Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

DOOMED?: The Lessons of Katrina

avatar

As the announcement of Bertha brings us into the third hurricane season since Katrina, it is important to heed one of her terrible lessons - that our FEMA strategy is (still) overwhelmingly dependent on the ability of ordinary citizens to help themselves.

The epicenter of Katrina's human toll centered in the poorest wards of New Orleans, where many people (by their own means) could not evacuate prior to the storm's arrival.  An oft repeated question in the aftermath was "why didn't those people just leave?"   The fact is, hurricane paths are not predictable; particularly early on.  Where a storm will take landfall, and how destructive it will be (or not be) cannot be accurately predicted until the final days or hours. Moving out of harms way can bring with it significant expense: lost wages, travel, lodging, and food, among others.  Thus, the decision to stay or leave can be a very expensive crap shoot for those living paycheck-to-paycheck.

The economic crisis now facing the whole of the U.S. has greatly increased the number of families that cannot easily bear the speculative expense of avoiding a potential storm.  Further, the breathtaking rise in fuel and food prices have only upped the ante.  Looming still, is the specter of an early Gulf hurricane crippling domestic refining capacity and driving the cost of a tank of gasoline, which could ultimately be the difference between a family's life and death, out of reach.

It is highly likely that many of the critical assumptions within our FEMA policy rely upon economic realities that no longer hold true.  Many Floridian families have been particularly affected by the impacts of the sub-prime mortgage crisis leaving them much less able to fend for themselves even without the threat  of hurricanes.

Unless, FEMA, the President, and our political leadership take immediate action to adapt and respond to this new vulnerability, the likeliness of a "worse than Katrina" scenario is all too plausible.


Comments (5)

I know you are right because I lived it. Four years ago I owned a waterfront house, had a tranquil life and money in the bank. I lost it all -- not because of the gulf hurricane itself, but rather, because:
1) FEMA was very, very late and useless when they arrived;
2) the insurance industry is now in the business of delaying and denying claims, for a year or more, on policies that were paid in full; partial payments are approved only when one agrees to a percentage payout, rather than a payment in full;
3) during that year (or more) that intervenes, everything you have to spend on clean-up crews, engineering reports, other substantiating documentation, as well as replacements of bare necessities like clothing, is out-of-pocket -- the insurer tells you to "keep your receipts for reimbursement";
4) despite this delay, mortgage payments and property taxes are still due, on time, even if the house is gone; in fact, many mortgage companies attempt to call the original loan in full, even if you are current in your payments (just say no, repeatedly, with a lawyer's help if necessary);
4) you have to live somewhere, and so your housing and utility expenses can double.

The good news? Learning real survival skills in both the literal and figurative sense. And, after the fact, learning to love living with less.

And the point I was trying to make here, before I got "engulfed" by another round of self-pity, is that if I was vanquished -- with all the assets and life experience confidence I had, why do we think that someone downtrodden, without assets, living in the nineth ward, can somehow triumph over this kind of bureaucratic malfeasance?
Everyone -- old/young, rich/poor, educated/illiterate -- is on his or her own. That is the reality of the current hurricane, or Midwest flood, season. And note: although hundreds of thousands of Midwesterners were subject to the same syndrome as those who experience tidal surges from hurricanes, how many follow -up articles, or MSM videos do you see, to tell you how people are actually doing, after the adreniline surge of the actual event is over????
As we speak, people in the Midwest who were struck either by tornadoes, or by flooding, are suffering, trying to do the best they can in the face of what they will discover are impossibly stacked odds.
The response by the media? No coverage. The response by their government? No real help.The ongoing concern by their fellow citizens not so affected? Zero.
And we will only add to their numbers those who are affected by this current hurricane season.

This is great, Brian. We get so caught up in the issues that get big media hype and we lose sight of the ongoing issues that are being neglected until the next crisis.

Brian, are you originally from the DC area?

avatar

No. I'm not originally from DC, but I did live in Columbia MD for short time around 2000.

Well, not the BC I'm thinking of. Thanks for confirming. :)

Post a Comment

Inside Cafe

Recommended Reader Posts



Cafe Features


September 15-20

Book Cover

September 22-27

Book Cover

September 29-October 3

Book Cover

October 6-10

Book Cover

October 13-17

Book Cover

October 20-24

Book Cover

December 1-5

Book Cover





Book Club Archive



Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall

Site Editor
Lila Shapiro

Intern
Claire Wilcox



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address