writes: "I wonder if that rang any bells on this trip." Get it? Heroes? Thank God he didn't see her in a kiddie Mamma Mia. Dowd would have spouted Abba lyrics at him, pregnant with significance.

His greatest sin per Dowd? Reckless displays of intellect unbecoming a black man.
She writes: " The senator left his briefing books behind for a rare instance of mingling with his journalism posse at a Berlin restaurant as he sipped a rare "very dry" martini with olives."

"Briefing books," she sniffs, as if to suggest 'only the little people need to know what they're talking about. The Elect just say it (whatever it may be) with natural authority and that's enough.' And then of course, the dig about not sufficiently kissing her ass, the "rare instance of mingling with his journalism posse..."

She goes on: "The Obamanauts were so elated [with the overseas trip] that they didn't even seem to mind the caricature of Obama, ears sticking out, that had been drawn on the round We-Are-The-World Obama logo in the press section. The cartoon candidate demanded: 'Worship me.'"

The press is now drawing horns and a mustache on his image. Then one of them is stupid enough to admit it in print. And they wonder why we think they're adolescent, self-righteous fools.

Dana Milbank goes Dowd one better. He takes the word "Presumptuous," -- today's euphemism for "Uppity Nigger" and slings it with a malicious abandon you'd expect from a bunker-based, confederate-flag draped Red State commenter.

"Barack Obama has long been his party's presumptive nominee. Now he's becoming its presumptuous nominee," he writes.

He ordered up a teleconference with the (current president's) Treasury secretary, granted an audience to the Pakistani prime minister and had his staff arrange for the chairman of the Federal Reserve to give him a briefing.

Note the construction: Obama "granted an audience"... as opposed to the Pakistani prime minister agreeing to meet with him. "Had his staff arrange" for a briefing. In other words, he had "the help" do it when we all know that he should be "the help."

Milbank continues, "Then, he went up to Capitol Hill to be adored by House Democrats in a presidential-style pep rally."

Of the same House Democratic "pep rally," Maureen Dowd wrote:

Some said his reception was not as enthusiastic as the one Hillary got when she returned from her odyssey. The room warmed to him, mainly because he told the lawmakers how much he'd need them to get policies passed if he gets elected.

Same event, opposite takes. Both equally devoid of verifiable fact. Both equally negative.

Milbank then blames Obama for his travel style: 

Along the way, he traveled in a bubble more insulating than the actual president's. Traffic was shut down for him as he zoomed about town in a long, presidential-style motorcade, while the public and most of the press were kept in the dark about his activities.

Obama should obviously ignore the security precautions of the Secret Service and hop a bus.

In both Milbank and Dowd, there is the hint of the personal affront. Both their tones suggest that the American political Marquis of Queensbury rules are being broken and both appoint themselves the Keepers of Sacred Tradition. It was the same with the Clintons. They just weren't "one of us." Might there be another Barbarian at the gate? Or, to paraphrase a character from the 1972 film, The Man, Rod Serling's take on the first black president: 'There may be a jigaboo in the White House.'

Obama is behaving the way any other over-achieving black man behaves (who has not risen due to the condescension of white benefactors). He is preparing ad nauseum for any event, and out-doing his competition at every turn. He is the smartest guy in the room. He displays the results of his brains and preparation.

Attack him for any direct quote or action that suggests he buys his own hype. That's only fair. However, he's now being attacked for doing a better, and more thorough job of running for president than anyone in recent political memory. He's being attacked for being good at his given task.

I once had a white boss in an all-white workplace literally sit me down in his office and say. "You're a very bright guy."

"Thank you," I said.

He paused for too long. Then he said. "You should try to be..." he paused again, obviously uncomfortable, "... a little less. You know what I mean?"

Yes. I knew what he meant.


Comments (14)

Thanks for reading Dowd so that the rest of us don't have to, I guess.

avatar

LOL

Not sure Millbank is "the press," and I know for sure Dowd is not.

Once upon a time Maureen Dowd was a good journalist. She was young bright and ambitious. The Times took note and in time gave her more and more editorial freedom; i.e. they allowed her to suggest a style other than The Times stricters. Her 1992 Pulitzer for reporting increased her style allowance 10-fold. Some whispered that The Times promoted her to columnist when editorial could no longer control her unbriddled style. She won the 1999 Pulitzer for commentary and from then on the snitty, pop-style wannabe Maureen Down emerged. The first victim: Al Gore.

Today, I don't think the profession or most readers see writing and style as anything other than a smart-ass, pop-culture huing, wit-obsessed, smarm. To my earlier point, she is not understood as a journalist, but only as a pundit.

Alas, our dear Dana Millbank was also once a fair journalist, albeit without any Pulitzers. I think he fell victim to his beat (political theater) and then his fame (via CountDown). Will he reach the level of snarkiness that Ms Dowd has reached in sarcasm? We shall see.

