« previous | TPM CAFÉ READER POSTS HOME | next »
Belated Praise for Hillary's Outstanding Speech
Yesterday I had commitments that prevented my hearing Senator Clinton's speech live. When I finally heard it, I was overjoyed. Senator Clinton pulled off something I thought nearly impossible after Tuesday night - a convincing message to unify the Democratic Party for all the right reasons.
Hillary Clinton was once again the candidate I originally supported, but she was much more. She was truly eloquent and inspirational. I think it's ungenerous to quibble over technicalities such as whether she used first person singular too often. Her message did not come over as self-serving - quite the opposite. The only negative feeling I experienced was regret at the absence of this inspiring, eloquent Hillary Clinton during the long painful months of this presidential campaign.
It's impossible to comprehend why such an attractive candidate has been hidden from public view. I can only speculate that the candidate I admired yesterday fell victim to advice from a cabal of veteran male advisers - geniuses like Mark Penn, Harold Ickes, and Bill Clinton. The Hillary Clinton who spoke yesterday was fully capable of competing with Obama by offering a positive alternative. The strategy that attacked Obama's eloquence as empty and worthless deprived Hillary of a powerful tool - her own eloquence. The decision to dismiss Obama's inspirational message, and inspiration itself - as an infantile wish to see solutions fall from the sky - deprived her of her own inspirational voice. The decision to concede younger generations and African Americans to Obama and to court other demographic groups based on resentment was not only harmful to the Democratic Party, it was nothing less than tragic for Senator Clinton. She could have competed with Obama in his areas of strength, retained her advantage among women, and offered greater experience as well. She could have won, rallied universal Democratic support, and left an undamaged Obama with a bright future. Obama's most ardent followers would have been disappointed but strongly committed to electing Hillary Clinton president.
The election could have played out as what we originally thought it was - a difficult choice from a roster of outstanding Democratic candidates, but a choice certain to produce the next Democratic president after eight catastrophic years of incompetent and malicious Republican rule. We are now at a more challenging pass, but there is much greater hope today than 48 hours ago.
With respect to this campaign, there is little point in speculating about whether the real Hillary is the eloquent, inspirational woman we saw rallying the party yesterday or the mean-spirited candidate who seemed to feel no compunction about antagonizing millions of Democrats for the slightest chance of improving her own chances at the nomination. I hope the former is the true Hillary and the latter an illusion conjured by a band of idiots who hijacked her campaign.
In either case, few politicians could redeem themselves after waging a divide-and-denigrate campaign like the one so skillfully designed and implemented under Penn, Ickes and company. Nevertheless, in my view, redemption is exactly what Hillary pulled off yesterday. Against all odds, she redeemed herself along with Democratic hopes. Whatever motives are the true definition of her own heart, the Hillary Clinton who spoke yesterday proved herself a candidate who could have won the nomination and the White House on her own strengths. If that Hillary Clinton had taken the podium from January until June, she would have won.
Looking to the future, if we see that Hillary Clinton throughout this fall's campaign and in years to come, we may yet live to see the inauguration of President Hillary Rodham Clinton.











Comments (11)
Hello Lifelongdem,
Great post. Just terrific. Highly rec'd!
June 8, 2008 1:14 PM | Reply | Permalink
For what it's worth, we should remember that so far, what Hillary has done is "just words" (ironic, isn't it?)
The next step is to deal with this mess:
http://www.gop.com/clintonvsobama/
The speech she gave was for her core demographic. The next speech she gives needs to be for the Democratic core.
My fingers are crossed....
June 8, 2008 1:16 PM | Reply | Permalink
We may yet live to see the inauguration of President Hillary Rodham Clinton.
You gotta be kiddin?
June 8, 2008 1:21 PM | Reply | Permalink
I'm not kidding, Kash. She's clearly an extremely gifted politician. We don't know what the future holds.
To win the Democratic nomination on any future scenario, she will have to do one of two things: a) convince Democrats like me that she truly is what she seemed to be yesterday or b) maintain a long-term bravura performance that continues to dupe innocents like me. I'm not stupid enough to ignore it if the selfish, ruthless Hillary goes public again.
