« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »
Decision Time...In The Real World
You're not--like me--a carefree TPM blogger.
You're the Prez or PM of a nation.
An enemy has in its possession the bodies of 2 of your nation's soldiers who were kidnapped several years ago in a cross-border raid.
Your nation has under incarceration several convicts whom your enemy wants returned.
One of those prisoners committed the following crime in 1979: He entered by force the home of a civilian in your country; he shot dead the "man" of the house in front of his 4-year-old daughter; as the daughter cried in terror, the prisoner seized her, put her head against a rock in the garden outside and crushed her skull against it with the butt of his rifle, killing her; during the course of this attack, the wife and mother of the victims hid in another room with her 2-year-old child; trying to keep the child silent, the mother smothered her own child to death.
Do you make the deal?
This is not a fictional account; this decision had to be made by real people within the last few days.
The inane posts and blogs here at TPM, so trivial in content, and frequently so distant from what the world is really like for national leaders, prompted me to write this.
MyBlog: http://ProteanPerspectives.blogspot.com












Comments (6)
"We will not trade arms for hostages"
"We will not talk to our enemies"
Is that real world enough for you?
June 29, 2008 9:18 PM | Reply | Permalink
HUH?
June 29, 2008 9:30 PM | Reply | Permalink
Thanks for bringing this up to the top of the heap. I have to admit that I don't get this trade. Maybe if they got back that one soldier (still alive) being held in Gaza (and then just maybe) ... but to give up everything they are for the remains of two soldiers just astounds me. I have to figure there's more here that we are not hearing about because it doesn't make a lick of sense to me.
June 29, 2008 10:05 PM | Reply | Permalink
chophouse,
I can't figure it out either...but that's why I'm blogging on TPM and not the PM of Israel, I suppose.
FB
June 29, 2008 10:09 PM | Reply | Permalink
For some religions, the trade would be worthwhile. It puts me in mind of the "funeral games" segment of the Iliad, when King Priam was so desperate to get his son Hector's body back so that Hector could continue on to the afterlife.
If I'm the Prez or PM of a relatively non-religious country, or at least one w/a separation of Church and State, no way do I make the trade. A criminal can commit more crimes and thus remains dangerous; a body is the shell of someone who has already passed. Also, this feels like a reward to someone who killed my soldiers.
If not, it becomes a lot more complicated....
June 30, 2008 2:25 AM | Reply | Permalink
It's our country's committment to bring our soldiers home. I see your points, but have to ask - if the remains were of YOUR child, would you feel the same?
June 30, 2008 2:29 AM | Reply | Permalink
Post a Comment