Reader Posts

« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »

The Case Against McCain

I know we’re still waiting for Hillary Clinton to come on board the Obama train, but for most Democrats, the time has come to look forward to the upcoming contest between Obama and McCain. I’ve had thoughts about what makes McCain weak – which is a lot of things – but I thought to ask the TPM readership their thoughts. What are the weaknesses of McCain that should be part of the debate?

I’m not looking for dirty, swift-boating politics, but real vulnerabilities.

I’ll start with a few I can think of right off:

1.       McCain’s stance as a maverick is old news. He has positioned himself solidly with Bush in the past few years on some of the most critical issues, in particular the war in Iraq and tax breaks for the rich.

2.       He claims he wants to clean up Washington, yet his own campaign is riddled with lobbyists. Even when he issues a directive to clean up his campaign members, he defends some of the worst of them. He comes off as a hypocrite and an opportunist.

3.       He seems to have a hard time keeping facts straight. This is not really surprising at his age, and though I’m not throwing age at him out of prejudice, he doesn’t seem as clear minded as he might have been before. This is a concern not only in his retention of facts, but makes it difficult to trust his judgment.

4.       He takes an anti-woman position on the abortion issue.

5.       He wants to stack the courts with more conservative ideologues.

6.       He has switched positions so often, and sometimes so rapidly, that even the Republicans who support him can’t be sure which McCain will actually show up. Such unreliability is different from being a maverick. It’s dangerous, especially when these switches do not seem to have been from further reflection, new information or real changes of heart, but more from shifting political winds or even just whim. So, really, he’s a live wire, a possible grenade who could blow up and do collateral damage to anyone, not just Democrats.

7.       To me, he’s less a war hero than a war victim. He’s admirable in his ability to overcome the horrors of his experiences in Vietnam, and for that I have great respect for him, but he’s no military genius. I’m sorry, but being a POW doesn’t train you to lead armies, navies and air forces. To me, the notion that he is better prepared to lead the military than someone who can think and listen to qualified advisors – actually listen instead of firing them for saying something he doesn’t like – is ludicrous.

His choice of VP will be interesting, and it may help him among some constituencies, but I’m guessing, based on the field of out-of-touch Republicans from which he will choose, that there will be further liabilities with his VP as well.

Anyway, I just wanted to start this off. I’m really interested in hearing from others what they think. I hope now that we’re all on the same side, and that anyone for McCain really is a Republican or Independent who believes in him and his message. I have no problem with that, but I’m very glad to be done with the primaries and on to something with a clearer distinction.


Comments (6)

The Keating Five scandal, part of the Savings & Loan crisis, shows even more poor judgment about associates than Obama's connections. The scandal mirrors his current coziness with institutions that invested heavily in sub-prime mortgages.

I just read a HuffPo article about Jim Webb, and this quote seemed incredibly relevant to item number 7:

John McCain's comment about Barack not having sat down recently with General Petreaus means nothing," Webb said. "If you know who to listen to, if you know how to make judgments, if you know how evaluate information, you can do that. I don't think Franklin Roosevelt was ever at the front in France during WWII in order to help end the war.

Nice point, Jim. And good comment, raider.

His health care plan is nothing if not avoidance of the American electorate's top continuing concern (after transient issues like the economy and Iraq). It offers no real coverage, only a system of tax credits that do nothing for those who pay less in taxes. This, I kid you not, is from his web site under "A Specific Plan of Action":

"GREATER ACCESS AND CONVENIENCE: Expanding Access To Health Care. Families place a high value on quickly getting simple care. Government should promote greater access through walk-in clinics in retail outlets."

Wal-Mart health care. That says it all.

All excellent points, Ripper. Thanks.

Great post. I agree with both the points about McCain and the need to move on to our real opponent. For the first time, a progressive America has blogs and new media to make their voices heard.

The one thing that is different this year is our ability to see past the Doublespeak.

I think it's been a slowly evolved skill, and one long overdue for a disinterested and misinformed electorate. With all the marvelous technical tools at our disposal, Barack has the opportunity to completely change the electoral landscape as well as the landscape in Washington with a newly revived progressive majority. If we do this thing right, the chance exists for the type of Renaissance this country hasn't seen in 40 years.

I don't believe McCain has anything nearly as attractive as that to offer to the American people.

Post a Comment

Advertisement
Please disable your adblocker!
Ads are how we pay the bills!

Subscribe

The Coffee House
TPMCafe's regulars

House Brew
From Your Cafe Editor

Special Guests
Big names and big brains

Special Features
Pressing topics and trends

Table for One
An expert's week-long talk.

All Reader Posts
TPM readers discuss.

Book Club Calendar

Coming Soon



Nov. 30-Dec. 4



January 12-16



« Book Club ArchiveFull calendar »

Recent Reader Posts

All Reader Posts »





Masthead

Editor-in-Chief
Josh Marshall



Subscribe to TPMCafe's feed.
Subscribe to TPMCafe's reader blog feed.

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address