« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »
White House for Whites Only? A Fathers Day Tribute
Cleary afraid to debate the Obamas on policy, the Republicans are playing the "They Hate America" card, and all of its permutations. The ace and queen in this deck are "he went to a racist church" and, his wife "isn't proud" of her country. On Father's Day, I find this particularly offensive. So I write this to honor my father.
In some ways, this is not unlike the campaign that defeated John Kerry, who looked too "French". At its heart, the argument is "he's too different." And when the candidate is Black, and most of the voters are not, the line separating "too different" from "too Black" is thin indeed. The terrorist fist pumping "baby's mama" lovers at Fox crossed that line long ago.
This becomes particularly dicey for Michelle Obama. Unlike her husband, whose black father only came to the US in 1959, she is the product of all of America's shameful race history. The right is making the false claim that to be disappointed in that history means she does not love America, so she's not qualified to live in the White House. The logic that Hannity and friends sell is that any Black who is not "over" racism is a crazy radical who hates the country. Since this group includes pretty much every black person I know who is not a Republican, it's a logic that disqualifies almost all African Americans from the nation's highest office. It is time to call Bullsh*t on this crap once and for all. If he were alive today, this is the argument my father would have made.
Let me one more time point out the complete duplicity and lack of logic in this argument. Obama tried it once in his first Rev Wright speech, and it got blanketed over by the loud shouters on Fox and the radio.
Black Americans have a different experience than most whites. We are not talking slavery or ancient history. We're talking current events. Our families, our fathers, our lives, right now. We could no more deny it than we could deny the entire black community.
I'm talking about the real life experiences of our families. Almost all of our parents were denied equal access to everything from jobs to education to free choice of where to live. It includes being born into a ghetto, because that is the only place our parents were allowed to live. It includes going to under funded public schools, because in so many places, when integration became the law, many whites with money either fled to the suburbs or to private schools, taking their cash and involvement with them. It includes, even to this day, 1/3 of black children being born into poverty.
Great scholarships, high income and political success are wonderful things to achieve, but to many African Americans who have "made it", there is also the sadness of knowing how far our parents could have come had they been granted equal opportunity. If you only think of your personal success, then maybe you could be Rush Limbaugh proud. But if you look around the black community, or drop by your mom's house in the old neighborhood, there's a good chance you'll get pissed off. Pissed that this is where the federal government put the projects back in the 60's, and where the local government allows crack houses to flourish today
As I write this, it is Father's Day. I have achieved great success in my life because of his efforts. I earn enough money that John McCain's tax policy benefits me better than Obama's. My father was one of the smartest people I know. When he died, one of the teachers at the school where he worked said he would have made a better principal than most of the ones he worked under. But he wasn't the principal, he was the head custodian. He was mopping floors and cleaning toilets until the day he retired. It was the best job he could get and he made the best of it. My success is his success, and he died as he lived, a very proud man. He left no debt and he owned his own home. Sadly, it was only worth about $25,000, because it was in a black neighborhood. So don't tell me I don't have the right, on Father's Day, to be disappointed in the country that told him that a janitor was all he could be.
This disappointment does not consume me. Most days, it never crosses my mind. But on Father's Day, it always does. To deny it is to deny the struggle my father endured to make me what I am. If Shawn Hannity thinks that's what I need to do to prove I love my country, I have 2 works for him. F off.
I wish this was not my reality. But the stain of the past doesn't disappear when they hand you a degree and a nice salary. This doesn't mean I don't love America. It means I love her in spite of her faults, and it means I have a continuing commitment to helping the country overcome its history.
I can't love America the same way John McCain does. When his daddy was Admiral, my daddy was mopping floors. And when his granddaddy was Admiral, all the Blacks in the entire Navy were mopping floors. But they still volunteered and went to war, even when their commanders didn't think they were brave enough to fight. So who loves America more? The cook on the ship who couldn't vote in 15 states, or the Admiral who dined on the meals he slaved over?
So when the right wing-nuts say Michelle Obama, because she remembers similar indignities imposed on her own parents, can't be first lady, what they are really doing is hanging a 'Whites Only" sign on the White House. The very thought is un-American.











Comments (19)
M3Man,
Thank you for such an honest and heartfelt post. It made me cry and I have cried a few times during this campaign.
People like Hannity, Limbaugh and Buchanan absolutely must deny our reality because to acknowledge it means admitting they are privileged which for most privileged people is impossible to do.
White people are told that they are successful because of their skills and talents so how devastating it is to realize that perhaps it's only because they're white and not because they're smart or special or better than people of color. They are white in a system created just for them--that doesn't make them special, it just makes them, well, white.
I think about your father and his potential....I wrote a piece once about how the world denies itself the fullness of human potential by oppressing fellow human beings. We would no doubt be more progressed as a people on a planet if everyone was allowed and encouraged to contribute all of their talents, skills and creativity. It's a disgusting shame and an outrage.
