Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

Borger Almost Gets the Story Right (formatted)

John McCain's increasing meltdown into jealousy and fury seems invisible to most of the mainstream media, including Katie Couric's fawning piece on tonight's "CBS Evening News," which examined none of McCain's policies and, in fact, barely quoted McCain at all.

Gloria Borger, columnist for the conservative U.S. News & World Report, almost had it right — almost.

Borger's most recent column, republished on the CBS News web site, at least recognizes the petty distortions and petulant temper that increasingly define McCain and his campaign. She writes:

Getting mad made Clinton look small. McCain just looks mean.
Borger's prescription is for McCain to cool his jets and position himself as a "humble" servant of his country. But then Borger blows a fairly even-handed opinion piece with this:
So why not try to accentuate what works best for McCain, such as his credentials as someone who has spent a career bucking his party, working across the aisle, trying to fix things? Clinton's populist voice handed her success; McCain as a reformer is his best bet. After all, McCain was a leader in efforts to reform congressional pork-barrel spending, immigration, and ethics. He worked with Democrats on a truce to limit filibusters of Supreme Court nominees. He's against torture.
I won't quibble with Borger's quibble-worthy litany of praise, except for her last assertion: "He's against torture."

Every columnist is entitled to their own opinion; none are entitled to their own facts. Borger, while earning Brownie points for acknowledging McCain's tantrums, somehow missed this character flaw reported in the Feb. 16 edition of the Boston Globe:
JOHN MCCAIN this week had a choice between his principles and propping up a failed president. He chose the latter.

The Senate joined the House in passing an intelligence bill that would ban the CIA from using waterboarding as an interrogation tactic. The CIA would have to abide by the Army Field Manual, which also prohibits beatings, electric or temperature shocks, forced nudity, mock executions, and the use of dogs. Some of those abusive techniques were on global display in the torture photos from Abu Ghraib.

McCain, a Vietnam prisoner of war, has long condemned waterboarding as torture, making him more sensitive than President Bush on an issue that stained America's image. But the Arizona senator and virtual Republican nominee to replace Bush voted against the bill. Bush says he will veto the measure.

McCain said that while he remains opposed to waterboarding, "We always supported allowing the CIA to use extra measures."
If Borger's foray into honestly assessing McCain breaks down in the end, it may be that her subject's inconsistency has rubbed off on her. Or it may be that the Straight Talk Express is running on too much anger to counter with mere fact-checking.

If the media is no more accurate than the mean old man who can't get express straight talk, how are we all to keep from getting thrown under the bus by lies?


Comments (6)

Ending should be: If the media is no more accurate than the mean old man who can't express straight talk, how are we all to keep from getting thrown under the bus by lies?

Not a strong ending, I realize, but a point I hope will stimulate thought.

avatar

'ello, Ripper. How are you? Hope things (non-political) are looking brighter for you.

re Couric: she worries me. I remember reading during the primary that she's great friends with Hillary Clinton. It has me wondering how many other women she reflects - prepared to throw this election to McCain just to give Hillary her chance in 2012?

Somebody needs to talk Supreme Court to sweet little Katie... sigh

Couric is a waste - not even worthy of being called a journalist. She's fluff.

Borger...I like what she's doing. It's the beginning of a challenge, I think. She's setting McCain up to return to what he's supposed to represent. Problem for John is, he's not what he's been set up to be. He can't fulfill his own image. Thus, the tantrums and pettiness. She's calling him - ever so gently - on his bad behavior. I'd like to see more of this coming from the press. No more passes and excuses. Obama has risen above and risen above, and McCain just keeps sinking lower and lower. Enough.

If there's more to you, McCain, then let's see it. Show your cards.

This whole pro-McCain bias is alarming. Interesting that as soon as Obama gets some really good news McCain complains about the phantom "liberal bias". That turned out to be a good thing because it prompted Media Matters to review and find that Obama gets much more negative and much less positive press than McCain. It's important to keep it up to call out the real right-wing bias that we have been seeing for many years now.

Glad to see Borger is at least dipping her toe in water that's not rose tinted for McCain.

avatar

"Damn kids get the hell of my lawn " McCain is only being held up by the Borgers of the media world - wHAT IS EVEN MORE PROBLEMATIC -is that Fournier at the AP almost worked for the Mc Cranky election effort -
but nothing sticks in my craw like the time Ken Ruud of NPR -while on CNN- kept referring to how Senator Clinton was starting to look and sound like Glenn Close in "Fatal Attraction"..
So we need to treat Ms Couric with some due deference and respect - there was a lot of hate women speak during the primary -
But going back to the Straight Talk Express Senator McCain has sold his soul and his priniciples to the neo cons & K street -and the real karmic retribution for that sell out for Mac is that we will win big in November -up & down the ticket
PS -any of you all got any spare change send it to Noriega - we are going to beat Cornyn down here if we can get enough resources !!

avatar

Don't make me dislike Borger even more.
She's Cokie Roberts lite; yah, that stupid, but with more stretches and squirms on camera, though with just as many cliches and cable's boundless tolerance.
And Couric, but what more can be said about the unashamed girl in the warehouse next door, the one that America keeps resisting despite her 'All-This-and-Heaven-Too' salary that still insults common sense, $15 million a year, as the flowers wilt on the great Murrow's grave.

Post a Comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address