Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

The REALLY Great Escape, 2008 (Steve McQueen as Mullah Omar, James Garner as Baitullah Mehsud

Are you kidding me?  In this version of the movie (Oliver Stone, pick up the phone...) everyone gets clean away.

Freedom's on th' march fer sure...What kind of government is susceptible to this sort of evidence of  open irrelevance?  

Someone who knows Sarah Cheyes, please ask her what's up, because it is evident that the writ of Kabul runs about five hundred yards away from the Presidential palace, and no further.

"Wali Karzai, the brother of President Hamid Karzai who is president of Kandahar's provincial council, said... ''all'' the prisoners escaped, ''There is no one left,''

http://www.nytimes.com/aponline/world/AP-Afghan-Prison-Attack.html?hp


Comments (25)

That good news?

THIS IS EXCELLENT NEWS, FOR OSAMA!

(For us, eh, not so much...)

That said, it does appear that our puppet regime in Kabul is *mimicking our version of gitmo justice and perhaps we may be forgiven for thinking that some of the fleeing prisoners are no more guilty than the brave flyboys who busted out of that nazi p.o.w. camp...

*"Lawmaker Habibullah Jan said 47 of the prisoners had **stitched their mouths shut during the hunger strike in May. He said some of the hunger strikers had been held without trial for more than two years and others were given lengthy prison sentences after short trials."

**(These are some hard core motherfuckers...)

Dammnnnn... That's taking the "Iron-Jawed Angels" approach to entirely new heights.

That good news?

On second thought, maybe so:

"Some 300 women who came to protest outside the prison at the time said their relatives inside had been picked up by NATO and American military sweeps and were innocent but nevertheless held without trial for months and even years"

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/14/world/asia/14kandahar.html?hp

Iron-Jawed Angels

mmmm...Hilary Swank (disclaimer:gratuitous chauvinism alert)

Whoa, from the NYTimes report:

The prison attack came just a few hours after Defense Secretary Robert Gates told his counterparts in Europe that NATO members need to bolster their military effort in Afghanistan, where violence has been escalating.

Dramatizing his report, Gates said that for the first time, the monthly total of American and allied combat deaths in Afghanistan had exceeded the toll in Iraq during May.

What's that new P.R. effort all about?

I've been reading an awful lot of stuff suggesting that many peeps are growing increasingly unhappy with Karzai (and not just Bush peeps,) maybe that has something to do with it.

Oh and I found this one interesting:

In Afghanistan, the NATO-led Force is 'Underresourced' For the Fight Against the Taliban When it comes to combat, it is a coalition of the willing and not-so-willing By Anna Mulrine, Posted June 5, 2008

KANDAHAR—Ask American troops in Afghanistan what ISAF means, and you are opening the door to a running joke: "I Saw Americans Fight," and "I Suck at Fighting," and "I Sunbathe at FOBs" (a reference to the heavily fortified and largely safe forward operating bases) are among the more popular punch lines. In fact, ISAF is the acronym for the NATO-led International Security Assistance Force....

And the U.S. soldiers who offer up the jokes are only half kidding. Their point is a serious one: that troops from the United States—along with just a handful of other countries—do the bulk of the heavy fighting, while a number of other ISAF detachments are limited by their own governments' combat restrictions. These include prohibitions, or "caveats," against, for example, fighting in the snow for troops from some southern European nations. Other soldiers are required to stay in calmer areas of the country or to keep their aircraft grounded at night or to consult their home legislatures before operating near the volatile Pakistani border....


American and allied combat deaths in Afghanistan had exceeded the toll in Iraq during May.

a real eyebrow raiser, n'est-ce pas?

Apparently there's going to be enough material for more than one good action flick:

Mass jailbreak by Taliban stuns Kandahar
guardian.co.uk, UK - 4 hours ago
Up to 1000 prisoners, including 400 Taliban militants, were on the run in Kandahar last night after a dramatic Taliban assault on the southern Afghan city's ...

Could it have something to do with the Zawahiri v. Fadl debate?

the Zawahiri v. Fadl debate?

Ya gotta love the Salafi Chat Room--Uncle Ayman answers all your questions...

Yeah, two action flicks, for sure:

Jets Bomb World's Biggest Drugs Haul Sky News, Updated:16:04, Thursday June 12, 2008

The world's biggest haul of drugs - worth more than £200m - has been discovered in Afghanistan and blown up by British fighter jets.