I do think this is a moment for generosity of spirit, not sarcasm, regardless of personal feelings on this. This is true both for reasons of common courtesy and, if that holds no charms for you, political expediency. Mean-spiritedness by Obama supporters toward Hillary after yesterday's speech is a great way to start an exodus from the Democratic Party.
There's no harm in implying I'm a fool for responding to yesterday's speech as I did - I'm an Obama supporter. But trashing Hillary directly or by implication will infuriate Hillary's followers and hurt Obama's chances. Which faction of the party does that help? What's the point?
If your point is that Hillary will never have another chance because Obama will serve two terms as president and time will pass her by, I think that's far from clear. The next president will have to govern a country with problems as severe as at any time since the Great Depression. Millions of people need help and yet the national debt is part of the problem. Entrenched interests in oil and healthcare remain powerful. Whoever is elected this time around has a better than 50-50 chance of being voted out after one term, perhaps for simply trying to do what is best for the country.
On reflection, there is a third possibility for Hillary's future that can't be ruled out: perhaps the selfish, ruthless Hillary this time around was the real thing, but Hillary is capable of learning and change.
For now, give her a break.
June 8, 2008 2:16 PM | Reply | Permalink
"Nevertheless, in my view, redemption is exactly what Hillary pulled off yesterday. Against all odds, she redeemed herself along with Democratic hopes."
If I can offer a slight edit:
""Nevertheless, in my view, redemption is exactly what Hillary yesterday. Against all odds, she herself along with Democratic hopes."
My biggest concern, right now, is the Hillary that went from "I'm so honored" to "shame on you" to "celestial choirs" in the space of three days. I agree her campaign was badly mismanaged, primarily by others, but she's responsible for what comes out of her mouth and the expressions on her face.
What she does and says in the coming months is going to determine whether yesterday was an unveiling of the real Hillary Clinton and a redemption ... or .... another well-played role. Like you, I was tremendously impressed and felt she was, at last, truly authentic, so I'm hopeful. I'm even very grateful even if it was only another momentary blip (well-chosen moment). But only she will control what happens next.
June 8, 2008 1:32 PM | Reply | Permalink
Yet another comparison to Nixon: "the New Hillary"
;-)
June 8, 2008 1:41 PM | Reply | Permalink
I agree Hillary's speech could have been a bravura performance successfully concealing a typical ruthless, devious politician. That is not the feeling I got.
As you say, the coming months will show which Hillary is real. I hope my feeling is correct that the Hillary who from deep moral conviction sincerely values universal healthcare is the prevailing spirit, not a Hillary for whom all issues are simply tools for gaining personal power. If the latter is the case, she is just a typical politician, like thousands of male politicians before her, but happens to be a woman and happens to be particularly good at it. We will have to watch what she does. Based on yesterday's speech, I think we should give her the benefit of the doubt.
June 8, 2008 1:46 PM | Reply | Permalink
Oh, dear --- Note to self: don't put anything in brackts. It disappears. Here's the proposed edit:
""Nevertheless, in my view, redemption is exactly what Hillary MADE A GREAT FIRST STEP TOWARD yesterday. Against all odds, she BEGAN TO REDEEM herself along with Democratic hopes."
June 8, 2008 5:52 PM | Reply | Permalink
Hillary gave a good speech because as been noted it's about money. She wants her debt paid off. We'll see if that happens since her supporters didn't put their money where their mouf is.
Don't think that your praise of Hillary is felt through motivation for Democratic principles. She made real sure that the effort would "pay off".
June 8, 2008 3:08 PM | Reply | Permalink
Quasar,
You make a very good point:
All those millions of voters, so devoted to her that can't bring themselves to vote for Obama...
They did not put their money where their mouth was!
June 8, 2008 3:36 PM | Reply | Permalink
Hillary still has a boatload of work to do for the Democratic Party and for Obama.
The webpage linked below gives just one small example of the damage she's done and that we have to deal with now ... and it's just from the GOP, NOT the 527's.
http://www.gop.com/clintonvsobama/
June 8, 2008 5:21 PM | Reply | Permalink
Post a Comment