Thank you so much for addressing issues that touch me at the core of my soul. And peace & blessings to you and your father.
June 15, 2008 3:12 PM | Reply | Permalink
Love this comment.
I am often ashamed to live in a country that leaves 80-percent of its people behind and then I remember we live a world that leave perhaps 99 percent of its population behind.
How many Einsteins and Mozarts have to die in poverty and hunger before we wake up as a human race?
The only thing that gives me hope is that we will have no choice but to come together as a planet as climate change gets more severe. A global problem may finally prompt us to acknowledge the basic greatness of every person, regardless of skin hue or geographic location.
June 16, 2008 8:33 AM | Reply | Permalink
What you're talking about is very similar to what Aldous Huxley was driving at with his short story "Young Archimedes" ...
June 16, 2008 10:08 AM | Reply | Permalink
Very Well Said!
No need to add anything else, other than:
Bravo!
June 15, 2008 3:46 PM | Reply | Permalink
When I read something such as your post, it solidifies my belief that, "Until you walk in someone's shoes, you do not have the right or the experience necessary to make judgments about their character. Most who hand out verdicts about anothers life and actions seldom turn the mirror on themselves as harshly or with the same broad brush."
We all forget that our words and actions or lack thereof cause ripples in others lives, sometimes tidal waves. Too often, our lack of 'standing up and speaking out' is the most damaging.
Today is a good day to celebrate Obama's candidacy for too many reasons to list.
I thank you for your heartfelt post and sincerely wish you a Happy and Blessed Fathers Day!
June 15, 2008 4:01 PM | Reply | Permalink
Thanks for your thoughtful rely, Vision.
I would not want to deny any white person the fact that they may have worked hard for what they achieved. Likewise, I would like many to stop denying that they play on a field that is not level. Even when there is no overt racism, they are far more likely to remind the boss of his son or daughter than of a dangerous robber or rapper. Their competance is more likely to be expected, than surprizing. And let me squelch the Affirmative Action argument before it even starts. A-A only serves to give minority an equal chace for a job they are otherwise qualified to do. And remember, when 10 people are up for a job and the black guy gets it, 9 may decry reverse racism. The reality is 9 of them would have never gotten the job under any circumstances, but AA lets them all blame the black guy.
If you really want to talk A-A, how about the Admiral's son and grandson who somehow gets a coveted spot at the Naval Academy, graduates near the bottom of his class, gets a coveted pilot's job, then crashes a bunch of planes before being captured, who gets out and marries a multi-millionaire. Know any black people like that? Or like the President's son who got into Yale as a Legacy.. the original Affirmative Action plan, who drinks 2 oil company's into the ground, takes credit for the way Bob Bullock ran Texas, then lies the nation into the Iraqi debacle.
It would be so nice if the Obama phenomenon allowed a full discussion of all of this. But if we allow Fox and Rush to control the conversation, race relations will be harmed rather than helped.
May we all follow Obama's example and be respectful of the pain race causes whites, browns and blacks. Just don't be deceived into thinking the pain is equal.
June 15, 2008 5:02 PM | Reply | Permalink
Yes, that didn't come out quite right and I did not mean to suggest that white people are only successful or accomplished because of their whiteness!
Instead, having done diversity work as a profession, I found that is was very difficult, often painful for some people to recognize that they could have been, and most likely are beneficiaries of unearned privilege.
Did you get that job or cab because of the color of your skin?
Did you get that apartment because you were married and in a heterosexual relationship?
Were you voted Prom Queen because your parents made the biggest donation to the school building fund?
Coming to terms with the reality of unearned privilege can be brutal.
In terms of loving this country or being proud to be an American....Well, I think if it wasn't for the First Peoples, African Slaves, White Indentured Servants and Poor Women of every color, there would be no America. On top of all the hard work these groups have done, oppressed people force this country to live up to its highest ideals and represent the heart and soul America. Damn it!
June 15, 2008 6:46 PM | Reply | Permalink
"May we all follow Obama's example and be respectful of the pain race causes whites, browns and blacks. Just don't be deceived into thinking the pain is equal."
That's a beautiful statement and a beautiful wish. Being respectful of the pain is a key. So many of us white folks are indeed blind and deaf to the ways in which the odds are stacked in our favor and against non-whites. We don't see the way others suffer for being other than white, and we don't wanna hear them talk about it!
BTW, white brethren/sisters, I am not self-hating or encouraging any guilt-fest on your part. I didn't see this attitude in myself until mid-life, even though I always considered myself progressive and did not consciously embrace any racist ideology. Most of us have been afflicted by this blindness and deafness, as a result of being embedded in the very soil from which we sprang. Just don't let that soil fill your eyes and ears. Make an effort to be open. Open your eyes and see what you see. Open your ears and just listen respectfully when someone is speaking their pain, feel it and think on it. See where it takes you.