More than 260 tons of marijuana was uncovered in 6ft-deep trenches in the southern province of Kandahar.

The jets were called in to smash open the underground stores.

The planes dropped three 1,000lb bombs on the trenches before troops doused the wreckage with petrol and set it alight....


RAF bombs send world's biggest drugs haul up in smoke
By David Blair, Diplomatic Editor, The Telegraph
Last Updated: 2:46PM BST 12/06/2008

RAF Harrier jets have been called in to destroy the largest drugs seizure in history after Afghan police discovered hashish worth at least £200 million.

Two Harriers launched a strike on a huge cache of 260 tons of the drug, stuffed in sacks of grain and buried in trenches and underground bunkers in Kandahar province in southern Afghanistan.

The combat aircraft dropped 1,000lb bombs on the hiding place, which also included 2.5 tons of raw opium.

After the Harriers had delivered their payload, troops set the drugs ablaze. No previous haul comes close to matching this find, which weighed roughly the same as 30 double-decker buses....

I screwed up code on the 2nd article above, the link is here.

260 tons of marijuana

They don't mean grass like we would--they mean hash.

I saw a German guy walk out of Afghanistan in a pair of sandals that had a pound of hash in each sandal; When he got to the Persian side coming out of Isalam Kala, he watched the guard who was practically dissecting my workboots, and retired, like Michael Corleone in reverse, to stash his sandals on top of the ceiling level water tank.


Went through the inspection, returned to toilet, retrieved sandals.

More than 260 tons of marijuana was ... doused with petrol and set it alight....

That is just so wrong...

(It's hard not to visualize Cheech and Chong--BTW, Tommie Chong got a truly raw deal...)

Do you think the situation in Afghanistan is the result of turning security over to NATO, us diverting resources to Iraq, would have happened anyway, given the country?

Nothing has gone right in Afghanistan since the Brits split the Pashtuns into two sides of the Durant Line.

The Pashtuns (around 35 million!) are the world's largest single tribal grouping. I think it is fair to say that the presence in Pakistan of autonomous pashtun jurisdiction is fatal to any central government rule in an Afghanistan the geographical predicates of which include half but only half of the pashtuns.

That said, the Taliban could have been dispossessed from the drug trade by over bidding them and making medical morphine out of the local opium.

(There is always the impossibly sensible alternative of full on drug legalization, which is to say refusing to enforce the franchise for which the drug lords have spilled their own and others blood)

Certainly there would have been more chance for success if our special forces and cia assets had not been so early snatched out for redeployment to Iraq.

Yet and still, no one has made a success of occupyong Afghanistan and it's been tried by the best.

The terrain is unforgiving.

We are simpatico, I would have answered something similar.

I sometimes fantasize that creation of the nation of Pashtunistan is the key to solving a lot of problems. Let them alone to do it their way, proudly show what kinda wunnerful place they can create as a beacon to the rest of the Sunni world. See who wins that contest, Dubai or Pashtunistan. :-) It would be a little bit of helpful kick in the ass if, when the world agrees to such a state, they make it a condition that the women of such a state can freely cross the border for an alternative choice of citizenship in Pakistan or Iran, with a nice welfare check to get them started. (An Islamic version of Lysistrata might end up being written out of it.)

One thing I never got into researching is how the heck those federally adminstered tribal areas got created within Pakistan. The powers that be had no qualms about causing all kinds of horror dividing Muslim and Hindu, but no one would dare force the Pashtuns to submit fully to a state?

created... Pakistan

For another headscratcher:

P(unjabi)
A(fghani)
K(ashmiri)

istan...

You got it, the damn name of the country is a fuckin' acronym. A total construct from the word go.

Sarah Cheyes knows the wily Pashtun better than any westerner alive--check out the Bill Moyers interview on the PBS site from about three months
ago for a bit of local border color...