But for now, I don't think Dana (isn't that a girl's name?), who still pracices some journalism, currently represents all journalism.

I've been heartened by some of the journo's at The Times, the WaPo and CNN in challenging the fairness of McCain's recent attack plan. When did the chorus do the same for Gore or Kerry?

Not sure Millbank is "the press," and I know for sure Dowd is not.

Once upon a time Maureen Dowd was a good journalist. She was young bright and ambitious. The Times took note and in time gave her more and more editorial freedom; i.e. they allowed her to suggest a style other than The Times stricters. Her 1992 Pulitzer for reporting increased her style allowance 10-fold. Some whispered that The Times promoted her to columnist when editorial could no longer control her unbriddled style. She won the 1999 Pulitzer for commentary and from then on the snitty, pop-style wannabe Maureen Down emerged. The first victim: Al Gore.

Today, I don't think the profession or most readers see writing and style as anything other than a smart-ass, pop-culture huing, wit-obsessed, smarm. To my earlier point, she is not understood as a journalist, but only as a pundit.

Alas, our dear Dana Millbank was also once a fair journalist, albeit without any Pulitzers. I think he fell victim to his beat (political theater) and then his fame (via CountDown). Will he reach the level of snarkiness that Ms Dowd has reached in sarcasm? We shall see.

But for now, I don't think Dana (isn't that a girl's name?), who still pracices some journalism, currently represents all journalism.

I've been heartened by some of the journo's at The Times, the WaPo and CNN in challenging the fairness of McCain's recent attack plan. When did the chorus do the same for Gore or Kerry?

Yes, I've known what many a person meant, so to speak.

Dowd does her damnedest to emasculate Obama at every turn, and the Milbank thing, while out of far left field, was the kind of thing that I've seen people fired over.

If Obama was not confident, the press would accuse him of not being comfortable in his own skin. Is it just him not genuflecting before the media, their penchant for creating whatever flaw with the Democrat, or something else? I don't know. I don't understand the shallowness of it all.

avatar

The press "turned" on OBama right around March-April, when they decided to attack him to keep it close with Hillary.

Now it's time to "keep it close" and also help out the GOP.

Just the usual MSM job of gaming/manipulating the election.

By "presumptuous", what they really mean is "uppity". Interesting how quickly the media has chosen to play by Rove's playbook.

To quote Mos Def: “If white boys doing it well, it’s success / when I start doing it well it’s suspect.”

avatar

So true!!

Another Mos Def quote, also somewhat appropos,

"We're either n-----s or kings,
We're either bitches or queens."

avatar

I wonder why the press can only pick up on the point that Sen. Obama gets more media attention and not the fact that the attention he gets is negative 72% of the time. I am sick of the press and broadcast media driving these petty issues to the point of nausea. Can we ever get to the real issues? Can we ever get a discussion on maybe the John McCain we see today is the real John McCain? I don't know. I have questions about Barack Obama too, but fair is fair. The American people deserve better from the media and the candidates.

The Mainstream media and McCain's handlers have focused on selling Americans on imagery of the "War Hero...Maverick...Naval Aviator" while hiding the disturbing side of McCain. Nine out of 10 POW's who returned from Vietnam were diagnosed with PTSD (Post Traumatic Stress Syndrome).

Evidence shows that McCain was tortured so severely in Vietnam that he tried to commit suicide. On the campaign trail, including interviews with media professionals, McCain has exhibited a consistent failure to recall basic facts and has been known to lash out in anger and sing strange songs like "Bomb Bomb Iran" to the tune of the Beachboys Barbara Ann. McCain's behavior indicates the onset of Alzheimers, Senility or at least some form of mental illness, which should have been treated a long time ago.

Despite his wearing Navy ballcaps regularly and posing as a TOP GUN ala Tom Cruise, history shows that McCain was a terrible pilot,crashed several military aircraft, nearly flunked out of the Naval Academy where he spent more of his time behind a bar stool than studying and preparing to become a proficient pilot. McCain was unprepared for Vietnam and is admittedly unprepared now. He has stated that "the economy is not my strong suit" and "I need my assistants to log me on to the internet. I have no use for email." ----Is this the type of Maverick America needs right now...or an old ignorant schmuck who is the Trojan Horse of the GOP? McCain is off his rocker and many in his own party know it which is why they want a stabilizing force on the ticket and see John McCain as the Trojan Horse to help them hold on to the Whitehouse. Face it, Republicans know how to win elections. Rove works for McCain now.

avatar


at a Berlin restaurant as he sipped a
rare "very dry" martini with olives."

OMG! The same martini that Rove "sees" him
drinking at the country club.. with the beautiful
date.. and making snide comments about everyone
who passes by"?

Post a Comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Book Club Calendar

Coming Soon



Nov. 30-Dec. 4



January 12-16



« Book Club ArchiveFull calendar »

Recent Reader Posts

All Reader Posts »





Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address