June 15, 2008 7:13 PM | Reply | Permalink
Great post!
June 15, 2008 9:04 PM | Reply | Permalink
Thank you for this post. When I opened it, I had only just stopped bawling my eyes out having come from watching the Russert memorial edition of Meet the Press.
So maybe I was vulnerable when I started reading your post but it had me weeping all over again confronting as it does man's bloody awful inhumanity to man at different times and in different places.
As I write this I'm sitting in a lovely little computer room overlooking my cottage garden with the sun glinting off the morning glory leaves. And I know that only 1000 km away, so many of our (Australia's) indigenent people are living in the most appalling conditions that no amount of government money seems to ameliorate, basically now because of alcohol, but originally because of the original Australian sin of genocide and effective apartheid.
I wonder how many generations does it take?
June 15, 2008 9:47 PM | Reply | Permalink
Thanks for your excellent post.
I think many whites don't have a clear understanding of the indignities black Americans suffered during segregation. I think many whites don't actually understand how horrible it was for a black man, who sincerely wanted to provide for his familiy to find out that that his talent mattered much less than his race.
That said, I think many, even most whites, would be empathetic. No, not the Sean Hannity types who simply work for their Republican paymasters who benefit from racial disharmony, but the overwhelming bulk of whites who 1)often had similar struggles against prejudice themselves based not on race, but on language, culture or religion and 2) are sympathetic to the idea of a massive struggle against overwhelming odds.
I don't think whites understand what our parents and grandparents went through, but I think many whites know enough to recognize that the system was horribly unfair and, themselves, take some pride in the fact that much of segregation has been dismantled.
I think black hostility to these whites many of whom are reasonable, fair minded people is counterproductive. I think many, even most white Americans believe that in all spheres of public life blacks and white should receive the same treatment. Equally, many whites (and blacks) would admit that the system remains unfair but much less unfair than it used to be and would argue that, even in an unfair system, blacks men do themselves no favors when they abandon their kids.
Obama speaks to many reasonable whites in a language and tone they understand. For example, blacks and whites may disagree as to whether high black incarceration rates are explained by high black criminal behavior or by racially biased policing. I think Obama would say that we need to try and curb black criminality and reform the police. Neither party is completely guilty or guiltless. In fact, sitting around trying to assign blame is far less useful than working for improvement.
If real racial progress is to be made, someone has to mediate between both sides. Obama, in my view, is the best in politics today.
June 16, 2008 12:39 AM | Reply | Permalink
wow, what a poignant post! hear hear hear!!!! i always got it and your post just solidify what i have always known in my heart...in the spirit of obama, let's keep it all respectful...
June 16, 2008 12:50 AM | Reply | Permalink
As a father, I don't know if I'd be able to find the words to adequately express just how proud I was feeling, if I were to read this post and realize that these were my son's words.
I do know that I'd feel like I'd done something that nobody could ever take away from me. You've done your father proud with this.
June 16, 2008 6:29 AM | Reply | Permalink
"Since this group includes pretty much every black person I know who is not a Republican, it's a logic that disqualifies almost all African Americans from the nation's highest office."
Great line.
An addition to your great lineage paragraph toward the end of your post. (You may have avoided this one on purpose, but it's worth noting, and it's true.) Go one more generation back and we've got:
When McCain's great-grandaddy needed his floors mopped, he told one of his dozens of slaves to do it.
June 16, 2008 8:22 AM | Reply | Permalink
There is a county in Virginia that from 1959 to 1964 closed their public schools rather than desegregate. "Private" schools were opened all over the county for the white student however most of the black students had to forgo their eduction all together.
I don't bring this up to stir up old pain but to point out that the effects of these actions are long lasting as the children of this generation were raised by parents with often only an elementary school education. I absolutely agree with this great post that their are current effects of the actions of previous generations that can't be ignored. They don't need to be used as a weapon either but we can all agree that Barack Obama is as far from a racial radical as you can get while still remaining in touch with racial realities.
June 16, 2008 10:21 AM | Reply | Permalink
Link: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Davis_v._County_School_Board_of_Prince_Edward_County
June 16, 2008 10:23 AM | Reply | Permalink
What a beautiful and moving post. Thank you.
June 16, 2008 11:35 AM | Reply | Permalink
Great post. A human post.
June 16, 2008 2:40 PM | Reply | Permalink
I've never lost sight of the divide between opportunities for white people and opportunities for black people, but it was abstract until I did research for a student guide to the film Public Enemy. Some of what I discovered:
The 1999 President’s Initiative on Race found these statistics:
Nothing like a few numbers to show how much racism still exists, and it's the covert racism that does the most harm.
June 16, 2008 2:59 PM | Reply | Permalink
Post a Comment