Consider further, that the state the suzerainty of which the British East India Company superceded was, in fact, Afghanistan, in the sense that the seat of the Mogul Empire was Balkh, and the Durant Line which (when drawn) separated the British Raj from the remaining territory of the Moghuls, is today the Afghan-Pakistan Border.

no one would dare force the Pashtuns to submit

The Siege of Malakand was the 26 July – 2 August 1897 siege of the British garrison in the Malakand region of modern day Pakistan's North West Frontier Province.[8] The British faced a force of Pashtun tribesmen whose tribal lands had been bisected by the Durand Line,[9] the 1,519 mile (2,445 km) border between Afghanistan and British India drawn up at the end of the Anglo-Afghan wars...The unrest caused by this division of the Pashtun lands led to the rise of Saidullah in Malakand. the small garrison at the camp of Malakand South and the small fort at Chakdara were both able to hold out for six days against the much larger Pashtun army... a relief column was sent... Accompanying this relief force was second lieutenant Winston Churchill, who later published his account as The Story of the Malakand Field Force: An Episode of Frontier War.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siege_of_Malakand

Wikipedia also has a bit on the creation of the FATA themselves, along the changes thereafter and how they work now:

Governance

The region is only nominally controlled by the central government of Pakistan. The mainly Pashtun tribes that inhabit the areas are fiercely independent but, until friction following the fall of the Taliban in neighbouring Afghanistan, the tribes had friendly relations with Pakistan's central government.[3] These Tribes are governed by the Frontier Crimes Regulation introduced under the British Raj. They are represented both in Pakistan's lower house and in its upper house of parliament. Previously, tribal candidates had no party affiliations and could contest as independents, because the Political Parties Act had not extended to the tribal areas. However, tribesmen were given right to vote in the 1997 general elections despite the absence of a Political Parties Act.

The head of each tribal Agency is the Political Agent...

But the words "Frontier Crimes Regulation" are not linked, so they don't have a page with more on that...saving googling it for another day.

"The deaths of Mullah Naqibullah, the longtime leader of the Alokozai tribe that populates Arghandab, and another senior commander, Abdul Hakim Jan, who was killed in a huge suicide bombing in February, have critically depleted the tribe, which has always fiercely opposed the Taliban."

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/17/world/asia/17afghan.html

Naqibulllah and Hakim Jan were Sarah Cheyes protectors in Kandahar. She has been running a botanical oil/soap stuff business and loving the Pashtuns for maybe four years.

Yup, Kandahar province, the joint is jumpin'.

Taliban Fighters Infiltrate Area Near Afghan City
By CARLOTTA GALL and ABDUL WAHEED WAFA 9:37 AM ET
Hundreds of Taliban fighters have swarmed into a strategically important district just outside Kandahar.

And to continue the cinematic imagery...

Old-Line Taliban Commander Is Face of Rising Afghan Threat
By CARLOTTA GALL
Published: June 17, 2008

...It was only weeks later, when Taliban militants put out a propaganda DVD, that the implications of the attack became clear. The DVD shows an enormous explosion, with shock waves rippling out far beyond the base. As a thick cloud of dust rises, the face of Maulavi Jalaluddin Haqqani, a Taliban commander who presents one of the biggest threats to NATO and United States forces, appears. He taunts his opponents and derides rumors of his demise

“Now as you see I am still alive,” he says....

I find continual irony in that a cultural movement that wants to go back to the days of the Caliphate is so invested in the ways of Hollywood action flicks (Bruce Willis in this particular case? :-)) in order to inspire and recruit. No one has beaten Osama and Khalid on that front yet, but they certainly are continuing their tradition.

The bomber in the March attack, for instance, turned out to be a German citizen of Turkish origin who was trained in Pakistan....The combined terrorist-insurgent networks have flourished from sanctuaries in Pakistan. In a sign of the increasing frustration of the president of Afghanistan, Hamid Karzai, with the challenges to his government, he threatened on Sunday to send Afghan troops into Pakistan to hit militant leaders who have vowed to continue a jihad in Afghanistan.....

I myself cannot get the cinematic image out of my mind of Karzai getting alone with Mullah Omar as a prisoner and not being able to hold himself back from strangling the old dude with his own hands.

P.S. My own cinematic imagery is of course the effects of Godfather Sopranos et. al. on my brain, as, yes I do know that Karzai is Pashtun. He is Pacino, with "them" dragging him back in...

Afghans See Pakistan Role in Karzai Plot

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/26/world/asia/26afghan.html

Post a Comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Book Club Calendar

Coming Soon



Nov. 30-Dec. 4



January 12-16



« Book Club ArchiveFull calendar »

Recent Reader Posts

All Reader Posts »





Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address